Abstract:Performance evaluations often convey values promoted by the government. However, it is unclear in the Chinese context what 'performance' means when referring to appraised values because little empirical evidence exists, particularly regarding the relations between values. This study examines Hangzhou, a pioneering case among Chinese municipalities of comprehensive performance evaluation, to analyze the relations between values. We examined 2,422 performance evaluation reports and policies released to the public. After conducting content and social network analyses, we theorized the public values structure were composed of relations of hierarchy, proximity, and causality. Our findings indicate prime values were listed prior to instrumental or market-driven values. The proximity between public interest and quality is demonstrated by the highest correlation coefficients. Each value cluster contains a causal relationship, indicating one value is the means to another. We discuss the values-oriented approach to performance evaluation, the contextual nature of public values studies, and the limits of using public satisfaction in performance evaluation. As an exploratory study, this work identifies values advocated by local governments in China; such findings are absent from existing research. Moreover, this study provides a practical method for empirically studying public values.

A Consideration to the Role of Government Involvement in Social Organization Evaluation

Study On Exchange Relationship Between Government And Non-Governmental Organization

Several Thoughts on the Evaluation of Nongovernmental Organization

The Exploration of A New Type of Social Organization:An Investigation on Possibilities of Government's Empowerment of Society through the Practice of Social Composite Subject in Hangzhou

Evaluating Government Portal Websites in China.

The Role of Government in the Development of Self-Help Organizations

Do Civic Education Influences Matter? China'S Civic Education And Its Implication To The Transition Of Governance

Administration: Reconsideration of the Theory of Relation Between a Country and Its Citizen Society

Evaluation on the Participant Evaluation System on Government Performance

Public Participation, Expert Knowledge and Performance Evaluation Mode of the Government:An Inquiry for Analytical Framework of Performance Evaluation Mode of the Government

Necessary and Theoretical Ideas of Developing the Public Benefit Evaluation Instrument for Public Medical Institutions

Quality Evaluation of Government Information Resources Based on Public Participation

What Is Government?——A Premise Analysis of Chinese Government's Reformation and Construction

Study On Comprehensive Effect Evaluation Of E-Government

Double Building of the Government and Society:The Practical Proposition of Public Governance

The role and influencing factors of government performance evaluation: A test of Chinese public officials’ perceptions in Gaoming district

On Consideration of Government Organization Forms in Network Era

Analysis of the New Character of Government Performance Evaluation of Western Government from the Visual of Compare

An Exploratory Study on the Assessment Model of E-Government in China.

The balancing role of evaluation mechanisms in organizational governance—The case of publicly funded research institutions

What Values Are Evaluated? an Exploratory Empirical Study of the Public Values Structure in Chinese Local Government Performance Evaluation Through the Case of the ‘hangzhou Model’