Thoughts Concerning Several Issues on Research of Musicology
Yu Runyang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0447-6573.2009.01.001
2009-01-01
Abstract:I.History and Theory The mission of research of music history is to discover,sort out and research all the various historical facts,events,personalities and,in particular,composition works,on the basis of which an overall description can be clearly made so as to form a complete and comprehensive historical view of music.However,such a description is after all not the ultimate object of music history,which should never be a simple gathering of numerous historical facts.Let's then look at theoretical research of music,taking music aesthetics as an example.This is a highly abstract and controversial subject of music theory.Its prior object is the distinctive nature and character of this art form which differs from other art forms,and which is even attributed to music philosophy.But explorations of such kind should abstain from merely focusing on the abstract and controversial level while neglecting historical sense.In my opinion,in the field of musicological research,particularly researches of music history and music aesthetics,we should try hard to realize the mutual infiltration and fusion between history and theory or between history and logic.II.Musicology and Other Related Subjects of Humanity Musicology,as a science of humanity,is a system of music knowledge in various genres,in close relations with a series of subjects such as philosophy,historiography,aesthetics,art science,ethnology,anthropology,psychology and sociology.And there are even more close ties among various sub-branch subjects within musicology itself.III.Theoretic Standpoint and History:The Contemporary Sources of Theory Musicology is a human-social science which can not do without support of some kind of theory,or in other words,can not do without a theoretical standpoint whether you realize or admit it or not.As for me,the Marxist materialistic theory of history full of dialectic views is my philosophical standpoint.But in spite of this philosophic and aesthetical standpoint that I have,I am not in favor of rejecting in a simple way any other valuable non-Marxist philosophical or aesthetical source of theory whether in history or in modern days.IV.Society:Historical Interpretation and Analysis of Music Content In my paper on the music of one of Wagner's operas,I put forward the concept of "musicological analysis".I describe this concept as such that "should be a professional analysis on a higher level with comprehensive nature,and should not only study artistic style,language and aesthetic feature of a music work,but also reveal the social and historical content of the work to make proper historic and realistic evaluation,and should try hard to make the two aspects into one,so as to form a higher level of overall understanding of the work." V.Music Text Itself and the Experience and Understanding of It As a researcher in the field of musicology,one should have full sense of his own role when facing a music work,i.e.he should be involved in the ultimate construction of the object for music appreciation through his own orientation.This requires his high ability of aesthetic appreciation over the music work itself,including minimum ability of artistic imagination.VI.Thoughts and Expressions In essence,truth should finally become clear.Although a theoretically complex article would inevitably use philosophical and aesthetical terminology for discussion purpose,the content of such terms and concepts should always be clearly defined.It is of course necessary to invent new terms and new concepts,but they are only necessary when it is impossible to express their content in modern terns and concepts.