Abstract:Background Endoscopic treatment for urethral stricture, including cold knife and laser, poses a major challenge to clinical practice. Both the benefits and drawbacks of these two treatments remain controversial. This article aimed to compare the efficacy and safety of laser and cold knife urethrotomy for urethral stricture. Methods We searched Pub Med (1966-2009), Embase (1980-2009), Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CCRCT, 2009 No.1) and Chinese Biomedical Literature Database (CBM) for laser and cold knife urethrotomy as treatment for male urethral stenosis, looking in the English literatures. Two reviewers independently screened the literatures and extracted information. Chi-square test was used for statistical analysis with SPSS15.0. Results A total of 44 articles, including of 3230 cases was retrieved. Success rate of patients treated with laser was 74.9% compared with 68.5% for cold knife, with very similar clinical results despite a statistically significant difference (P=0.004). The trend in success rate at a different follow-up time was similar between the two groups. No significant difference in success rate was found between the groups of repeat operation for recurrence cases, first P=0.090 and second P=0.459. The shorter the stricture length was (<1 cm), the higher the success rate was (P <0.0001). No significant difference in success rate between the laser and cold knife groups was found in neither bulbar nor membranous urethra, bulbar P=0.660 and membranous P=0.477. The rates of urinary incontinence, urinary extravasation, and urinary tract infection showed no significant difference (P=0.259, P=0.938, P=0.653, respectively). Conclusions Success rates for laser and cold knife were very similar despite being statistically different, with the groups having a similar trend in success rates at different follow-up time. Stricture location and history of endoscopic intervention did impact treatment outcome but was not significantly different. The two groups showed no significant difference in major complications. Chin Med J 2010;123(12):1589-1595

Efficacy of Cryoscalpel Internal Urethrotomy and 2 Micron Continuous Wave Laser Vaporesection in Treating 32 Patients of Urethral Stricture

Efficacy and safety of endoscopic treatment of urethral stricture and urethratresia with 2μm continuous-wave thulium laser

Treatment of long urethral stricture and atreturethria with application of various endoscopic technology

Treatment of Urethral Stricture with Urethrotome and Holmium: YAG Laser under Telescope (43 Cases Report)

Analysis on efficacy of direct-vision internal urethrotomy with Holmium:YAG laser followed by retention of urethral catheter to treat anterior urethral stricture of more than 2cm long in twenty-one male patients

Treatment of Urethral Stricture with Application of Endoscopic Technology(Report of 56 Cases)

Safety and Efficacy of Laser and Cold Knife Urethrotomy for Urethral Stricture

Treatment of Urethral Stricture with Thulium Laser

Ureteroscopic Holmium Laser Urethrotomy for Male Urethral Stricture and Atresia

Comparison of Combined Holmium Laser Incision with Electro-Incision and the Open Surgery in the Treatment of the Latter Urethral Stricture

Efficacy of Holmium Laser in Treatment of Urethrostenosis Through Ureteroscope

Comparison of laser versus cold knife visual internal urethrotomy in the treatment of urethral stricture (stricture length <2 cm): A systematic review and meta-analysis

The transurethral treat ment of male's long-seg ment urethral stricture

Thulium laser urethrotomy for urethral stricture: a preliminary report.

Antegrade-retrograde Via Flexible Cystoscopy Endoscopic Urethrotomy with a Cold Knife for Treatment of Obliterative Urethral Stricture: an Observation of Clinical Effectiveness

The effectiveness and precautions of internal urethrotomy for long-length traumatic bulbar urethral strictures

Internal Urethrotomy Plus Electrotomy for the Treatment of Urethral Stricture and Atresia

Holmium laser urethrotomy for urethral stricture and occlusion (report of 26 cases)

Application of 120 W 2 Μm Laser Prostate Vaporesection in the Treatment of Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia

Clinical Study of Internal Urethrotomy for Urethral Stricture by Bipolar Plsamakinetic

Holmium laser urethrotomy in treatment of urethral stricture:an outcome of long term follow-up