Abstract:Conditional VaR models′correct specification test is equivalent to testing the de-meaned hit sequence following a mar-tingale difference sequence (m.d.s), however the commonly used backtesting techniques only test some properties of the se-quence.Using generalized spectral test which directly tests the m.d.s property of the de-meaned hit sequence, we evaluate the out-of-sample predictive performance of various parametric, nonparametric and semi-parametric VaR models with a total of 22 models calculated by using rolling predictive method for China′s stock markets including Shanghai Composite Index, Hang Seng Index and Taiwan Weighted Index.Because conditional VaR models′correct specification test can not reflect the tail risk infor-mation exceeding one specific VaR level, in order to avoid the occurrence of extreme losses as well as to increase the robustness of the results, we adopt MCS ( model confidence set) test simultaneously by selecting the asymmetric loss functions proposed by Koenker and Bassett and the magnitude loss function proposed by Lopez.Comparing with SPA( Superior Predictive Ability) test, the main advantage of MCS test is that it does not require a benchmark model to be specified as is the case for SPA tests.It char-acterizes the entire set of models that are not significantly outperformed by other models, while a test for SPA only provides evi-dence about the relative performance of a single model ( the benchmark) . The empirical results imply the following three conclusions:①it would cause wrong results using the commonly applied backtest-ing techniques such as Kupiec likelihood ratio test, Christoffersen likelihood ratio test and Engle and Manganelli dynamic quantile test.However adopting generalized spectral test and MCS test with Lopez loss function simultaneously would give us more accu-rate and robust results.②Comparing with historical simulation models, extreme value theory models, CAViaR and CARE mod-els, the out-of-sample predictive performance of the GARCH family with student-t distribution is the best at 1%and 5%signifi-cant level during the financial crisis for these three stock indexes.This implies that the risk characteristics of mainland stock mar-ket is getting closer and closer to the mature stock markets of Hong Kong and Taiwan after more than 20 years development.③At 1%significant level, the optimal VaR predictive models of Hang Seng Index include one of the CARE models which can be used to measure extreme loss situation with small probability.This implies that price limit system implemented by Hong Kong yet not by mainland and Taiwan will make Hong Kong′s stock market face more risk during the financial crisis.

A Comparative Study of the Validity of Stock Market's Index Between Mainland and HKSAR

An Empirical Study and Discussion on the Difference of the Trade

Portfolio Validity Test in the Chinese Market

Research on the Validity of Chinese Stock Market

The Lead–lag Relationship Between Chinese Mainland and Hong Kong Stock Markets

Offshore Stock Index Futures' Influence on Mainland Stock Market

Evaluating Predictive Performance of Value-at-Risk Models Based on Generalized Spectrum and MCS Tests

Effects of Short-Sale Constraints on Stock Prices and Trading Activity: Evidence from Hong Kong and Mainland China

Has Chinese Stock Market Become Efficient? Evidence From A New Approach

Investor Sentiment and Stock Price Premium Validation with Siamese Twins from China

Incentive Mechanism and Investor Protection of the Capital Structure: Evidence from Comparison between Public Companies Listed in Mainland and HK

An Empirical Study on the Verification of Efficiency in Shanghai Stock Market

An Approach to Hang Seng Index in Hong Kong Stock Market Based on Network Topological Statistics

Upward and Downward Multifractality and Efficiency of Chinese and Hong Kong Stock Markets

Analysis on the Reaction between Shanghai Stock Market and Hong Kong Stock Market

The Empirical Study of Psychological Barrier in Stock Market

Comparison of the Markowitz Model and Index Model for Portfolio Optimization in the Chinese Stock Market

Comparing Relative Valuation Efficiency Between Two Stock Markets

Does Shanghai Stock Exchange Composite Index Deviate China's Fundamentals?

Empirical Analysis on the Go-movement Effects Inter-Asia-Pacific Regional Capital Markets——Case Study on the Stock Market of Mainland China, HK, Japan and the U.S.

Empirical Analysis on Fractal Market Hypothesis in Shanghai and Shenzhen Stock Markets