Money Is Not Everything: Political Contributions and Legislative Cosponsorship in Chinese Taiwan
Chao Chen,Hua Tang,Rui Wang
2023-01-01
Abstract:Beyond partisanship, what can foster cosponsorship of proposals in a legislature filled with intense partisan competition? To answer this question, using public materials released by Taiwan's Supervision Yuan and Legislative Yuan, this article established two networks of members of the 9th Legislative Yuan: the Contribution Similarity Network (CSN) and the Joint Proposal Network (JPN). The CSN connects 2,649 companies and 168 corporation groups with legislators through political donations, while the JPN connects legislators to each other in terms of their cosponsorships. The results indicate that political contribution similarity is an important factor in the co-signing behavior of legislators, but the influence varies by legislative topic. Specifically, legislators who receive similar corporate donations are more likely to cosponsor proposals that are not controversial and opposed by the public ("uncertain vote proposals"), such as financial and industrial development proposals. In contrast, political contribution similarity has no significant effect on the cosponsorship of "vote-risk proposals," such as labor and human resources policies and environment and resources policies, because these proposals are prone to social controversy and backlash. These findings reveal the specific characteristics of "crony capitalism" in Taiwan's legislature. They also imply that, when examining the electoral system in Taiwan, money politics is as important as party politics, and the logic of the former does not completely coincide with that of the latter.