Abstract:This paper addresses an important extension of the circle packing problem (CPP), the circle packing problem with equilibrium constraints (CPPEC). It considers the dense packing of n circular disks in a large circular container at the same time satisfying the equilibrium constraints. Under the industrial background of the layout design on satellite modules, this NP-hard global optimization problem is important in both theory and practice. We introduce two new quasi-physical models for solving CPPEC in this paper. One is to mimic the elastic movement driven by repelling forces from extruded disks, the other is to simulate a whole translation movement of the disks driven by a pulling force from an imaginative elastic rope connecting the centroid of the disks and the center of the container. Then, inspired by the coarse-to-fine control strategy in the manufacture industry, we propose a coarse-to-fine quasi-physical (CFQP) optimization method that adopts the two quasi-physical models for the quasi-physical descent procedure and combines a basin hopping with tabu method for the search procedure. In this way, not only could CFQP take into account the diversity of the search space to facilitate the global search, but it also does fine search to find the corresponding local minimum in a promising local area. Experiments were on two sets of 11 representative test instances. Computational results showed that CFQP achieved new and better results on four instances, at the same time it matched the current best records on the other six (accurate to 0.0001). Moreover, CFQP resulted in smaller equilibrium deviations than that of others published in the literature. In addition, we generated 34 new CPPEC instances basing on the CPP benchmarks, and provided computational results on the two sets of 34 new CPPEC instances, and the container radii obtained are close to the published results on CPP.

Local Search Based on a Physical Model for Solving a Circle Packing Problem

A Fast Local Search Algorithm for Solving Circles Packing Problem with Constraints of Equilibrium

Neighborhood search algorithm associated with Quasi-physicalmethod for solving unequal circle Packing problem

Extremal Optimization with Local Search for the Circular Packing Problem

An improved algorithm for the packing of unequal circles within a larger containing circle

An Efficient Algorithm for Solving the Arbitrary Sized Circle Packing Problem

A Two-Level Search Strategy For Packing Unequal Circles Into A Circle Container

Quasi-physical global optimization method for solving the equal circle packing problem

Perturbation-based Approach for Solving Arbitrary Sized Circle Packing Problem

Tabu Search Algorithm Combined with Global Perturbation for Packing Arbitrary Sized Circles into a Circular Container

A Simulated Annealing Algorithm For The Circles Packing Problem

Global optimization method for finding dense packings of equal circles in a circle

Adaptive large neighborhood search for solving the circle bin packing problem

Note on: an improved algorithm for the packing of unequal circles within a larger containing circle

A coarse-to-fine quasi-physical optimization method for solving the circle packing problem with equilibrium constraints

Solution-Hashing Search Based on Layout-Graph Transformation for Unequal Circle Packing

Discretization-Based Solution Approaches for the Circle Packing Problem

Using Iterated Local Search for Efficiently Packing Unequal Disks in a Larger Circle

Finite Circumcircle Based Packing Optimization of Arbitrarily Shaped Components

Greedy vacancy search algorithm for packing equal circles in a square