A New Approach to Management Methodology:Quasi-Experimentation Design Based Field Research
MIAO Qing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2007.06.008
2007-01-01
Abstract:The article introduces the Quasi-Experimentation Design based Field Research(QEDFR)from the concept,innovation,designing case,implementation and statistic power for the sake of promoting local research practices and development in the future.Management research in china still rests on the large scale survey,which are confronted by many limitations,including randomized sampling challenge,accurate measurement challenge and causality challenge.In the condition of more and more complex management phenomenon,QEDFR has to be strengthened urgently.Manipulation and control are the two fundamental requirements for conducting experimentation.QEDFR not only embodies those advantages,but also characterizes the integration of low subjects randomization and field observation.The innovation of QEDFR comprises of 8 aspects,including independent variable manipulation,irrelevant variable control,large range of research interests,long-term sustainable effects,moderate total costs,definite causal relationship,high probability of represented reality,and low subjects randomization.These features reflect the relative advantages to the survey,lab,etc.QEDFR has two kinds of research designs.The most common design of QEDFR is nonequivalent control group design.The main principle is the simultaneous application of experimented group and comparative group.Through the manipulation of independent variable by researchers,the variance can be observed accordingly.This approach must conduct pre-test and post-test within both groups,so as to confirm that the variance is caused only by the independent variables.Another approach is the interpreted time series design,which requires the dependent variable to be tested in multiple times during the observations.The demand of frequent tests could exactly demonstrate the effect and its time-lasting degree influenced by the independent variable which often relies on the monthly performance appraisal.A case about the relationship of payment styles and individual job performance is illustrated to specify the application of the above designs.The essay offers two points for the QEDFR implementation as well as the statistical power.Firstly,situational factors including four kinds of problems are the most important basis while conducting QEDFR.They are underestimation of controlling exogenous variables,the change or destroy of real situation,the limited generalization of the specific situation,the researcher's authority imposed on the subjects.Secondly,subjects and related factors are the activated variance which cannot be neglected by the researchers.These factors have four dimensions,including preventing the subjects' treatment prescience,restricting subjects' interaction,focusing on the individual difference and the randomization difficulty.The preferred sample size of QEDFR ranges between 30—150.If the minimum number is lower than 30,the probability of category II,statistical error will increase.Meanwhile,if the maximum number is higher than 150,the probability of category I,statistical error will be enhanced.