Current Practice of Psychological Assessment.

JA SWEENEY,JF CLARKIN,ML FITZGIBBON
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/0735-7028.18.4.377
1987-01-01
Abstract:A survey was conducted to evaluate current psychological testing practice in acute care inpatient settings. Findings indicated that psychologists typically continue to use the standard test battery developed by Rapaport, Gill, and Schafer in the 1940s. We outline an alternative problemoriented approach to assessment that seems better suited for short-term care settings. In this model the primary assessment strategy emphasizes rapid assessment of symptoms and problem areas rather than comprehensive personality assessment. The aims and procedures of psychological testing have been matters of dispute for many years (Meehl, 1954). Authors have presented differing views regarding the importance of assessing situational versus intrapsychic determinants of behavior (Mischel, 1968), the use of a standard battery versus tests selected to focus on a patient's presenting problems (Schafer, 1967), and the relative value of objective versus projective tests (Megaree, 1966). The most common ideological differences about the aim of assessment have centered on whether to construct a comprehensive personological description of the patient or to describe overt problems. We advocate the use of the latter for short-term inpatient psychiatric hospitalizations. A model focusing on the description of overt problems and symptomatology is potentially more beneficial to a patient than are the results of a comprehensive test battery. A focused problem-oriented assessment is a more efficient use of what typically is limited professional staff time and is focused on the immediate clinical problems that require hospital care.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?