Brand price competition's unsymmetrical effect

Hu Song,Zhao Ping,Qiu Xiao Dong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-0714.2006.08.079

2006-01-01

Abstract:The asymmetric effect of price competition indicates that high tier brand will attain more benefit on market share that low price brand.This article review the relevant literatures of price tier competition.It is useful for the Chinese pricing research and practice.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Effect of Price Promoting on Consumer Brand Choice

HU Song,ZHAO Ping,QIU Xiao-dong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1003-207X.2007.02.022

2007-01-01

Abstract:Through experimental study,the authors find that consumers have different price sensitivity to different product.The choice market share gained by low tier brand promotion is larger than high tier brand in comparatively expensive product such as lap-top,cell phone etc.,while the opposite result will be acquired in some comparatively cheap product,e.g.shampoo.The results give significant implications on pricing tactics for marketers in Chinese market.
The Influence of Capital Structure on Product Market Competition:A Theoretical Review

Pan Yueqi,Jia Shenghua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-9301.2011.01.011

2011-01-01

Abstract:This paper surveys theoretical models on capital structure and product market interplay,including the limited liability effect,the deep-pocket theory,two-stage switching cost models and competitive industry equilibrium models.For these models,we mainly focus on their key point,basic logic,mutual relations,internal structure and key literatures.Finally,we offer our conclusions and elaborate on this review article's implications for future research.
The impact of recommender systems and pricing strategies on brand competition and consumer search

Chi Zhou,Mingming Leng,Zhibing Liu,Xin Cui,Jing Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.elerap.2022.101144

IF: 6

2022-05-01

Electronic Commerce Research and Applications

Abstract:As a type of internet and business intelligence technology, recommender systems have been widely adopted by store brands to improve brand competition and to affect consumers' search behaviors in the e-commerce market. This paper studies the effects of recommender systems and pricing strategies on the competition between store brands and national brands and on consumers' search behaviors. We develop game models without and with recommender systems and analyze the equilibrium solutions under uniform pricing and differential pricing strategies. The results show that the brand-preference consumers' market share will affect the strategy choice of recommendation system and differential pricing for the store brand. When the store brand is recommended, the store brand should adopt the differential pricing strategy and the price of the store brand will exceed that of the national brand. Furthermore, we also find that when the brand-preference consumers' market share is low and the reservation price difference is high, the store brand can gain the competitive advantage by improving recommendation strength. In addition, a recommender system attracts consumers by converting their search costs into the recommendation costs of the system.

business,computer science, information systems, interdisciplinary applications
The Effect And Strategy Of High-Priced Level Premium Brand Products Price Reduction

Qiu Xiaodong,Hu Song,Zhao Ping

2007-01-01

Abstract:In the market level of high-priced products, firms that own premium brand, when they are trying to compete with other firms in the industry using price strategy, the implication of price strategy, if from the long run, is a positive or negative signal? This paper use testable empirical research method and systematically investigate the price reduction effect of premium brand. We find that using when premium brands using price strategy to compete with others, the effect is negative to the profitability of premium brands from the long run, as it reduces the profitability and premium ability of the brands that firms have built for a long time. That is, it is necessary for firms that own premium brands to deal with the competition from a totally new insight.
Market share analysis with brand effect

Zhixuan Fang,Longbo Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/cdc.2016.7799350

2016-12-01

Abstract:In this paper, we investigate the effect of brand in market competition. Specifically, we propose a variant Hotelling model where companies and customers are represented by points in an Euclidean space, with axes being product features. $N$ companies compete to maximize their own profits by optimally choosing their prices, while each customer in the market, when choosing sellers, considers the sum of product price, discrepancy between product feature and his preference, and a company's brand name. A company's brand name influence is modeled by a function of its market area in the form of $-\beta$. (Market Area) q, where $\beta$ is the weight of brand influence and $q$ captures how market share affects the brand. By varying the parameters $\beta$ and $q$, we derive existence results of Nash equilibrium and equilibrium market prices and shares. In particular, we prove that pure Nash equilibrium always exists when $q=0$ for markets with either one and two dominating features, and it always exists in a single dominating feature market when market affects brand name linearly, i.e., $q= 1$. Moreover, we show that at equilibrium, a company's price is proportional to its market area over the competition intensity with its neighbors, a result that quantitatively reconciles the common belief of a company's pricing power. We also study an interesting “wipe out” phenomenon that only appears when $q > 0$, which is similar to the “undercut” phenomenon in the Hotelling model, where companies may suddenly lose the entire market area with a small price increment. Our results offer novel insight into market pricing and positioning under competition with brand effect.
Competition Between Brand-Name and Generics--analysis on Pricing of Brand-Name Pharmaceutical.

