Abstract:The optimal choice of the planetary boundary layer (PBL) parameterization scheme is of particular interest and urgency to a wide range of scholars, especially for many works involving models. At present, there have been many works to evaluate the PBL schemes. However, little research has been conducted into a more comprehensive and systematic assessment of the performance capability of schemes in key regions of China, especially when it comes to the differences in the mechanisms of the schemes themselves, primarily because there is scarcely sufficient observational data, computer resources, and storage support to complete the work. In this companion paper (i.e., Part 1), four typical schemes (i.e., YSU, ACM2, BL, and MYJ) are selected to systematically analyze and evaluate near-surface meteorological parameters, PBL vertical structure, PBL height (PBLH), and turbulent diffusion coefficient (TDC) in five key regions of China (i.e., North China Plain, NCP; Yangtze River Delta, YRD; Sichuan Basin, SB; Pearl River Delta, PRD and Northwest Semi-arid region, NS) in different seasons (i.e., January, April, July, and October). The differences in the simulated 2 m temperatures between the nonlocal closure schemes are mainly affected by the downward shortwave radiation, but to compare the nonlocal closure schemes with the local closure schemes, the effect of sensible heat flux needs to be further considered. The 10 m wind speed is under the influence of factors like the momentum transfer coefficient and the integrated similarity functions at night. The wind speeds are more significantly overestimated in the plains and basin, while less overestimated or even underestimated in the mountains, as a result of the effect on topographic smoothing in the model. Moreover, the overestimation of small wind speeds at night is attributable to the inapplicability of the Monin–Obukhov similarity theory (MOST) at night. The model captures the vertical structure of temperature well, while the wind speed is outstandingly overestimated below 1000 m, largely because of the TDC. The difference between the MOST and the mixing length theory, PBLH, and Prandtl number is cited as the reason for the difference between the TDC of the YSU and ACM2 schemes. The TDCs of the BL and MYJ schemes are affected by the mixing length scale, which of BL is calculated on the basis of the effect of buoyancy, while MYJ calculates it with the consideration of the effect of the total turbulent kinetic energy. The PBLH of the BL scheme is better than the other schemes because of the better simulation results of temperature.

The effect of MYJ and YSU schemes on the simulation of boundary layer meteorological factors of WRF

An Evaluation of the Mellor-Yamada-Janjić Formulation Parameters for the QNSE Scheme in the WRF Model over the Lower Yangtze River Valley

Effects of different topographic correction methods on the simulation of surface wind speed and temperature in parameterization scheme of the YSU boundary layer

A Modified Double-Moment Bulk Microphysics Scheme Geared Toward the East Asian Monsoon Region

OPTIMIZATION TEST FOR MICROPHYSICAL AND BOUNDARY LAYER PARAMETERIZATION OF HIGH-IMPACT ZHEJIANG TYPHOONS BY WRF MODEL

Evaluation and improvement study of the Planetary Boundary-Layer schemes during a high PM2.5 episode in a core city of BTH region, China

Simulating the Wind Energy Distribution in the Coastal Hilly Area of the Jiaodong Peninsula Using the Weather Research and Forecasting Model

The Effects of Different Microphysical Schemes in WRF on the Rainstorm of Typhoon Fitow in 2013

Modification Tests for the Coefficient of Turbulent Mixing Length Scale in QNSE Scheme in the WRF Model

Impacts of Urbanization and its Parameters on Thermal and Dynamic Fields in Hangzhou: A Sensitivity Study Using the Wrf-Urban Model

Simulation Experiments with Different Planetary Boundary Layer Schemes in the Lower Reaches of the Yangtze River

Effect of Soil Texture and Hydraulic Parameters on WRF Simulations in Summer in East China

Comprehensive evaluation of typical planetary boundary layer (PBL) parameterization schemes in China – Part 1: Understanding expressiveness of schemes for different regions from the mechanism perspective

Simulating Flow and Dispersion by Using WRF-CFD Coupled Model in a Built-Up Area of Shenyang, China

Simulation of Urban Heat Island Effect and Its Impact on Atmospheric Boundary Layer Structure over Yangtze River Delta Region in Smnmer

Influences of Planetary Boundary Layer Mixing Parameterization on Summertime Surface Ozone Concentration and Dry Deposition over North China

Evaluation and Analysis of WRF-simulated Meteorological Variables in the Urban and Semi-Arid Areas of China

The Influence of Refined Urban Morphological Parameters on Dynamical and Thermal Fields in a Single-Layer Urban Canopy Model

Influence on the temperature estimation of the planetary boundary layer scheme with different minimum eddy diffusivity in WRF v3.9.1.1

Assessment of Different Boundary Layer Parameterization Schemes in Numerical Simulations of Typhoon Nida (2016) Based on Aircraft Observations

The Influence of Dry Deposition on Surface Ozone Simulations under Different Planetary Boundary Layer Schemes over Eastern China