A Summary Commentary of Some Major Translation Theories

区林,陈燕

2013-01-01

Abstract:This paper gives a summary commentary of some major translation theories and points out an integrated approach with a cultural turn is a preferable one,and the acceptance of new ideas with open- mindedness will help a healthy development in translation studies.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Translation Studies in China:Its Functions and A Possible Direction for Its Further Development

Xu Jun

2012-01-01

Abstract:Translation studies conducted since China’s reform and opening up has played a pivotal role in the establishment of translation as a discipline in this country.Whether in introducing insightful theoretical perspectives on the translational practice,laying a conceptual foundation for the discipline,promoting translation-related pedagogy, enriching the teaching of foreign languages,fostering a historical understanding of the cultural exchanges between China and foreign countries,or enhancing China’s soft power,remarkable achievements have been made by Chinese translation scholars.Having gained its disciplinary status and succeeded in refuting popularly held misassumptions such as"translation is not amenable to theory"or"theories of translation are useless,"however,how translation studies should further develop itself in China poses a formidable challenge to its practitioners.This paper takes up the challenge by reflecting on some of the burning issues of the moment,including those over the exclusive adoption of the cultural approach to the study of translation,the dearth of translation-specific theoretical sources,and the subordination of translation to some better established disciplines.
The Constructiveness of Translation Criticism in Critical Cases

刘云虹,许钧

2011-01-01

Abstract:What exactly are the value and the strength of literary translation criticism In this paper,we turn to historical facts,seeking to find answers from the actual translation criticism events.Taking three representative critical cases in the history of translation criticism as the objects of investigation,this paper seeks to reveal the constructiveness of translation criticism for translation theory and practice through an in-depth analysis of the form,the content,the object,the objective and the value of the events,and,on the basis of the objective evaluation of translation criticism,to prompt it to develop in a more scientific and beneficial direction.
The study of the history of translation in China: A methodological consideration ?With comments on A History of Translation in China

Xu Jun,Zhu Yubin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-0429.2007.06.008

2007-01-01

Abstract:This paper attempts to explore the new methods that can be used in the study of the history of translation in China.Then it will proceed to introduce and comment on the ground-breaking work,A History of Translation in China,with a view on the future trend of the study of the translation history in China.
The characteristics of contemporary Chinese translation theory development: a systematic review of studies in core Chinese journals (2012–2022)

Zhongshu Qin,Xuehai (John) Cui,Xuesong (Andy) Gao,Xuehai Cui,Xuesong Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-023-01955-w

2023-09-21

Humanities and Social Sciences Communications

Abstract:Researchers have long problematized the prevalence of Eurocentrism in modern Western translation theory. Alternative theories have been developing across many contexts, including China. This review examines 153 theory-related articles in four leading indexed Chinese journals that publish studies on translation. We analyzed the selected articles to explore the patterns in the development of Chinese translation theory through the past decade. Our analysis identified three characteristics of the development of Chinese translation theory: (1) Chinese translation theory developed under a heavy Western influence; (2) translation theories developed by translators; and (3) "theory"-related theoretical development on translation. These insights may help readers who do not have direct access to translation studies published in the Chinese language to better appreciate evolving translation theories that may counteract the inadequacy of Eurocentric approaches.
Translation,Different Texts and Transformed Language

Xiao-quan CHU

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-9358.2010.03.001

2010-01-01

Abstract:Current translation theories and translation critiques generally focus on a contrastive analysis between the original text and the rendered one.Little attention is paid to another dimension of the translating process,i.e.the impact of translation on the target language.In the history of translation,however,there have always been great translators who set up the transformation of the target lan-guage as the main objective of their work.This objective has been either neglected or misinterpreted,as in the case of Lu Xun.But if we examine the development of modern Chinese language,we will see that both the modern political discourse and the literary language in China have been deeply influenced by translated texts.
A Study on Translator’s Subjectivity of Dream of Red Mansions Based on Polysystem Theory

Lixia Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54691/np7nd212

2024-09-17

Abstract:With the development of The Times, translation studies are no longer limited to text and syntax, but have expanded from in-text studies to out-of-text studies. Translation activities are carried out in two cultural contexts. Therefore, from a new translation perspective, the translation process pays more attention to the target language culture and the influence of various social, cultural and economic factors on translation activities, thus developing the translator's subjectivity. The status of the translator is gradually revealed, which makes the translation closer to the target language culture and expands the target audience. Based on the comparison between traditional translation theory and multi-system theory, this paper takes the translation of Dream of Red Mansions as an example, and has an in-depth study of the translator's subjectivity in the translation process through comparison and analysis, emphasizing the important effect of the translator's subjectivity in translation activities,so as to provide references for how to produce high-quality text translation.
Translator Behavior Criticism---Ten Years in China

