Abstract:Abstract The need to evaluate natural resource investments under uncertainty has given rise to the development of real options valuation; however, the analysis of such investments has been restricted by the capabilities of existing valuation approaches. We re-visit the well-known example of a copper mine project under a one-factor and two multi-factor models using the influence diagram simulation-and-regression (IDSR) approach. The one-factor setting was originally proposed by Brennan and Schwartz (J Bus 58(2):135–157, 1985), who used partial differential equations (PDEs) and finite differences to approximately solve the valuation problem; extensions to two and three factors were later analysed by Tsekrekos et al. (Eur Financ Manag 18(4):543–575, 2012) using the least-squares Monte Carlo method. We apply the IDSR approach to perform a detailed portfolio analysis of the one-factor benchmark investment and find issues in both the definitions and values of the fixed-output-rate mine and closure option at the portfolio decomposition stage in Brennan and Schwartz (1985). We then apply the IDSR approach to re-evaluate two multi-factor extensions of Tsekrekos et al. (2012) and detect issues in their sensitivity analyses that impact on the reliability of some of their findings. To confirm this and validate the values we obtained, we integrate PDE-based analytical expressions that describe the volatilities implied by the multi-factor models into our IDSR-based analysis. Using the investment-uncertainty relationship, we are able to correctly analyse the impact of the complex multi-factor model parameters on investment value. We conclude that the limitations of PDE-based finite difference approaches may invalidate their use in portfolio situations, but analytical expressions obtained from PDE-based modelling may be profitably integrated into a simulation-based, numerical analysis to validate results and gain new insights.

Valuation Model of Mineral Resource Based on Real Option

The Valuation of the Multistage Investment in an E&P Project Using a Four-Fold Compound Option

Study on the Real Option in the Value Estimate of Coal Resources

Kalman Filtering-Based Approach for Project Valuation of an Iron Ore Mining Project Through Spot Price and Long-Term Commitment Contracts

The Theory of Real Option Pricing Model in the Application of Risk Investment Decisions

Timing Decisions of Housing Sales and Development Based on Real Option Theory

A Multi-Stage Dynamic Decision-Making Model Of Mine Resources Exploitation With Many Running Units-Theoretical Analysis

Model Risk in Real Option Valuation

The Sunk Cost and the Real Option Pricing Model

Real Option Characters of Petroleum Exploration and Development Projects

Estimation of Stage Volatility in Real Options of Petroleum Exploration

Portfolio Real Option Based on Trigeminal Tree Model in Sustainable Utilization of Exploration Asset

Application of Real Options in Project Portfolio Selection

Risk-Adjusted Valuation for Real Option Decisions

STUDY ON STRATEGIC ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF OIL & GAS EXPLORATION PROJECTS BASED ON COMPOUND REAL OPTIONS

A Real Options Analysis for Renewable Energy Investment Decisions under China Carbon Trading Market

Review on Real Option Theory of Land Investment Decision

Study on the Application of Real Options in Coal Resources Investment

Modeling And Pricing Of China Venture Capital Incentive Tax Policy Based On Option Theory

Re-evaluating natural resource investments under uncertainty: An alternative to limited traditional approaches

Evaluating real estate development project with Monte Carlo based binomial options pricing model