On the Responsibility Mechanism of Administrative Environment Law

Liu Zhi-jian

2007-01-01

Abstract:Legal responsibility is the embodiment of the compulsory nature of law and the basis for its implemen- tation,but the vacancy of responsibility in environment protection law in China leads to the laxity of the law.The paper proposes six suggestions as to how this vacancy can be filled in order to render the environment protection law effective.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Legal Liability of Violation of Obligation on Administrative Law: Between Administrative Punishment and Penalty——Analysis on Article 7 (2) of Administrative Punishment Law

ZHANG Jian-sheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-0078.2011.02.002

2011-01-01

Administrative law review

Abstract:When an act,which violates the obligation on administrative law but undertakes the penalty result,fits in with the constitutive requirements of both administrative punishment and penalty,it should be defined into only one category according to different determinant and application,i.e.circumstances,result,condition,quantity,subject,etc.Meanwhile,as for the procedure,basing on the two opposite models of 'Administrative Punishment → Penalty' and 'Penalty → Administrative Punishment',the essential content of current relevant regulations should be interpreted from the aspects of initiating requisites,running steps and the procedural effects,in order to reveal the legal framework of the cohesion part in the two procedures.
Reflection on Administrative Litigation System under the Concept of "people Oriented"

ZHANG Jian-sheng

2010-01-01

Abstract:Even if the administrative litigation system is not perfect, it is still a strategy selected in the system, by administrative counterparts struggling for their rights. In front of the administrative counterparts who struggle their rights, the difficulties of agency managing social affair have become increasingly prominent. The court, hardly guaranteed the independence in the litigation relationship, often trapped in a kind of embarrassing situations where it cannot help itself. This issue requires us to reflect on the administrative litigation system under the concept of people-oriented idea, so that a good way solving the problem can be found.
The Basic Modification Direction of The Administrative Procedure Law——Discussing Article 1 of The Administrative Procedure Law

Zhang Jian-sheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.19563/j.cnki.sdzs.2012.01.008

2012-01-01

Abstract:The Article 1 of The Administrative Procedure Law,as the"soul article"of its legislative purpose,is a barricade when involving modification of The Administrative Procedure Law.The understanding of Article 1 of The Administrative Procedure Law mainly includes the following three different views as claim of protecting rights,claim of maintaining supervision and equilibrium theory.Based on the analysis of these three kinds of views,right relief should be the legislative purpose of administrative lawsuit.So,the modification of The Administrative Procedure Law should abide by the principles such as effectiveness,rights protection and non-loophole rights protection.
Government's Environmental Responsibility and the Modification of the Environmental Protection Law

Qian Shui-miao

2008-01-01

Abstract:The imperfection of the government environmental responsibility is a key reason of the deficiency of the environmental law's effectiveness.The modification of The Environmental Protection Law should strengthen the government's environmental responsibility to change this current situation.According to the concept of government's responsibility,this paper analyzes the importance of the government's environmental responsibility and introduces the legislation experiences of United States,Japan and Russia.Owing to our nation's conditions,The Environmental Protection Law should set down the government's environmental responsibility on both positive and negative levels.The paper also makes the positive government's environmental responsibility as the emphasis.The provision of the environmental public products(services),the performance of environmental impact assessment in making each government decision and the publication of environmental information are involved in this system.
A Brief Study on How to Perfect the System of Civil Liability Caused by Environmental Pollution

Zhang Yan

Abstract:In China,the primary legal basis of environmental pollution infringement liability spread among the General Principles of the Civil Law,environmental basic laws and environmental specialized laws.In contrast to environmental pollution infringement liability system in developed countries, the defects of current environmental pollution infringement liability system in China are obvious.The author suggests that the system can be improved in the following ways: cutting out the regulations that environmental pollution infringement should be based on lawbreaking;broadening the scale of compensation for damages appropriately;setting up the rules of burden of proof inversion and cause-effect relationship presumption;detailing the composition and modes of infringement elimination;adopting liability insurance and damage compensation system;granting the victim rights of advisory and request for liability examination,and perfecting administrative mediation system and arbitration system.

