The evaluation of different surgeries on femoral intertrochanteric fracture in elderly patients
陈述祥,刘彦,陈丽君
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-9965.2014.02.013
2014-01-01
Abstract:Aim:To compare the clinical efficacy of extramedullary fixation system,intramedullary fix-ation system and hemi-hip arthroplasty in treatment of intertrochanteric fractures in the elderly.Meth-ods:A retrospective study of 220 cases of femoral intertrochanteric fracture were assigned to dynamic hip screw(DHS)group(82 cases),proximal femoral nail antirotation(PFNA)group(68 cases),hemi-hip ar-throplasty(HHA)group (70 cases).There were 92 males and 128 females,at age range of 70 ~101 years,mean 79.8 years.According to the modification Evan classification,the fracture included typeⅠin 22,type Ⅱ in 51,type Ⅲ in 78,type Ⅳ in 44,type Ⅴ in 20,type R in 5.The Preoperative conditions, postoperative function and complications,operativing time,bleeding during the operation,postoperative full weight-bearing time,fracture healing time were comparatively studied among the three groups.Results:All cases were followed up for 8~24 months,average 13 months.All patients obtained a satisfactory effect and there were no significant differences(P>0.05 )regarding the excellent and good rate,gender,age, fracture types and medical complications,the mean operativing time and blood loss:there were significant differences between the PFNA group,DHS group and HHA group;there were significant differences be-tween the PFNA group,DHS group(P<0.05 ).The operativing time of PFNA group is the shortest,bleed-ing loss is the least.HHA group had the longest operativing time and the most bleeding loss.DHS group is the medium.The mean walking time and completely loading time,PFNA group A took the least time than HHA group and DHS group,there are significant differences (P<0.05 ),union time:there are no signifi-cances between the PFNA group,the DHS group.Postoperative complications were found in 29 cases (13.2%).Harris score was highest in the HHA group,with satisfactory significances in comparison with the other two groups.Conclusion:Three kinds of treatment are effective for the elderly patients with femo-ral intertrochanteric fracture.We should take the patients age,body condition,osteoporosis,fracture type into account and choose a reasonable operation method to achieve a satisfactory clinical effect.Intramedul-lary fixation should be the treatment of choice for the patients with unstable,or severe osteoporosis frac-tures and with intolerance of HHA.HHA is suitable for the elderly patients with unstable or severe osteo-porosis fractures,capability of walk or tolerance of operation,DHS is also suitable for the patients with sta-ble or no severe osteoporosis fractures,good body condition.