Abstract:This paper considers finitely many investors who perform mean-variance portfolio selection under relative performance criteria. That is, each investor is concerned about not only her terminal wealth, but how it compares to the average terminal wealth of all investors. At the inter-personal level, each investor selects a trading strategy in response to others' strategies. This selected strategy additionally needs to yield an equilibrium intra-personally, so as to resolve time inconsistency among the investor's current and future selves (triggered by the mean-variance objective). A Nash equilibrium we look for is thus a tuple of trading strategies under which every investor achieves her intra-personal equilibrium simultaneously. We derive such a Nash equilibrium explicitly in the idealized case of full information (i.e., the dynamics of the underlying stock is perfectly known) and semi-explicitly in the realistic case of partial information (i.e., the stock evolution is observed, but the expected return of the stock is not precisely known). The formula under partial information consists of the myopic trading and intertemporal hedging terms, both of which depend on an additional state process that serves to filter the true expected return and whose influence on trading is captured by a degenerate Cauchy problem. Our results identify that relative performance criteria can induce downward self-reinforcement of investors' wealth--if every investor suffers a wealth decline simultaneously, then everyone's wealth tends to decline further. This phenomenon, as numerical examples show, is negligible under full information but pronounced under partial information.

Information, Expected Utility, and Portfolio Choice

Information Choice, Uncertainty, and Expected Returns

Information Uncertainty and Expected Returns

Preliminary Version Information , Diversification , and Cost of Capital ∗ †

Welfare effects of information and rationality in portfolio decisions under parameter uncertainty

The Price of Information

Consumption utility-based pricing of the option to invest with partial information

Risk Preferences and Efficiency of Household Portfolios

Private Information , Diversification , and Asset Pricing ∗ †

Private Information, Diversiflcation, and Asset Pricing ⁄y

Information, Diversiflcation, and Asset Pricing ⁄y

Partial Information in a Mean-Variance Portfolio Selection Game

Information, Diversification, and Cost of Capital

Utility Maximization and Indifference Value under Risk and Information Constraints for a Market with a Change Point

Informational efficiency and welfare

Optimal information acquisition for eliminating estimation risk

Expected utility maximization for an insurer with investment and risk control under inside information

Asymmetry of Risk and Value of Information

Comparative study of information measures in portfolio optimization problems

Adaptive Expectations, Confirmatory Bias, and Informational Efficiency

Portfolio choice in the model of expected utility with a safety-first component