Abstract:The so-called calcifying odontogenic cyst (COC) represents a heterogeneous group of lesions that exhibit a variety of clinicopathologic and behavioral features. Because of this diversity, there has been confusion and disagreement on the terminology and classification of these lesions. We reviewed the clinicopathologic features of 21 intraosseous cases that were previously diagnosed as COC or under related diagnostic terms. Based on the biologic behavior, the lesions of the present series were divided into three subgroups: cyst, benign tumor, and malignant tumor. Sixteen cases (nine men and seven women) proved to be unicystic lesions with (five cases) or without associated odontoma. The lining epithelium of the cystic lesions fulfilled the histologic criteria for COC proposed by the World Health Organization, and their overall clinicopathologic features were consistent with that of developmental odontogenic cysts. The age of patients from the cyst group peaked at the second decade. The maxilla was affected more often (69%) than the mandible, with a predilection for the canine-premolar region (62.5%). Thirteen patients with follow-up information revealed no recurrence following enucleation. The four cases in the benign tumor group had variable clinicopathologic features. Two cases were solid tumors consisting of ameloblastoma-like sheets of odontogenic epithelium that contained ghost cells/calcification foci and juxtaepithelial dentinoid. Both patients experienced multiple recurrences following conservative surgeries. The other two lesions contained typical areas of COC and other types of odontogenic tumors (one ameloblastoma and one odontogenic myxofibroma). All four lesions occurred in the mandible and were relatively large. In the present series one case identified as malignant tumor arose from a previously benign COC. The tumor shared some features of COC (ghost cell foci and dystrophic calcification) but also had prominent mitotic activity, nuclear and cytoplasmic pleomorphism, areas of tumor necrosis, and infiltrative/destructive growth. Recognizing the extreme diversity in clinicopathologic features and biologic behavior among the so-called COCs, we suggest that the term COC should be used to specifically designate the unicystic lesions with or without an associated odontoma, i.e., lesions of the cyst group, and other related lesions identified as benign tumor and malignant tumor should be termed and classified separately. A tentative scheme with respect to the terminology and classification for this group of disparately behaving lesions was herein proposed to reflect the likely difference of their nature.

A historical review on the terminology and histological classification of several odontogenic lesions

Clinical and Pathological Aspects of Some Odontogenic Tumors and Related Lesions

Statistical Analysis of 9 056 Cases of Oral and Maxillofacial Tumors, Cysts and Tumor-Like Lesions in 52 Years

Critical assessment of the latest classification of jaw cysts proposed by the World Health Organization (2017)

Proceedings of the 2023 North American Society of Head and Neck Pathology Companion Meeting, New Orleans, LA, March 12, 2023: Odontogenic Tumors: Have We Achieved an Evidence-Based Classification

Malformations vs. Neoplasia in the Oral Cavity: Special Emphasis on Mixed Odontogenic Tumors

Critical reviews in oral biology & medicine: The odontogenic keratocyst: A cyst, or a cystic neoplasm?

The evolving molecular characterisation, histological criteria and nomenclature of adenoid ameloblastoma as a World Health Organisation tumour type

Imaging approach for jaw and maxillofacial bone tumors with updates from the 2022 World Health Organization classification

Calcifying cystic odontogenic tumour: Dilemma and pitfalls

The Unicystic Ameloblastoma: A Clinicopathologically Distinct

Pathological diagnosis of odontogenic cysts and odontogenic tumors

Clinicopathologic spectrum of the so-called calcifying odontogenic cysts: a study of 21 intraosseous cases with reconsideration of the terminology and classification.

Updated WHO nomenclature of head and neck lesions and associated imaging findings

Emphasizing the Significance of Differential Diagnosis

Classificatory updates in verrucous and cuniculatum carcinomas: Insights from the 5th edition of WHO-IARC head and neck tumor classification

Ameloblastic Fibroma and Related Lesions: a Clinicopathologic Study with Reference to Their Nature and Interrelationship

Odontogenic tumors: a study of 1309 cases in a Chinese population.

Calcifying odontogenic cysts: A novel outlook on classification, diagnosis and management

[The Nature of Calcifying Odontogenic Cysts of the Jaws].

Molecular Markers in the World Health Organization Classification of Head and Neck Tumors, Fifth Edition