Abstract:China has introduced several pilot emission trading schemes to build the basis for a national scheme. The potential scale of this initiative raises prospects for a regional carbon trading network as a way to further engage other major Asian economies. However, the Chinese carbon markets rest upon a unique political-economic context and institutional environment that are likely to limit their development and viability. This article offers an overview of such structural economic and political constraints. Four main challenges are identified, namely, inadequate domestic demand, limited financial involvement, incomplete regulatory infrastructure, and excessive government intervention. The first two challenges concern economic dimensions and may be partially addressed by the incentives created by the newly introduced emission trading schemes. The other two are more deeply entrenched in the dominant political system and governing practice. They require fundamental changes to the ways in which the state and the market interact. The success of China's carbon market reform depends crucially on the ability of the ongoing efforts to transform the distorted state–market relationship. Policy relevance The burgeoning carbon markets offer opportunities for emissions mitigation at lower costs and enable circulation of a new form of capital, i.e. carbon credits, across borders. China accounts for a gigantic share of global GHG emissions and has the potential to significantly scale up these opportunities. There are clear implications for market developers and participants worldwide, including climate policy makers who attempt to link their emission trading schemes to other schemes, firms who seek to take advantage of the inexpensive carbon offsets generated in developing countries, international financial institutions who endeavour to establish their business in an emerging major carbon market, etc. This article can inform their decisions by identifying key issues that may undermine their ability to achieve these goals. Policy makers and stakeholders will benefit from this analysis, which shows how the Chinese carbon markets operate in ways that may be different from their experience elsewhere.

Legal Study of Carbon Trade in China

Carbon Markets in China: Development and Challenges

A study of legal attributes of carbon emission rights in carbon trading

Legal and Policy Pathways of Carbon Finance: Comparative Analysis of the Carbon Market in the EU and China

Discussion on Key Issues for Establishing Compliance Mechanism of CO2 Emissions Trading in China

How does global sustainable Policy influence Nation Policy -- A case Study of China

From Command And Control Regulations To A Business Proposition Creating A Chinese Market For Emissions Trading

Study of Chinese carbon emission trading market mechanism based on the game theory

A case study on China's carbon emission trading system: experiences and recommendations

Status and Experience of Carbon Trading Based on CDM Projects of Transportation

A Brief Discussion of the Legal System of Carbon Emissions Trading Market Regulation

Challenges to the development of carbon markets in China

Key Issues in Designing China'S National Carbon Emissions Trading System

Risk identification and regulatory system design for the carbon market

The Impact of Carbon Trading on Regulated Agents in China

Does China’s National Carbon Market Function Well? A Perspective on Effective Market Design

Research on the Development Status and Strategies of Carbon Emission Trading in China

Carbon finance and carbon market in China: Progress and challenges

International Cooperation Mechanisms for Carbon Reduction

International Carbon Markets under the Paris Agreement: Basic Form and Development Prospects

Crossing the river by feeling the stones: the case of carbon trading in China