Ying Kong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/hec.1392

IF: 2.395

2008-01-01

Health Economics

Abstract:The objective of this paper is to provide two-stage game models explaining the 'Generic Competition Paradox' that demonstrates an increase of brand-name drug price in response to generic entry. Under the assumption that there are two groups of consumers who are segmented by their insurance status, high insurance coverage and low insurance coverage consumers, the models indicate that the decisive factor is the market share of the high insurance coverage consumer and the size of cross-substitute factor relative to certain characteristics of market demand. The paper analyses both the case of only true generic entry and the case of pseudo-generic and true generic entry. The models prove that a brand-name price will increase when both the market share of high insurance coverage consumer and the factor of cross-substitute are small. Also, the 'Generic Competition Paradox' more likely occurs in the market where less pseudo-generic products are produced.
Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

Bing XU,Ping WANG,Bin ZHANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-0464.2018.01.017

2018-01-01

Abstract:Based on the Hotelling model,the game models were built to characterize the competition of one dual-channel retailer and one traditional retailer who are respectively located at two endpoints of linear market.The existence conditions and the equilibrium solutions for the competition equilibrium of two re-tailers were obtained under two situations such as differentiation pricing strategy and unified pricing strate-gy for products selling online and offline set by dual-channel retailer.The effectiveness of two pricing strat-egies and congestion negative effect affecting the competition equilibrium states were analyzed.Finally, some suggestions were proposed that the traditional retailer should speed up its transition and improve its service level,and the dual-channel retailer should make differentiation pricing for products selling online and offline and subdivide the market.
The effect and strategy of high-priced level premium brand products price reduction - An empirical research to auto industry

Xiaodong Qiu,Song Hu,Ping Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/WICOM.2007.1031

2007-01-01

Abstract:In the market level of high-priced products, firms that own premium brand, when they are trying to compete with other firms in the industry using price strategy, the implication of price strategy, if from the long run, is a positive or negative signal? This paper use testable empirical research method and systematically investigate the price reduction effect of premium brand. We find that using when premium brands using price strategy to compete with others, the effect is negative to the profitability of premium brands from the long run, as it reduces the profitability and premium ability of the brands that firms have built for a long time. That is, it is necessary for firms that own premium brands to deal with the competition from a totally new insight. © 2007 IEEE.
Price Competition Between a Dual-Channel Retailer and a Pure Online Retailer

Wang Chun-xu,Guo Jun,X.U. Chuan-Yong

2014-01-01

Abstract:Price competition between dual-channel and pure online retailers frequently occurs in reality, but the result is too complex to foresee. Pricing strategy and management advices are given in this paper to help enterprises solve problems of price competition. Focused on the price competition between a dual-channel retailer and a pure online retailer, and the uniform pricing strategy was adopted by the dual-channel retailer to avoid channel conflicts. A linear demand model which contained the substitution effect was adopted to characterize the competition between different channels and a non-cooperative game model was built to obtain the pricing equilibrium. Several specific scenarios were set to compare the pricing strategies of retailers. From the findings it can be concluded that whether the dual-channel retailer has an advantage over the pure online retailer in competition depends on the relative size of online market to the traditional channel market and the dual-channel retailer's main sales channel should be gradually shifted from the offline to online, and the traditional channel will be a complementary channel of online channel to improve the user experience. When the dual-channel retailer has no obvious advantage on market size, the pure online retailer will benefit more from price competition.
Effects of online reviews and competition on quality and pricing strategies

cui zhao,xiaojun wang,yongbo xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.13791

