Abstract:Background The effectiveness of peer learning in clinical skill development is well recognized and researched, given the many benefits gained such as enhanced learning, alleviation of the burden on faculty, and early development of teaching skills for future doctors. However, little is known in terms of its effectiveness as an assessment tool and the extent to which peer assessment can be relied upon in the absence of faculty support. Objective This study was conducted to assess medical students’ perception toward peer learning, which is based on self-regulated learning as a tool of assessment, and to compare peer evaluation with faculty evaluation of clinical skill performance. Methods A cohort of 36 third-year medical students were exposed to peer learning (same-level) in clinical skills education for 3 months. A convergent mixed methods approach was adapted to collect data from 3 sources, namely, students’ perception of peer learning, performance scores, and reflective observational analysis. A 5-point Likert-type scale was used to assess students’ (n=28) perception on the value of peer learning. The students were asked to assess their peers by using a preset checklist on clinical skill performance, and scores were compared to faculty assessment scores. Reflective observational data were collected from observing video recordings of some of the peer learning sessions. The findings from all 3 sources were integrated using joint display analysis. Results Out of 28 students, 25 students completed the survey and 20 students perceived peer learning as valuable in clinical skills education. The mean score of peer assessment was higher than that of faculty assessment. There was a significant difference in student performance between supervised teaching and peer learning groups (P=.003). Most students focused on the mastery of skill with little attention to the technique’s quality. Further, students were unable to appreciate the relevance of the potential clinical findings of physical examination. Conclusions Peer learning in clinical skills education, based on self-regulated learning, empowers students to develop a more responsible approach toward their education. However, peer assessment is insufficient to evaluate clinical skill performance in the absence of faculty support. Therefore, we recommend that peer learning activities be preceded by supervised faculty-taught sessions.

Compatibility of Peer Assessment and Teacher Assessment in Observational Situations: An Emerging Assessment Tool in Higher Education

Students’ Experiences of Peer Observed Teaching: A Qualitative Interview Study

Peer Observation as a Professional Development Intervention in EFL Pedagogy

Review On Peer Assessment As Effective Knowledge Sharing Tool For Students Learning In Classroom

Online self-assessment and peer-assessment as a tool to enhance student-teachers’ assessment skills

Medical Students’ Perception and Perceived Value of Peer Learning in Undergraduate Clinical Skill Development and Assessment: Mixed Methods Study

Continuous Professional Development of Secondary School Teachers through Peer Observation: Implications for Policy & Practice

Peer assessment, self-assessment, and resultant feedback: an examination of feasibility and reliability

The Study of Peer Assessment Impact on Group Learning Activities

Peer Assessment Between Students in Colleges and Universities

Peer evaluation as an alternative assessment method for case presentations: A cross‐sectional study of dental students' perception

Peers as OSCE assessors for junior medical students - a review of routine use: a mixed methods study

PEER TEACHING STRATEGY AND ITS EFFECT ON SELF- EFFICACY, COLLABORATIVE BEHAVIOR, AND PERFORMANCE OF NURSING STUDENTS AT NURSING COLLEGE, KING KHALID UNIVERSITY

Peer observation of student-led teaching

Enhancing Student-Teachers Assessment Skills: A Self-and Peer-Assessment Tool in Higher Education

Interdisciplinary Class Observation in Higher Education: Lessons Learned from the Professional Development Experience of Four Teachers

Peer Assessment In The Digital Age: A Meta-Analysis Comparing Peer And Teacher Ratings

Peer and self-evaluation using active teaching method

Peer assessment of professional competence

Medical Students' Perceptions of Peer Assessment in a Problem-based Learning Curriculum

Factors That Determine the Perceived Effectiveness of Peer Feedback in Collaborative Learning: a Mixed Methods Design