Abstract:Navon hierarchical letter stimuli are often used to measure interference between global and local visual information, with global-to-local interference effects being usually interpreted as evidence for perceptual grouping (e.g., Behrmann & Kimchi, 2003). The relationship between this measure and holistic/configural face perception, namely the encoding of the multiple features of a face as a whole representation, remains elusive. In a recent study, Gao and colleagues (2011) showed that global processing of Navon stimuli increased the sensitivity to incongruence between the upper and the lower halves of a composite face and concluded that global processing of Navon stimuli augments holistic face processing. However, rather than using a standard composite face matching paradigm, the authors used a congruency paradigm with composite faces (e.g., Richler et al., 2008), namely a paradigm that has a built-in decisional confound and includes responses on ‘different’ trials likely reflecting part-based judgments (Rossion, in press). Here we reanalyzed Gao et al. (2011)’s data by examining only the ‘same’ trials, as in a standard composite face measure, and found that global processing of Navon stimuli did not increase the composite face effect, neither in accuracy rates nor in correct RTs. The effect initially described is due only to a priming of the ‘different’ composite face trials, reflecting part-based judgments. These findings reinforce the view that the congruency paradigm with composite faces measures general processes that should not be mistaken with face-specific holistic/configural perceptual processes measured in the standard composite face paradigm. More generally and importantly, they support the view that processing global aspects of hierarchical Navon stimuli is functionally distinct than holistic/configural perception of individual faces (Busigny & Rossion, 2011) and suggest that correlations between the two measures across individuals or impairments at the Navon task in cases of congenital prosopagnosia (Behrmann et al., 2005) essentially reflects general visual processes. Meeting abstract presented at VSS 2013

Parallel and Competitive Processes in Hierarchical Analysis: Perceptual Grouping and Encoding of Closure.

Interactions between perceptual organization based on Gestalt laws and those based on hierarchical processing

Segmentation and Selection Contribute to Local Processing in Hierarchical Analysis.

Perceptual Organization at Attended and Unattended Locations

Perceptual grouping and selective attention

On the Different Processing of Wholes and Parts: A Psychophysiological Analysis

Hierarchical Constraints on the Distribution of Attention in Dynamic Displays

Global processing of Navon stimuli primes the general (face) congruency effect but not the standard composite face effect

Attentional Mechanism for Organization in Visual Working Memory

Organization Principles in Visual Working Memory: Evidence from Sequential Stimulus Display

Overlapping neural representations for selection in attention and working memory

Stereoscopic Information Disrupts the Closure Grouping Effect in Discrimination Task but Not in Detection Task

Hierarchical Processing and Level-Repetition Effect As Indexed by Early Brain Potentials.

Neural Substrates of Global Perception Are Modulated by Local Element Grouping

Perceptual Grouping of Closed Contours is Disrupted by the Interpretation of the Scene Layout

Modulation of neural activities by enhanced local selection in the processing of compound stimuli.

Divided Attention in Perception: A Unified Analysis of Dual-Task Deficits and Congruency Effects

Serial processing of proximity groups and similarity groups

617 Modulation of Brain Potentials by Hierarchical Processing: A High-Density ERP Study

Where There is No Object Formation, There is No Perceptual Organization: Evidence from the Configural Superiority Effect

Uniform connectedness and classical gestalt principles of perceptual grouping