Analysis of false negative in malignant liver tumor biopsies―importance of contrast-enhanced ultrasound

WU Wei,CHEN Min-hua,YAN Kun,YIN Shan,DAI Ying,FAN Zhi-hui,YANG Wei,LI Ji-you
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-6448.2006.03.008
2006-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the clinical utility of contrast-enhanced ultrasound in percutaneous liver biopsies of malignant liver lesions. Methods Two hundred and eighty-seven patients with 342 unconfirmed focal liver lesions underwent percutaneous liver biopsy guided by ultrasound. Two hundred and three cases with 238 lesions were diagnosed as malignant, and 84 cases with 104 lesions were not found malignant. In 22 cases malignancy could not be excluded clinically due to the results from tumor markers, CT, MRI or angiography. They were analyzed in this study. We performed CEUS prior to the repeated biopsies in order to better localize the biopsy site. Among them, there were 15 males and 7 females, age 35~76 years (mean 53.4 years). Biopsy was performed using a 21~18 gauge manual aspiration needle or automatic cutting needle. The specimens were examined for histologic and cytologic analysis by 2 experienced pathologists. The specimen which was satisfied for histologic and cytologic examination was considered successful. Results The average puncture procedures in 22 cases was 1.7 (38/22) and the successful rate was 100%, 21 cases were diagnosed as malignancy and 1 case was not found malignancy in pathology and malignancy was excluded. The 21 cases were false negative cases. The false negative rate of malignant liver tumors in the first biopsy procedure guided by conventional ultrasound was 9.4% (21/224). The definite results of pathological diagnosis were 5 cases of hyperplasia with malignant degradation, 7 cases of HCC with degeneration and necrosis, 4 cases of metastases with necrosis or minute lesions and 5 cases with residual or renascent foci after surgery or interventional therapy. No complications occurred in our study. Conclusions CEUS can identify the active area, denaturalization or necrosis area of malignant lesions and minute tumors, which will significantly increase the accurate diagnostic rate of biopsy and decrease the false negative rate. The clinical application of CEUS should be appreciated.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?