Law,Environmental Science,Business
Strengthen the government's environmental responsibility——a view of the modification of the environmental protection law

Qian Shuimiao,Shen Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-3865.2008.03.022

2008-01-01

Abstract:The imperfection of the government's environmental responsibility is a key reason for the deficiency of the environmental law's effectiveness.The modification of the Environmental Protection Law can strengthen the government's environmental responsibility to change the current situation.In lieu of the concept of the government's responsibility,the writers gave the connotation of the government's environmental responsibility into a positive level and a negative level,analyzed the importance of the government's environmental responsibility and also introduced the legal status of United States,Japan and Russia.According to Chinese social and moral conditions,the Environmental Protection Law should set in both positive and negative levels of environmental responsibility for the government.This paper's emphasis makes the positive environmental responsibility a part of the government's legal system.This includes a provision for environmental public products(services),performance of the environmental impact assessment in different decision making processes and opens environmental information to the public.
The Administrative Accountability System: How Do the Regulations Behave?

ZHANG Zi-tai,XIA Ling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-0169.2006.06.003

2006-01-01

Abstract:The head of the Chinese EPA resigned for the event of Songhua River pollution,and this is a reflection of the administrative accountability system.But the officials are public servants,and the punishments to them should be enforced under the law.The administrative accountability system in The Public Servant Law falls into two: resign to take a blame and resign in charge,but there is lack of rules of procedure.To protect the rights of public servants,rules of procedure should be regulated in the administrative accountability system.
On the Dilemma and Outlet of the Environmental Civil Litigation in China

Tao Lei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-4970.2009.04.017

2009-01-01

Abstract:Environmental civil litigation,as an important mechanism of settling disputes in modern society ruled by law,plays a significant role in defending citizens' legal rights and stabilizing social order.Nowadays,environmental civil litigation in China has been caught in a dilemma.On the one hand,the economic strength and information of the litigants in the environmental civil litigation are imbalanced and the plaintiff is unwilling or unable to take legal proceedings against the defendant.On the other hand,the judiciary is unwilling or unable to hear an environmental civil case.And furthermore,some local governments have not attached enough importance to environmental civil litigation and even covertly and overtly interfere with it.The development of environmental civil litigation in China requires that people from all walks of life make joint efforts,which mainly depends on the juridical initiative bringing into play and the juridical independence becoming into reality.
An empirical examination of liability for ecological environment restoration in the context of the Civil Code of China

Fei Song,Kang Zhang,Baozhen Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e31240

IF: 3.776

2024-06-01

Heliyon

Abstract:In environmental tort lawsuits, China has been overly focused on “punishing” violators and has neglected the value of ecological environment restoration. The Article 1234 of Civil Code of China in 2021 has provided an important institutional guideline for the restoration of ecological environment and sustainable development in China. This paper analyzes 512 cases of ecological environment restoration liability and identifies five challenges in the judicial context: the lack of sound legal regulation, the lack of liability allocation, the mismatch of liability subjects, the difficulty of identifying damage facts, and the difficulty of effective implementation of restoration. In the face of these difficulties, countries that attach importance to ecological environment restoration, such as the United States, Germany and Japan, have provided experience that can be drawn on for China's ecological environment restoration liability. Based on foreign experience, China's liability for ecological environment restoration should be improved in the following aspects: first, to improve the legal system from basic laws and specific laws; second, to expand the scope of subjects from both litigation request subjects and liability subjects; third, to improve the identification and assessment mechanism and innovate the identification and assessment procedures in accordance with China's national conditions; fourth, to determine the restoration methods based on the criterion of “utilization value and the differences in the objects. The ultimate goal is to help China's Civil Code to be better applied judicially on the one hand, and to contribute to the world ecological protection on the other.
Effective Connection between Criminal Law and Administrative Law Protection in Environmental Crimes

Chen Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/0ss9vy59

2024-09-18

International Journal of Education and Humanities

Abstract:With the increasing emphasis on ecological environment protection, it has become a consensus of the whole society to use the strictest system and the most rigorous rule of law to protect the ecological environment. Due to its unique severity and deterrence, criminal law is becoming a trend to construct and improve protection for environmental crimes through criminal law. Many countries in the world have environmental crimes in their criminal codes or subsidiary criminal laws, and China is no exception. However, criminal law always relies on administrative law in regulating environmental crimes, and seeking a balance between the application of criminal law and administrative law in order to maximize the environmental protection and punishment functions of criminal law is an urgent problem that needs to be solved. The article analyzes and studies the basic theory of environmental crime and its administrative attributes, pointing out the appropriate mechanism for criminal law intervention in environmental protection, in order to achieve effective connection between administrative law and criminal law in environmental protection issues.
Finding Structural Imbalance: A Theoretical Explanation to the Failure of China's Environmental Regulations

