Abstract:Introduction: The combination of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and electroencephalography (EEG) allows researchers to explore cortico-cortical connections. To study effective connections, the first few tens of milliseconds of the TMS-evoked potentials are the most critical. Yet, TMS-evoked artifacts complicate the interpretation of early-latency data. Data-processing strategies like independent component analysis (ICA) and the combined signal-space projection–source-informed reconstruction approach (SSP–SIR) are designed to mitigate artifacts, but their objective assessment is challenging because the true neuronal EEG responses under large-amplitude artifacts are generally unknown. Through simulations, we quantified how the spatiotemporal properties of the artifacts affect the cleaning performances of ICA and SSP–SIR. Methods: We simulated TMS-induced muscle artifacts and superposed them on pre-processed TMS–EEG data, serving as the ground truth. The simulated muscle artifacts were varied both in terms of their topography and temporal profiles. The signals were then cleaned using ICA and SSP–SIR, and subsequent comparisons were made with the ground truth data. Results: ICA performed better when the artifact time courses were highly variable across the trials, whereas the effectiveness of SSP–SIR depended on the congruence between the artifact and neuronal topographies, with the performance of SSP–SIR being better when difference between topographies was larger. Overall, SSP–SIR performed better than ICA across the tested conditions. Based on these simulations, SSP–SIR appears to be more effective in suppressing TMS-evoked muscle artifacts. These artifacts are shown to be highly time-locked to the TMS pulse and manifest in topographies that differ substantially from the patterns of neuronal potentials. Discussion: Selecting between ICA and SSP–SIR should be guided by the characteristics of the artifacts. SSP–SIR might be better equipped for suppressing time-locked artifacts, provided that their topographies are sufficiently different from the neuronal potential patterns of interest, and that the SSP–SIR algorithm can successfully find those artifact topographies from the high-pass-filtered data. ICA remains a powerful tool for rejecting artifacts that are not strongly time locked to the TMS pulse.

Can Back-Projection Fully Resolve Polarity Indeterminacy of Independent Component Analysis in Study of Event-Related Potential?

Analysis on subtracting projection of extracted independent components from EEG recordings.

Independent Component Analysis(ica) for Denoising EMG Signal from ECG Signal

Global optimal ICA and its application in MEG data analysis

Individual Independent Component Analysis on EEG: Event-Related Responses Vs. Difference Wave of Deviant and Standard Responses.

Dealing with ocular artifacts on lateralized ERPs in studies of visual-spatial attention and memory: ICA correction versus epoch rejection

Comparing ICA-based and Single-Trial Topographic ERP Analyses

The Improvement of ICA with Projection Technique in Multitask Fmri Data Analysis

[Extraction of Single-Trial Event-Related Potentials by Means of ARX Modeling and Independent Component Analysis].

Optimal selection of independent components for event-related brain electrical potential enhancement

Evaluating the effectiveness of artifact correction and rejection in event‐related potential research

Data-driven re-referencing of intracranial EEG based on independent component analysis (ICA)

Variational Bayes for spatiotemporal identification of event-related potential subcomponents

A Comparative Study of Different EEG Reference Choices for Event-Related Potentials Extracted by Independent Component Analysis

Separating 4D Multi-Task Fmri Data of Multiple Subjects by Independent Component Analysis with Projection.

Using independent component analysis to remove artifacts in visual cortex responses elicited by electrical stimulation of the optic nerve.

Effects of Independent Component Analysis on Magnetoencephalography Source Localization in Pre-surgical Frontal Lobe Epilepsy Patients

An improvement of independent component analysis with projection method applied to multi-task fMRI data.

Constrained ICA and Its Application to Removing Artifacts in EEG

On the independent component analysis of evoked potentials through single or few recording channels

A simulation study: comparing independent component analysis and signal-space projection – source-informed reconstruction for rejecting muscle artifacts evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation