Legal Environment,Corporate Governance and Expropriation:Evidence from the Comparison of Chinese and U.S.Stock Markets

CHANGJIANG L,CHENGMIN XIAO

2008-01-01

Abstract:Investor protection has received much more attention since the 1997 East Asi- an financial crisis.In outward form,expropriation can be taken by corporate managers or by controlling shareholder,but the essence of this issue is that somebody who has residual con- trol rights of the company uses the rights to benefit himself.So the importance of investor protection is to limit self-benefit use of residual control rights.Legal environment and corpo- rate governance are two basic factors that can play this role. This paper studies the differences of corporate governance and expropriation between Chinese and U.S.A.legal environment by comparing Chinese companies listed in U.S.A. stock market with Chinese companies listed in Shanghai or Shenzhen.We select Chinese com- panies that listed in the U.S.A.at the end of 2004 as our basic research sample,and matc- hing them with Chinese companies that listed in Shanghai or Shenzhen stock exchange based on size and industry.We compare the level of expropriation and corporate governance of these two samples,and examine whether the difference of legal environment and corporate govern- ance can explain the difference of expropriation.We find that compared with companies listed in Chinese stock market,Chinese companies listed in U.S.A.stock market have more effi- cient corporate governance and less expropriation.Legal environment and corporate govern- ance both can explain the differences of expropriation,but the former does better. This paper integrates the macro level factor(legal environment)and micro level factor (corporate governance),and suggests that former is more important for Chinese company. To make our results robust,we measure the level of expropriation both directly and indirect- ly.A simple method to adjust the difference of financial reporting accounting standards is also given in this paper.