IF: 4.638

2022-01-01

Production and Operations Management

Abstract:By providing useful product information from the perspective of other buyers, online product/service reviews can help customers better evaluate the true quality of products and judge whether a product is a good fit for them. Based on online reviews, firms may improve product quality and/or adjust selling price to compete with other firms. In this study, we investigate the effects of online reviews on product quality and pricing decisions in a duopoly market that consists of two competing firms. Specifically, we consider a stylized two-period model and study the equilibrium decisions based on a Nash game framework. In the base scenario, the selling prices are exogenously given, and the firms decide on the product quality across two periods to optimize their respective profits. We study the equilibrium decisions in the static setting (in which the product quality remains the same across the two periods) and in the dynamic setting (in which the product quality can be improved in the second period), respectively. In the extended scenario, the selling prices can be endogenously determined as well. For each scenario, we compare the equilibrium decisions under dynamic competition with those under static competition through theoretical analysis and numerical experiments, which uncover some interesting managerial insights regarding the impact of online reviews under competition.
Dual-channel competition: the role of quality improvement and price-matching

Jinpeng Xu,Yufei Huang,Emmanouil Avgerinos,Gengzhong Feng,Feng Chu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2021.1931725

IF: 9.018

2021-06-06

International Journal of Production Research

Abstract:Quality improvement and price-matching are two commonly used competing strategies by the retailers. However, it is still unclear how the retailers should deliberate over the two strategies when selling in both online and offline markets. In this paper, we consider two dual-channel retailers selling a substitutable product to consumers in both online and offline markets. Especially, the retailers compete in the online market, and their offline markets are exclusive to themselves. We establish a game-theoretical model to investigate the trade-off between quality improvement and price-matching in competition, and the impact on retailers' profits and consumer surplus in the dual-channel market structure. The analysis shows that, first, a retailer should choose to improve its quality to avoid price competition when the online market is small; second, when retailers engage in price competition, the retailer with larger offline market is more willing to adopt price-matching, while the retailer with a small share of offline market can be hurt; third, quality improvement can always increase the consumer surplus, while price-matching always hurts consumer surplus due to price collusion.

engineering, manufacturing, industrial,operations research & management science
The Effect And Strategy Of Premium Brand Color Tv Price Reduction To Its Profitability

Xiaodong Qiu,Song Hu,Ping Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/WICOM.2007.1030

2007-01-01

Abstract:We find that using when premium brands using price strategy to compete with others, the effect is negative to the profitability of premium brands from the long run, as it reduces the profitability and premium ability of the brands that firms have built for a long time (Qiu et al. 2006). Then, how if the middle-level priced premium brand products reduce their prices and what will be the effect to the brand in the long run? We use color TV as an example and using the empirical research by interviewing customers and investigate the middle-level priced premium brand TVs price reduction effect on its profitability. Our results show that, the price reduction of middle-priced premium brand TVs, the effect is double-sided and the determinants of the direction of the effect is the price level in the group.
Influence of Online Reviews on the Dynamics of Product Quality and Pricing in a Competitive Market

Cui Zhao,Xiaoshuai Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10864415.2023.2226899

IF: 7.73

2023-07-10

International Journal of Electronic Commerce

Abstract:We study dynamic quality and pricing strategies in an e-platform with firm competition and online reviews by developing a two-period game-theoretical model. The results show that in equilibrium, online reviews lead to low selling prices in the early period but high product prices in the later selling period. On the side of equilibrium quality, online reviews will result in increased or reduced quality relying on the potential market size. Further, we examine the profit potential of the dynamic quality and/or dynamic price competition strategies. We find that the single dynamic quality competition strategy will always decrease profits of the firms. Regarding the single dynamic price competition strategy, it will increase profits of the rival firms with a large potential market size. Moreover, with a relatively large potential market size, the hybrid dynamic competition (dynamic quality and dynamic price competition) strategy is more likely to outperform the static competition strategy financially. Furthermore, we extend our model to examine how the quality and price strategies and the profit potential of dynamic competition strategies will change in the case of unit variable costs. We show from the extended analysis that in our setting, incorporating variable production costs does not alter the main findings of our research. The findings provide a decision-making framework for firms in choosing the initial and updated quality and price competition strategies with customer reviews.

business,computer science, software engineering
Reference-Dependent Utility, Product Variety, and Price Competition

Wilfred Amaldoss,Chuan He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2017.2834

