Understanding the Paradox of Insurance Demand: Evi-dence from China’s Auto Insurance Market

Wang Jun,Gao Feng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2008.05.008
2008-01-01
Abstract:Insurance demand is one of the most important theoreti-cal issues in insurance research, and related empirical studies are an active and fruitful field. The classic model of insurance demand was developed by Mossin (1968), who showed that insurance products are an inferior good for individuals with decreasing absolute risk aversion; that is, insurance demand decreases as the wealth level increases. However, this model is not consistent with the observed behavior in the insurance market because the wealthy tend to buy more insurance. One of the most important assumptions in Mos-sin's model is that the loss severity is independent of wealth. In this article, we extend the Mossin model by relaxing this assumption. We consider the possibility that the loss severity may depend on the level of wealth to resolve the apparent inconsistency of increased insurance purchase by the wealthy. We show that insurance demand may increase with the level of wealth if the loss severity is pro-portional to the wealth level. We empirically test the model using data from the domestic auto insurance market. We investigate the relationship between the insurance amount or claim amount and the policyholder's wealth level in an ordinary linear regression model, and investigate the relationship between insurance coverage and the wealth level in a Probit model. It is shown that the policyholder's wealth level is significantly positively correlated with his insurance amount, insurance coverage and claim amount, which is consistent with our model predictions. Despite the fact that the model proposed in this paper provides a reasonable explanation of the empirical findings regarding insurance demand, we are aware that there could be other explanations, such as the existence of background risks or the irrationality of policyholders, which we leave for future studies.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?