Gender Differences in Language Lateralization:A Meta-analysis of fMRI Studies

Shanshan Shi,Chuanbin Ni
2009-01-01
Abstract:Gender differences in language ability favoring women have been noted in behavioral studies. It has been hypothesized that they may result from a gender-related bilateral pattern of language representation in women. In order to test this hypothesis,numerous investigations have been done by psycholinguists using ERP,fMRI and PET,but controversy about the presence of gender differences in language lateralization remains. This paper presents a meta-analysis of these published studies that assess these gender-based language activities with fMRI from year 1995 to 2008 and explores the moderate factors that influence the outcome. Results show that no gender difference was found in language lateralization. Sub-analyses of studies that apply different paradigms all yield the same conclusion except one that uses story processing as language tasks. In conclusion,gender-related lateralization may not be attributable to the general gender differences in behavioral studies,and future studies may look into cognitive and social factors for a convincing explanation.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?