IF: 5.4

2018-09-01

Management Science

Abstract:Products such as Nike running shoes, Gillette razors, and Gatorade sports drink serve as the standard against which consumers evaluate other members of the category. Empirical evidence suggests that consumers care about not only the consumption utility derived from a product, but also the gain–loss utility in comparison to the reference product of the category. This paper examines how reference-dependent utility affects price competition in a horizontally differentiated market where consumers’ tastes are diverse. When consumer valuations are low, the reference product is priced lower than a nonreference product. In contrast, when consumer valuations are high, the reference product is priced higher than a nonreference product. Moreover, loss aversion on the price dimension always intensifies competition among low-valuation goods, whereas loss aversion on the taste dimension softens competition among high-valuation goods only if consumer sensitivity to the difference in match quality is above a threshold. We also find that an increase in the diversity of consumers’ tastes reduces equilibrium profits if consumer valuation is low but has the opposite effect if consumer valuation is high. We further explore how an increase in the popularity of the reference product affects price competition. Finally, we assess the robustness of the findings by extending the model in different directions. The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2017.2834 . This paper was accepted by Juanjuan Zhang, marketing.

management,operations research & management science
Competitive Pricing Strategies in Social Networks

Ying-Ju Chen,Yves Zenou,Junjie Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3122763

2018-01-01

The RAND Journal of Economics

Abstract:We study pricing strategies of competing firms selling heterogeneous products to consumers. Goods are substitutes and there are network externalities between neighboring consumers. In equilibrium, firms price discriminate based on the network positions and charge lower prices to more central consumers. We also show that, under some conditions, firms' equilibrium profits decrease when either the network becomes denser or network effects increase. In contrast, consumers always benefit from being more connected to each other. We determine the optimal network structure and compare uniform pricing and discriminatory pricing from the perspectives of firms and consumers.
Competition in Dual Markets: Two Game-Theoretical Models on Pricing in Online versus Multiple Channels

Yuanzhu Lu, Xiaolin Xing, Fang-Fang Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17256/jer.2009.14.2.001

2009-01-01

Journal of Economic Research (JER)

Abstract:This paper develops two theoretical models to explain why multichannel retailers (MCRs) usually price higher than pure Internet retailers (DotComs), a regular pattern observed in many empirical studies. In the first game-theoretical model, we assume that the number of non-MCRs in the conventional market is exogenously determined, while consumers are classified into three discrete groups: (a) aggressive consumers, (b) discreet online consumers, and (c) offline consumers. We relax the first constraint in the second model so that all retailers in the Brick & Mortar sector are potential MCRs. Before setting prices, these retailers have to make their entry choices. Then, the pricing distribution becomes related to the factors such as the number of retailers in two markets, the search costs, and the pricing strategies of the retailers in the online market. We explore how the different types of retailers compete in the dual channels. We find that MCRs benet from the existence of their conventional stores, since they can charge higher prices than marginal production cost and earn positive profits. However, if DotComs cannot differentiate themselves by building loyal consumers or investing in the new technology, they face the severe competition both from their own type and from MCRs, and gain zero profits. The price dispersion may exist in the long term due to the pricing strategy for MCRs to conciliate the competition in online market.
Optimal pricing policies for differentiated brands under different supply chain power structures

Zheng Luo,Xu Chen,Jing Chen,Xiaojun Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2016.10.046

IF: 6.4

2017-06-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:We investigate a supply chain in which a retailer is supplied by two manufacturers with differentiated brands, a good brand and an average brand. The customers in the market are segmented based on value and brand preference, namely the customer acceptance of the average brand and the customer surplus for each brand. Both horizontal competition (between the two competing manufacturers) and vertical competition (between the manufacturers and the retailer) are considered through an exploration of different power structure combinations. Multiple-stage game models are developed to examine the impact of different power structures on the pricing decisions and the profits of the manufacturers and the retailer. We find that intensified competition between the two manufacturers hurts the manufacturers and benefits the retailer. No dominance among supply chain members (the two manufacturers and the retailer) leads to the highest profit for the entire supply chain. We also find that for the two competing manufacturers, being first to announce the pricing decision results in lower profit – the second to announce benefits from knowing the rival's price. This explains why rivals prefer not to reveal decisions on prices, bid rates, and contracts, as this information represents bargaining power. The impact of customer acceptance of the average brand is also analyzed.

operations research & management science
Consumer Heterogeneity and Pricing Strategies:A Quality-Price Competition Model