WU Wei-xing

2013-01-01

Abstract:What explains the failure of China's environmental regulation is the structural imbalance of three types: the imbalance in environmental decision-making and litigation between such parties as the public and the businesses,the imbalance in law enforcement between such parties as authorities in charge of environmental protection,local governments and the authorities in charge of economic production;and the imbalance in the game between such interests as of environment and of economy.A solution to the imbalance of these types may be found in the structural reform of China's environmental act in the following respects: to establish an institution in which representatives on behalf of the public may monitor the environment for the public good,to strengthen the accountability in the administrative system,especially in the governments of all levels,and to bring into reality a practice in which assessed compensation and reparation will be made to make up any damage caused by environmental pollution.
The Establishment of Restoration-based Liability Regime for Damage to Environment in China

Zhang Tianzhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-6252.2012.04.002

2012-01-01

Abstract:It is in urgent need for China to establish a liability regime for damage to environment due to pollution incidents. This article begins with an analysis of three strategic components to coordinate the relationship between human society and the environmental system according to a process chain from human activities to environment. Subsequently, the paper discusses the environmental restoration implication of liability for damage to environment after identifying the problems marked by the overall lack of compensation liability for damage to environment in China. Finally, the paper proposes a pilot scheme as priority to develop the liability regime for injury to environment, which focuses the cases of environmental damage related to the pollution incident and is based on the clean up action of current environmental emergency system. The establishment of environmental damage liability will be helpful for strengthening pollution emergency system and environmental damage management in China.
A Re-Examination of the Function and Role of Administrative Lawsuit

JIANG Ming-an

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-7504.2011.01.019

2011-01-01

Abstract:At present,China is in a period when all kinds of social problems and contradictions happen more easily and frequently.There are two ways of thinking to tackle these problems: one is to use the rule-by man mode of thinking and method such as a combination of oppressing and pacifying;the other is to adopt law to administrate,tackle problems,supervise and relieve the stress.The importance of administrative law should be re-examined if we want to tackle the contradiction and problems in economic development of the society with legal mode of thinking and method.The most important function and role of administrative law is to tackle problems,supervise and relieve the stress.To realize all these and coordinate the relation between administrative lawsuit and reform,development and stability,a rule-by-law concept should be established to balance and tackle the contradiction,supervise and relieve the stress.
Establishment of the Environmental Infringement Lability Insurance in China

Zhang Zitai

2006-01-01

Abstract:The idea of socialization of responsibility is a positive reaction to the development of modern so- ciety by modern legal science. Environmental infringement liability insurance is a specific application of the socialization of responsibility in the issue of compensation incurred by environmental infringement. It bases on the liability insurance contract between the policy-holder and the insurer about environmental infringement, requesting the insurer to pay the victims certain sum of money when happening some cer- tain liabilities of environmental infringement. Current China has seen serious contradictions in its system of environmental dispute settlement, especially on the issue of the redress of victims. The establishment of environmental infringement liability insurance under the theory of socialization of responsibility could be a practical way to solve these problems.
Responsibility and Amends System on China's Real Estate Register--Study on Greffier Examination and Appointment System and Register Responsibility System

YU Zhen-guo,WU Ci-fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-9107.2005.06.019

2005-01-01

Abstract:The main problem of China's responsibility system for real estate register is that the making building of the greffiers is rather laggard,and there is short of explicit responsibility and amends system,so that the register quality and public confidence for the register is low.To solve this problem,this paper puts forward that strict qualification admittance system,examination and appointment system,register responsibility system,and amends system should be implemented in China's real estate register agencies,as well as the qualification training and examination system for practitioner,promotion assessing system for four levels of greffiers,and instauration of compensation fund,register liability insurance and claim system for compensation.
On Perfection of China's Legislations of Environmental Management of Chemicals

WU Weixing

2013-01-01

Abstract:Environmental management of chemicals is the weak link in China's environmental management.The current rank of China's chemical legislation is low,with its system being complicated.There is an urgent need to enact a Basic Law of Chemicals by the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress to strengthen the environmental management of chemicals.In the Basic Law,we should strengthen the environmental management of existing chemicals,establish or improve the systems of chemical environmental voluntary agreements,registration of pollutant release and transfer,as well as the mandatory insurance of environmental pollution.
To Establish a Liability Insurance System on Environmental Tort in China