Binghui Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.11648/J.IJALT.20200601.14

2020-03-11

Abstract:Translator behavior criticism theory is regarded as one of the main current translation studies theory in China. It is proposed by Professor Zhou Lingshun in 2010 and now it has been for 10 years. In 2014, he made his proposals clearly in two of his influential books. After that, this theory has drawn a lot of attention from the academic circle and the number of related articles on it is increasing year by year. This article starts from changes of the role of translator and translator’s position as the center, which provides the background for this theory. Then it moves on to make clear the main proposals and practice of this theory, especially his “truth-seeking and utility attaining” continuum mode of evaluation. Through this continuum mode, one can measure the degree of rationality of a translator’s behavior by taking various factors into consideration, and then the evaluation of the translated version. This theory provides a new perspective on translation by combining translator’s behavior with translation. But in practice, some scholars also questioned the manipulability of his continuum mode. So in the end, this article talks about the significance and limitations of this theory. His theory is a breakthrough in translation studies, but still needs to be further polished.

Sociology,Linguistics
A Brief Analysis of Communicative Translation and Semantic Translation

Mi Zu,Yang Dong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2991/JISEM-15.2015.55

2015-12-26

Abstract:This paper aims at facilitating translating practice by reinterpreting Peter Newmark’s theory from a different linguistic viewpoint blending with cultural factors. The research methods adopted in the paper include literature review, comparison and case study. Communicative translation and semantic translation are two major translation methods put forward by Peter Newmark in one of his masterpieces Approaches to Translation. Meanwhile, he classified the texts into three types according to their functions, namely, expressive, informative as well as vocative texts, and accordingly explored the adoption of ST or CT from the perspective of the dominant function of the text. However, the present paper takes a new look into the theory of ST and CT by analyzing them in terms of syntax, culture and pragmatics, which can shed some light on translating practice. The conclusion is that the combination and flexible use of both is the most ideal translation method.

Linguistics,Computer Science
Aesthetic Origin of Translation Studies

Chen Huani,Zhao Qing,Liu Zihan,Huani Chen,Qing Zhao,Zihan Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1107861

2021-01-01

OALib

Abstract:This article reviews the development of Chinese and western translation theories. Firstly, it introduces the three stages of the development of Chinese traditional translation theory, namely, from the initial emphasis on “faithfulness” to the emphasis on “literary grace”, and then to the later debate on the priority on grace or content. Then, it focuses on the development history of western translation theory from ancient Rome to the 20th century, and summarizes two main periods, namely, the period of rhetoric aesthetics and the period of historical comparative linguistics. The former period began with Cicero, who was deeply influenced by Plato, and in turn influenced the later Bible translation and literary translation; the latter period was divided into two stages: before 1950s, it was mainly influenced by structuralist linguistics, and after 1950s, it was profoundly influenced by emerging language schools and modern ideological trends. Through these introductions, it presents the macro framework of the development history of Chinese and western translation theories.
THE CHINESE AND WESTERN TRANSLATION TRADITIONS IN COMPARISON

ZAIXI Tan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1556/acr.2.2001.1.4

IF: 1.292

2001-05-01

Across Languages and Cultures

Abstract:The purpose of this paper is to provide a discussion of some of the basic differences and similarities between the Chinese and Western traditions of translation. After analysing some of the major findings about what is shared and what is unshared between the two traditions, as well as what lies beneath these differences and similarities, four basic conclusions are made; namely, (a) comparative translation studies is important and should be fully developed; (b) the differences between the Chinese and Western translation traditions are necessarily conditioned by differences in their broader socio-cultural framework; (c) quite similar ideas have been produced over the centuries between China and the West, which may be regarded as elements of ‘universality' as the most outstanding feature of theoretical discussions about translation across language-cultures; and most importantly, (d) an understanding of Chinese-Western differences and similarities should help create a meaningful environment in which translators and translation theorists from different traditions can draw upon one another's experiences. The rationale of the discussion is that by bringing culturally disparate translation traditions such as the Chinese and Western into comparison, important insights may be gained about the nature of translation and translation studies in general.

linguistics
Random thoughts on literal translation and free translation as seen from the development of Newmark's theory on translation

Yu Zhen

Abstract:Based on an analysis into the developemt of Newmark's translation theory, this paper is of opiniib that the method of literal translation and the method of free translation are a unity of opposites either of which can be dispensed with, Communicative translation, where transmission of information contained in the original is stressed, places meaning before form and thus favors free translation. Semantic translation, which attempts to cover the whole of the meaning in the original and at the same time retains the form of the original as much as possible, favors literal translation. Literal translation is the base, whereas the translation is an aid and a supplement to literal translation.

