The biomechanical effects of different internal fixations in the treatment of femoral neck fractures
Xinlong Ma,Jianxiong Ma,Tao Ma,Dan Xing,Jie Wang,Yang Yang,Shaowen Zhu,Baoyi Ma,Yang Chen,WeiGuo Xu,Zhibin Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0219519413500048
2013-01-01
Journal of Mechanics in Medicine and Biology
Abstract:The objective of this study was to contrast the biomechanical effects of standard internal fixations for femoral neck fracture treatment and provide a theoretical basis for the selection of the ideal internal fixation in the clinic. Twelve artificial PMMA femoral models were selected, and the central necks of the specimens were sawn with a electric saw at Pauwels angle of 70 degrees to form an adduction-type femoral neck fracture model. After anatomic reduction, we fixed the specimens respectively with the DHS, three hollow screws, PFN, and dynamic sleeve three-wing screw according to the operative approach. Instron-8874 servo-hydraulic mechanical testing machine was used to fix the specimens which simulated uniped standing. We selected 15 key points on the proximal femur as test points and gave the model gradation loading at the rate of 10 mm/min with linear load 0 similar to 1200 N. The strain of each point under 1200N load, head sink displacement under different loads, and the strain of eight points on principal pressure side were measured. A peak was observed at the eight resistance strain gages at 1200 N load, with the strain values of the DHS, three hollow screws, PFN, and dynamic sleeve three-wing screw were (-700 +/- 35), (-756 +/- 14), (-1362 +/- 136), and (3024 +/- 127) mu epsilon, showing statistical significance (P < 0.01). Under the same load, the head sink displacement in the group with the dynamic sleeve three-wing screw was greater than the hollow screws and PFN groups (P < 0: 01), but smaller than the DHS group (P < 0.01). The strain values at the eight resistance strain gages in the group with the dynamic sleeve three-wing screw was larger than the other three groups under the same load, showing statistical significance (P < 0.01), and the strain values demonstrated an increasing trend with the increase of load at the same fixation group. The dynamic sleeve three-wing screw has good biomechanical stability for the treatment of femoral neck fractures, which can be applied in clinical practice.