Re-examining the Harmon Doctrine

胡德胜,张青

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16494/j.cnki.1002-3933.2013.07.027

2013-01-01

Abstract:Transboundary surface water resources play an essential role in the riparian states' social and economic development and are of vital importance for the eco-environmental protection.The distribution of benefits generated from their development and utilization has always been a focus of disputes among related riparian states,and this makes the Harmon Doctrine or the doctrine of absolute territorial sovereignty come into being for the benefits of upstream states.The emergence of this doctrine is the result of unity of contingency and inevitability,and its weakness has its roots in various objective and subjective conditions.Although the doctrine has never been widely respected in the academic circle completely or to any great extent,it has some realistic functions and positive effects,and constitutes the essential or vital consideration for the occurrence,emergence or development of other theories on transboundary water resources,and one should considered deeply about whether or not the Doctrine is really obsolete or buried in fact due to its being out of any merit.In conclusion,as one of the countries that have many transboundary rivers worldwide,China should understand this doctrine deeply in a comprehensive way,and pay attention to taking its advantages and avoiding its shortcomings in the process of formulating and implementing laws and policies concerning the development,utilization and protection of transboundary surface water resources.