Abstract:Abstract Universities in the United States are remarkably diverse in their efficiency, both in terms of research output and educational achievement. Recent work has highlighted how important this heterogeneity is by showing that different broad categories of institutions demonstrate different scaling relationships for various features as a function of the number of students. These differences in scaling relationships reflect differences in organizational goals, constraints, and strategies. In the existing literature, this heterogeneity is under-explored and often ignored due to the lack of appropriate data and methodological limitations. In this paper, we address this problem by exploiting a newly consolidated dataset and adopting a neural-network based method to infer cost functions for universities. Our analyses reveal (1) the specific economy of scale in two distinct output types (education and research), (2) the nature of the trade-off between research and education efficiency, and (3) significant efficiency differences across universities. Particularly, we show that while both research and education outputs generally exhibit an economy of scale, their scalability largely depends on their size and other institutional characteristics. Similarly, research and education activities are complementary to each other (economy of scope) only in some situations, particularly when the scale of production is small to medium. Consequently, the cost isoclines of universities are highly non-convex, implying the possibility of multiple optima that may explain the diverse strategies universities adopt, and potential efficiency gains from specialization. It also suggests that some basic assumptions of microeconomic models may not be empirically supported.

Economies of Scope in Higher Education——An Evaluation Based on CES Cost Function

Economies of Scope in Distance Education: the Case of Chinese Research Universities

Multi-product Total Cost Functions for Higher Education: the Case of Chinese Research Universities

Regional Differences in Economies of Scale and Economies of Scope in Chinese Higher Education

On the Economy of Scale and Scope of Mass Higher Education in China

Screening Device and Segmentation Effects——A Theoretic Analysis to the Urban-rural Defference in the Higher Educational Investment in China

Economies of Scale and Scope in Internationalisation: Evidence from Chinese Universities

Scale and scope economies of distance education in Australian universities

Cost-Benefit Analysis and Evaluation of Education Informatization in Colleges and Universities

Dynamic Input-Output Model and Its Application in Higher Educational Costs Analysis

Evaluation of cost-effectiveness and economies of scope of network systems with discretionary indicators

Economies of scale or scope? The development strategies of university and its impact on research productivity in China

Efficiency, costs, rankings and heterogeneity: the case of US higher education

Quantitative Analysis on Coordinated Development of Higher Education-Population-Economy System

An Exploration to the Empirical Study and Econometric Techniques of Internal Efficiency of Higher Education Institutions

The Trend of Cost of Higher Education:A Human Capital Perspective

Cost of research and education activities in US colleges - scalability, complementarity, and heterogeneous efficiency

An Empirical Study on the Relationship Evolution of Higher Education Scale and Economic Growth in China

A Study on the Equity and Efficiency of Area Higher Education in China from 1990 to 2000

The Economical Analysis on the Financial Expenditure of Higher Education in China

Theoretical Analysis & Research Demonstration of China's Higher Education Financial Input in the Future Ten Years