Computer Science,Philosophy,Linguistics
Cultivation of Theoretical Attainments and Compilation of Textbooks of Translation Theories

XU Jun,GAO Fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13458/j.cnki.flatt.000266

2010-01-01

Abstract:Due to economic globalization,China's exchange with foreign countries in various fields,such as politics,economics,science and cultures,becoming more and more frequent,producing new requirements for the cultivation of qualified translators and interpreters.Therefore,it is necessary to clarify two basic problems in translators and interpreters' education:(1)the respective status of and relationship between Undergraduate Translation Major(UTM)and Master of Translation and Interpreting(MTI);(2)the relationship between the training of translation skills and the cultivation of theoretical attainment in these programs.The paper starts by fixing the objective of cultivating qualified translators and interpreters,and proposes the specific requirements for the buildup of theoretical attainment in their training programs.Then after discussing the compilation of theoretical textbooks in Translation Studies with a view to nurturing theoretical attainment in qualified translators and interpreters,it sets forth relevant principles for compiling such textbooks;that is,they should be conducive to the establishment of appropriate views on translation and its history characterized by qualified translators and interpreters,and be conducive to their understanding of the science of translation and their mastery of translation skills.
An Inspiration of Theoretical Awareness in Translation Assessment and Research——On the significance of the dispute over Chinese translations of Le Rouge et le Noir

XU Jun

2011-01-01

Abstract:This paper argues that the nationwide debate,in the 1990s,about the Chinese translation of Stendal's Le Rouge et le Noir was a significant,historic event.The event has drawn attention to the ethical aspect of translation and inspired Chinese scholars with theoretical awareness in their translation research and criticism.It is and will long be remembered for its contribution to the building of new scaffoldings for Chinese translators and critics to perform translation criticism.To a remarkable degree,it provoked thinking,on the part of the then enthusiastic reading community of foreign literature,about literary translation.
Analysis of the Chinese Translation of The Art of Loving (Excerpt) from the Perspective of Newmark’s Translation Theory

Yina Luo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/ijeh.v11i3.15164

2023-12-14

International Journal of Education and Humanities

Abstract:Peter Newmark was a famous British translator and translation theorist. According to the type of text, he divided texts into expressive text, informative text, and vocative text in his first book Approaches to Translation, published in 1981 and formed the core concept of his translation thought, “semantic translation” and “communicative translation”. Based on semantic translation, communicative translation, and text typology, this paper tries to analyze the Chinese translation of the source text, The Art Of Loving(excerpts), written by Eric Fromm, a famous German-American psychologist, psychoanalyst and philosopher. Due to the psychology and critical thinking of the source text, the translator prefers to communicative translation and uses various translation methods and skills to reduce reading difficulties. This paper finds that any translation is a mixture of many theories, strategies, or methods. To some extent, in the process of translation, it inspires us to pay more attention to the use of translation theory, so that intuition and rationality can be combined, and closer to the essence of translation than the subconscious translation behaviors.
A Brief Analysis of Peter Newmark’s Communicative Translation Theory

Yanlan Cai

2019-09-02

Abstract:Peter Newmark (1916-2011) was one of the representative figures in translation field of the English-speaking countries in the twentieth century. The paper mainly introduces Newmark’s viewpoints on translation theory, especially his basic principles of the Communicative Translation Theory, that is, the principle of receptor-oriented strategies, the principle of equivalence-expected effect as well as the principle of information accuracy. It is based on text type and language function to translate, which makes the translation smoother and clearer to the target language readers. In that case, it can reduce the understanding obstacles of the foreigners.

Linguistics,Philosophy
A Study of the English Commentary Translation of Chongzuo Zhuang Museum from the Perspective of Skopos Theory

Li Zhenying,Chen Yiyun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22158/selt.v8n3p87

2020-07-20

Studies in English Language Teaching

Abstract:In recent years, China’s tourism industry has continuously promoted economic development. Therefore, the translation of tourism commentary is becoming increasingly important. The museum’s English commentary translation plays an irreplaceable role as an important medium for disseminating cultural knowledge and informing foreign friends. However, we don’t think highly of the English commentary translation, there are many grammatical and general errors, which hinders foreigners from getting the correct and accurate information. Wrong English commentary is not only harmful for cultural transmission but also bad for expanding opening-up. Chinese English translations are rarely translated on the basis of theory, which hinders the development of theoretical studies on Chinese translation. This thesis mainly focuses on the research and analysis of the English commentary in the Chongzuo Zhuang Museum. And it researches and analyzes the English commentary translation from the perspective of Skopos teleology. And it will enrich domestic research on teleological translation theory.
Translation, Globalisation and Localisation A Chinese Perspective Introduction

