Review of the Theory of Board Governance and Research Schemes
Niu Jianbo,Song Xiaoyang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2009.01.018
2009-01-01
Abstract:Focusing on the theme of the governance of boards of directors ,we review and synthesize empirical research findings on the impact of boards of directors on corporate performance,and confirm the basic theories from recent decades.The limitations of different theories and relevant prior studies are also discussed.These works are beneficial to advancing our understanding of the mechanism of boards Of directors and improving their practical effects. Furthermore,we construct an integrative model of board attributes (composition,characteristics,structure,and process),roles(service, strategy,and control),and performance(accounting performance, financial performance,investment return,market performance,social performance and innovation) with the internal context(ownership structure,firm life cycle,CEO-style,company size,corporate resource situation) and external context(industry type,institutional investors,legal requirements,and governance scandals).Existing research evidence on board variables incorporated into this model helps to explain the major shortcomings of previous studies.From this model we can see that there is less knowledge about the direction and mechanism of the impact of characteristics and roles of boards of directors on firm performance,especially considering the evolution of governance practices and the dynamic nature of external regulations and other environments.Thus,we still have plenty of opportunities to expand the research in many aspects and fields. We offer an agenda for future studies in this promising area of empirical research,which will be helpful in validating the links among board variables,roles,company performance,and documenting effects of changes in board variables and circumstances on changes in company performance.This includes features such as paying more attention to field studies of how boards make their decisions considering their structure and processes,broadening the definition of company performance in the literature,conducting comparative research on board attributes,including international comparisons,and exploring the lag effect of board characteristics on organizational effectiveness criteria.