Abstract:Apology is one of the forms of tortuous liabilities when a right of personality is infringed under Chinese law. Regarding whether this is a constitutional or reasonable rule in law, a heated argument is going on among Chinese scholars. This paper argues that, apology helps to redress a victim's emotional and psychological wounds, therefore serves the function to repair harm just as other forms of tortuous liabilities. If the defendant fails to make an appropriate apology voluntarily before the end of court debate, the court should order the defendant to apologize in the judgment. Although an apology under a judgment may be insincere, it is still valuable for many victims. Moreover, based on the theory of cognitive dissonance, the judgment may induce the defendant to adjust his attitude and lead to a sincere apology. The most difficult part of this question is the compulsory enforcement of apology. This paper examines the possible measures of enforcement provided in the civil procedure law. Indirect enforcement measures, mainly fine or imprisonment, are unconstitutional in light of the principle of proportionality for violation of the freedom of expression, freedom of religion and human dignity protected by Chinese constitution. Publication of the content of judgment is not an appropriate form of substitutional enforcement because it cannot reach a similar effect as apology. Another suggestion, that the plaintiff or the court drafts a letter of apology on behalf of the defendant and publishes it when the defendant refuses to do so, also flaws. This paper proposes a special form of subsitutional enforcement that the victim should be allowed to publish a declaration of reprimand and the defendant should be ordered to pay the cost, because a reprimand by the victim could redress his emotional and psychological wounds as well as a personal apology of the defendant. If the victim doesn't want to do so, a sum of money, the amount of which is determined in the judgment, should be paid by the defendant.

Pragmatic Studies on Apologies and the Improvement of " Meier's Repair Work"

Politeness Phenomena In Ancient China: An Analysis Of A Dream Of Red Mansions

Apologies in Emails: Interactions Between Chinese EFL Learners and Their Foreign Peers

What Makes An Apology More Effective? Exploring Anthropomorphism, Individual Differences, And Emotion In Human-Automation Trust Repair

Use of Apology Strategies in Emails by Chinese Learners of English: Evidence Based on Naturally Occurring Data

A Pragmatic Study of Chinese and Western Linguistic Politeness

Misunderstanding in Cross-cultural Communication ——A Comparative Study of Expressions of Politeness in French and Chinese

A Study of Pragmatic Failures in Cross-Cultural Communication

The Restorative Role of Apology in Resolving Medical Disputes: Lessons From Chinese Legal Culture

Appreciation vs. apology: Research on the influence mechanism of chatbot service recovery based on politeness theory

The Liability of Apology in Civil Law and its Compulsory Enforcement

A Pragmatic Study of Euphemisms

Repairing damaged professional relationships with leader apologies: An examination of trust and forgiveness

A Cognitive Study on Politeness Intention Processing and Its Association with Pragmatic Failure in Cross-Cultural Communication

A Study on the Pragmatic Distinction of Chinese and English Politeness Principle

Using Corpus-Linguistic Methods to Track Longitudinal Development: Routine Apologies in the Study Abroad Context

Leader Apology in the Employee–Organization Relationship: The Roles of Subordinate Power Distance Belief and Leader Competence

Exploring Apology Strategy by Indonesian Public Figures: A Pragmatic Study in Social Media

Can an apology change after-crisis user attitude? The role of social media in online crisis management

A Study of Politeness in Chinese and English Culture and Cross-cultural Pragmatic Failure

Analysis of Speech Act Between SA and AH Chinese L2 Speakers of English—With Regard to Request Refusal, and Apology Strategies