Li Hua

2006-01-01

Abstract:With further development of the market economy and rapid industrialization in China,environ- mental pollution and deterioration have increasingly become major social problems that are affecting the eco- nomic growth significantly. To establish related insurance systems,it is needed to resolve the environmental tort and reduce damages caused by environmental pollution. It has become a main issue concerned by scholars in the field of environmental laws. The environmental liability insurance is based on the theories of tort law and liability insurance. Choices of patterns of the liability insurance on the environmental tort under state interven- tion were explored. Based on discussions,the establishment of a dualistic liability insurance system on the environmental tort was further demonstrated.
Traps in Structure and the Unbearable Heaviness of Chinese Environmental Law: With a Discussion on the Amendment of Environmental Protection Act

ZHANG Zi-tai,GUO Shao-qing

2013-01-01

Abstract:At a critical point of amending China's environmental protection act,we find it not enough to amendment this act only as an independent law.The enforcement of Chinese environmental law is hampered by the traps in such independent structures as energy consumption,industry,regions,town and country,and social power,which lead to the law making of a disconnected "centering-on-so-and-so" type,thus worsening the situation.It is evident that parochialism in law making concerning environmental protection prevents the environmental act from achieving what it has been expected to achieve.To break through,the Chinese environmental law must be codified,and put into a wider perspective in its making.
Responsibility Government:the Claim of Ages:Analyse on the Problem of Blurry Administration Responsibility in Contemporary China

LONG Yue,HE Xiao-Qian,WU Zhi-xiang

2006-01-01

Abstract:Nowadays,the responsibility government has already become an important symbol of the politics and democracy nation.The government of China has some problems that its administrative responsibility is not clear.Therefore,this paper makes the simple comment for its various performances and endangering and tries to analyze the reasons,which will be of practical significance for building the responsibility government.
Factors Affecting the Operation of China's Environmental Protection Law:an Analysis of the Governing Impacts on the Implementation of Environmental Protection Law

Jin WANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13806/j.cnki.issn1008-7095.2012.01.007

2012-01-01

Abstract:Although the implementation of environmental protection law has been increasingly strengthened in the last thirty years,China's environment is still deteriorating.Through an analysis of the inner factors affecting of the implementation of China's environmental law,this it is found that the current problem for environmental legislation is that environmental protection laws and regulations have no major mistakes,nor any major impact;the basic administrative factor affecting the implementation of environmental protection law is that the enforcement power of environmental protection departments and sectors is subject to and bounded by local governmental economic authorities and the unified environmental regulatory regime;and the judicial factor affecting the implementation of environmental protection law is that the courts have provided neither enough support for environmental law enforcement nor sufficient remedies for enviromental pollution victims.These problems is closely related to the external governing factor which is supposed to provide guarantee and protection for the implementation of environmental protection law,i.e.the Party's governance capability,and its arrangements of the public authority operating institutions and mechanisms of public authority.

On the Responsibility Mechanism of Administrative Environment Law

Legal Liability of Violation of Obligation on Administrative Law: Between Administrative Punishment and Penalty——Analysis on Article 7 (2) of Administrative Punishment Law

Reflection on Administrative Litigation System under the Concept of "people Oriented"

The Basic Modification Direction of The Administrative Procedure Law——Discussing Article 1 of The Administrative Procedure Law

Government's Environmental Responsibility and the Modification of the Environmental Protection Law

A Brief Study on How to Perfect the System of Civil Liability Caused by Environmental Pollution

Strengthen the government's environmental responsibility——a view of the modification of the environmental protection law

The Administrative Accountability System: How Do the Regulations Behave?

On the Dilemma and Outlet of the Environmental Civil Litigation in China

An empirical examination of liability for ecological environment restoration in the context of the Civil Code of China

Effective Connection between Criminal Law and Administrative Law Protection in Environmental Crimes

Finding Structural Imbalance: A Theoretical Explanation to the Failure of China's Environmental Regulations

The Establishment of Restoration-based Liability Regime for Damage to Environment in China

A Re-Examination of the Function and Role of Administrative Lawsuit

Establishment of the Environmental Infringement Lability Insurance in China

Responsibility and Amends System on China's Real Estate Register--Study on Greffier Examination and Appointment System and Register Responsibility System

On Perfection of China's Legislations of Environmental Management of Chemicals

To Establish a Liability Insurance System on Environmental Tort in China

Traps in Structure and the Unbearable Heaviness of Chinese Environmental Law: With a Discussion on the Amendment of Environmental Protection Act

Responsibility Government:the Claim of Ages:Analyse on the Problem of Blurry Administration Responsibility in Contemporary China

Factors Affecting the Operation of China's Environmental Protection Law:an Analysis of the Governing Impacts on the Implementation of Environmental Protection Law