Xiao-dong SUN,Peng TIAN,Li ZHAO

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-2542.2013.03.009

2013-01-01

Abstract:We consider duopoly quality-price competition in a market with two types of consumers: price-sensitive consumers and quality-sensitive consumers.The characteristics of consumers are reflected by both the price sensitivity and the quality sensitivity.We first establish the utility function for each type of consumers and derive the demand function for every firm based on Hotelling model.Then,we analyze the duopoly quality-price competition under two pricing strategies: uniform pricing sand discriminatory pricing.The results show that under price discrimination the quality is higher than that under the uniform pricing strategy;firms set lower prices for price-sensitive consumers and higher price for quality-sensitive consumers.By comparisons,we conclude that the firms may carry out discriminatory pricing when consumer's transportation cost is high,and adopt uniform pricing when consumer's transportation cost is low.Additionally,the proportion of different types of consumers has significant impact on equilibrium prices and qualities.
Analysis of Price Competition in Two-Tier Service Systems

Wuhua Chen,Zhe George Zhang,Zhongsheng Hua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/jors.2015.123

IF: 3.6

2016-01-01

Journal of the Operational Research Society

Abstract:This article focusses on the issue of price competition of two private service providers (SPs) in a market with a free public SP. The two private SPs, differentiated by service quality and capacity, choose the optimal prices to maximize their own profits. It has been shown that such a price competition between the private SPs in a market with a public SP reaches a pure Nash equilibrium. Such a system with both private and public SPs is called a two-tier service system. We investigate the impact on the social welfare of the two-tier service system of the competition and collaboration between the two private SPs. In addition, we also examine the impact of the public SP’s competitive advantage on customer service and the private SP’s pricing strategies and their performance. Numerical examples are presented to generate managerial insights for practitioners.
Pricing strategies for competitive firms with indirect network effects

Wenzhu Zhang,Yue Dai,Lin Tian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10696-020-09383-7

IF: 2.2092

2020-01-01

Flexible Services and Manufacturing Journal

Abstract:In this paper, we analyze the impact of indirect network effects and competition on two firms each offering two complementary products. We first formulate the pricing game with general network effects and show that it is neither a supermodular nor a submodular game. We then derive the closed-form Nash equilibrium with linear demand functions. Furthermore, we examine a model with two symmetric firms each having a major product and a minor product, where the major product of one firm is the minor one of the other. We find that the impacts of network effects of major and minor products on the equilibrium prices are not symmetric. Moreover, as the substitution rate increases, the firm might partially sacrifice the major product market to boost the minor product market when the substitution rate is low and the network effect of the minor product is quite weak compared to that of the major product. Our numerical analysis shows that strong externalities between the two complementary products will benefit the firms. Finally, the models with symmetric product structures and generalized customer preference are analyzed to verify the robustness of the main results.

Brand price competition's unsymmetrical effect

The Effect of Price Promoting on Consumer Brand Choice

The Influence of Capital Structure on Product Market Competition:A Theoretical Review

The impact of recommender systems and pricing strategies on brand competition and consumer search

The Effect And Strategy Of High-Priced Level Premium Brand Products Price Reduction

Market share analysis with brand effect

Competition Between Brand-Name and Generics--analysis on Pricing of Brand-Name Pharmaceutical.

Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

The effect and strategy of high-priced level premium brand products price reduction - An empirical research to auto industry

Price Competition Between a Dual-Channel Retailer and a Pure Online Retailer

Effects of online reviews and competition on quality and pricing strategies

Dual-channel competition: the role of quality improvement and price-matching

The Effect And Strategy Of Premium Brand Color Tv Price Reduction To Its Profitability

Influence of Online Reviews on the Dynamics of Product Quality and Pricing in a Competitive Market

Reference-Dependent Utility, Product Variety, and Price Competition

Competitive Pricing Strategies in Social Networks

Competition in Dual Markets: Two Game-Theoretical Models on Pricing in Online versus Multiple Channels

Optimal pricing policies for differentiated brands under different supply chain power structures

Consumer Heterogeneity and Pricing Strategies:A Quality-Price Competition Model

Analysis of Price Competition in Two-Tier Service Systems

Pricing strategies for competitive firms with indirect network effects