Fffects of Disruptive Behavior Disorders on Prognosis of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder in Adulthood
QIAN Qiu-jin,LI Yue-ling,WANG Yu-feng,ZHANG Yu-juan
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective To analyze the effects of disruptive behavior disorders(DBD) effects on the prognosis of children with attention deficit hypera-ctivity disorder(ADHD) in adulthood.Methods The structured psychiatric interviews were carried out in 58 adults of childhood ADHD with DBD(ADHD plus DBD group) to work out diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders(DSM)-Ⅳ diagnoses by trained clinicians,including Conners Adult ADHD Diagnostic Interview for DSM-Ⅳ (CAADID),the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-Ⅳ Axis Ⅰ Disorders (SCID-Ⅰ),Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-Ⅳ Personality Disorders(SCID-Ⅱ),and the Global Assessment of Functioning Scale (GAF),which were compared with other 58 adults of childhood ADHD with DBD (ADHD plus DBD group) compared with 58 adults of childhood ADHD without DBD (ADHD without DBD group),who were referred to the outpatient psychiatric clinic from Sep.1999 to Jul.2006.Results The average GAF score of group ADHD plus DBD was significantly lower than that in group ADHD without DBD[(71.6±10.6) score vs (77.1±11.3) score,t=2.725 P=0.007].The percentage of good overall functioning (GAF70 score)in group ADHD plus DBD was significantly lower than that in group ADHD without DBD (37.9% vs 56.9%,χ2=4.184 P=0.041).The percentage of teacher coaching and absence from school children in group ADHD plus DBD was significantly higher than that in group ADHD without DBD(85.7% vs 68.8%,P=0.038;26.8% vs 10.4%,P=0.035).The percentages of adult ADHD,borderline ADHD and the remitted in group ADHD plus DBD were 58.6%,24.1%,and 17.2%,while in group ADHD without DBD,they were 43.1%,15.5% and 41.4%.There were significant differences between those groups(χ2=8.225 P=0.016).There was much more persistent ADHD in group ADHD plus DBD.The percentages of mood disorder in group ADHD plus DBD were significantly higher than those in group ADHD without DBD(25.9% vs 10.3%,χ2=4.710 P=0.030,OR=3.023,95%CI 1.080-8.463).The percentage of any kind anxiety disorder in group ADHD plus DBD was significantly higher than that in group ADHD without DBD(13.8% vs 3.4%,χ2=3.940 P=0.047).The percentage of at least one DSM-Ⅳ axis-Ⅰ disorder in group ADHD plus DBD was significantly higher than that in group ADHD without DBD (37.9% vs 19.0%,χ2=5.124 P=0.024,OR=2.611,95%CI 1.123-6.072).The percentage of Cluster B personality disorder in group ADHD plus DBD was significantly higher than that in group ADHD without DBD(32.8% vs 6.9%,χ2=12.202 P0.001,OR=6.577,95%CI 2.074-20.859),in which the antisocial personality disorder was much higher in group ADHD plus DBD compared with group ADHD without DBD (29.3% vs 5.2%,χ2=11.842 P=0.001).The percentage of Cluster C personality disorder in group ADHD plus DBD was significantly lower than that in group ADHD without DBD(8.6% vs 22.8%,χ2=4.382 P=0.036,OR=0.319,95%CI 0.106-0.965).The percentage of at least one DSM-Ⅳ axis-I/axis-II disorder in group ADHD plus DBD was significantly higher than the group ADHD without DBD (56.9% vs 37.9%,χ2=4.184 P=0.041,OR=2.160,95%CI 1.028-4.539).Conclusions The childhood DBD represent risk factors for the adulthood development of severe psychopathy in the individuals with ADHD.Adults with childhood ADHD plus DBD frequently suffered significantly more often from adult ADHD,mood disorder,anxiety disorder,and Cluster B personality disorders (especially antisocial personality disorder) and had mild or moderate impairment of psychosocial functioning.