Wang Ning,Sun Yifeng

2008-01-01

Abstract:Acknowledgement 1. Introductory Remarks - Wang Ning (Tsinghua University) & Sun Yifeng (Lingnan University)Part One Historical Overviews 2. Transvaluing the Global: Translation, Modernity, and Hegemonic Discourse - Xie Ming (University of Toronto) 3. Translation in the Global-Local Tension - Cay Dollerup 4. Translation Studies in China: A Glocalized Theoretical Practice - Sun Yifeng & Mu Lei (Guangdong University of Foreign Studies.) 5. On Cultural Translation: A Postcolonial Perspective - Wang Ning 6. Toward Pluralistic and Interdisciplinary Approaches: A Reflection on Translation Studies in Contemporary China - Xu Yanhong (Tsinghua University ) Part Two Current Developments 7. A Global View of Translation Studies: Toward an Interdisciplinary Field - Edwin Gentzler (University of Massachusetts) 8. Transgression and Appropriation in Transnational Cultural Translation: A Deconstructive Observation - Chen Yongguo (Tsinghua University) 9. When a Turning Occurs: Counterevidence to Polysystem Hypothesis --- Wang Dongfeng (Sun Yet-san University) 10. Translating Popular Culture: Feng Xiaogang?s Film Big Shot?s Funeral as a Polynuclear Text - Mao Sihui (Macao Polytechnic Institute.) 11. English as a Postcolonial Tool: Anti-Hegemonic Subversions in a Hegemonic Language - Eugene Chen Eoyang (Lingnan University )BibliographyContributorsIndex
Theoretical Basis on English Translation for Chinese Cultural Classics

FengHua Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2991/icemaess-15.2016.204

2016-01-01

Abstract:As the lack of the awareness of building translation theory and the insufficiency of research on translation theory, the study on translation theory lags behind the achievements obtained in the field of practical translation, especially in Chinese classics translation field. In this paper, we focus on context theory, multisystem theory and functional...
Rethinking translation studies

Sanjun Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/ts.3.08sun

2014-11-28

Translation Spaces

Abstract:Since Holmes’ founding statement for translation studies in 1972, four decades have passed. During that time some trends seem to have developed in the discipline, and it is time to stop and take stock. This paper touches upon issues essential to understanding translation studies today, such as (1) the nature of translation; (2) the research scope of translation studies; (3) interdisciplinary orientation and its implications; (4) research methods; and (5) the relationship between translation theory and practice. An examination of these issues indicates that the discipline of translation studies is increasingly subject to opposing or competing research approaches and is exhibiting a kind of disciplinary fragmentation. There are imbalances in the research methods used and in the topics that emerge in the research literature. There is a growing gap between translation theory and practice. This paper tries to examine the reasons for these trends and offer perspectives on ways to reach some common disciplinary and professional ground.
Cultural Approaches to Translation Studies in Western and Chinese Translatologies

Yang Pin

Abstract:By analyzing and comparing the sources and features of cultural approaches to translation studies in China and in Western countries, this article discusses research targets, methodologies and problems of cultural research in Chinese translatology. It points out that new theories, including Western translation theories, broadens the horizon of China's translation studies while, at the same time, cultural research in China's translation studies must be based on China's own conditions and aim at solving China's own practical problems. In this respect, it suggests that Chinese researchers pay more attention to descriptive studies as well as proper assessment and analysis of translation activities and products.

Linguistics,Sociology

A Summary Commentary of Some Major Translation Theories

Translation Studies in China:Its Functions and A Possible Direction for Its Further Development

The Constructiveness of Translation Criticism in Critical Cases

The study of the history of translation in China: A methodological consideration ?With comments on A History of Translation in China

The characteristics of contemporary Chinese translation theory development: a systematic review of studies in core Chinese journals (2012–2022)

Translation,Different Texts and Transformed Language

A Study on Translator’s Subjectivity of Dream of Red Mansions Based on Polysystem Theory

Translator Behavior Criticism---Ten Years in China

A Brief Analysis of Communicative Translation and Semantic Translation

Aesthetic Origin of Translation Studies

THE CHINESE AND WESTERN TRANSLATION TRADITIONS IN COMPARISON

Random thoughts on literal translation and free translation as seen from the development of Newmark's theory on translation

Cultivation of Theoretical Attainments and Compilation of Textbooks of Translation Theories

An Inspiration of Theoretical Awareness in Translation Assessment and Research——On the significance of the dispute over Chinese translations of Le Rouge et le Noir

Analysis of the Chinese Translation of The Art of Loving (Excerpt) from the Perspective of Newmark’s Translation Theory

A Brief Analysis of Peter Newmark’s Communicative Translation Theory

A Study of the English Commentary Translation of Chongzuo Zhuang Museum from the Perspective of Skopos Theory

Translation, Globalisation and Localisation A Chinese Perspective Introduction

Theoretical Basis on English Translation for Chinese Cultural Classics

Rethinking translation studies

Cultural Approaches to Translation Studies in Western and Chinese Translatologies