Abstract:Purpose Autonomous orbit determination using geomagnetic measurements is an important backup technique for safe spacecraft navigation with a mere magnetometer. The geomagnetic model is used for the state estimation of orbit elements, but this model is highly nonlinear. Therefore, many efforts have been paid to developing nonlinear filters based on extended Kalman filter (EKF) and unscented Kalman filter (UKF). This paper aims to analyze whether to use UKF or EKF in solving the geomagnetic orbit determination problem and try to give a general conclusion. Design/methodology/approach This paper revisits the problem and from both the theoretical and engineering results, the authors show that the EKF and UKF show identical estimation performances in the presence of nonlinearity in the geomagnetic model. Findings While EKF consumes less computational time, the UKF is computationally inefficient but owns better accuracy for most nonlinear models. It is also noted that some other navigation techniques are also very similar with the geomagnetic orbit determination. Practical implications The intrinsic reason of such equivalence is because of the orthogonality of the spherical harmonics which has not been discovered in previous studies. Thus, the applicability of the presented findings are not limited only to the major problem in this paper but can be extended to all those schemes with spherical harmonic models. Originality/value The results of this paper provide a fact that there is no need to choose UKF as a preferred candidate in orbit determination. As UKF achieves almost the same accuracy as that of EKF, its loss in computational efficiency will be a significant obstacle in real-time implementation.

Novel Algorithm for Geomagnetic Navigation

A Geomagnetic Navigation Algorithm for Miniature Unmanned Helicopter

An Integrated Navigation Algorithm Based on Three-Axis Magnetometer and Gravity Measurement

Simultaneous Localization and Mapping Method for Geomagnetic Aided Navigation

Geomagnetic Surface Navigation Using Adaptive EKF

Autonomous navigation method using the angle between Geomagnetic and starlight vector

A novel algorithm for SINS/CNS/GPS integrated navigation system

Research on EKF based Geomagnetic navigation strategy

Geographic True Navigation Based on Real-Time Measurements of Geomagnetic Fields.

Autonomous Navigation Based Geomagnetic Research

A Novel Hybrid Algorithm of Split-Radix Fast Fourier Transform and Unscented Kalman Filter for Navigation Information Estimation

Autonomous Satellite Navigation Using Magnetic Measurements

Algorithm for Satellite Autonomous Navigation Using Magnetometer

Nonlinear Geomagnetic/gps/sins Integrated Navigation

An Adaptive UKF Algorithm and Its Application to Geomagnetic Navigation

An Autonomous Navigation Algorithm Using Geomagnetic Sensor and Star Sensor

Geomagnetism GPS SINS Integrated Navigation Based on an Improved Square-Root UKF

Comparison of Geomagnetic Aided Navigation Algorithms for Hypersonic Vehicles

Geomagnetic orbit determination: EKF or UKF?

Refined Aircraft Positioning Based on Stochastic Hybrid Estimation with Adaptive Square-Root Unscented Particle Filtering

Combined Navigation Algorithm by Means of Magnetometers and GPS