High-performance Human Resource Management System in Transitional China:A Contextualizing Research
Su Zhongxing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2010.04.012
2010-01-01
Abstract:Since the 1990s,in the western countries,a large number of empirical studies have revealed positive relationships between human resource management systems and firm performance.In recent years,similar studies have been conducted in China.We argue that,HR practices appearing in Anglo-American literature may not necessarily be the best choices for Chinese firms due to the unique management context and the stage of social and economic development in China.Unfortunately,all previous China-based empirical studies adopted the approach of measuring HRM systems in Chinese firms with western high-commitment,high-involvement,or high-performance work system scales.Consequently,these empirical studies just test the external validity of western SHRM models,rather than examining what might constitute best China-specific HR practices.In response,based on the analysis of the Chinese management context,through examining the HR practices suggested in western research as well as researching local Chinese perceptions of effective HR practices,we construct a model of China-based high-performance HRM system and test its effects on firm performance.Results show that China-based high-performance HRM system consists of some typical western high-performance work practices as well as some China-specific HR practices.It has 8 dimensions:extensive training,employee competition and discipline management,information sharing,strict selection,results-oriented performance appraisal,compensation,internal labor market,and employee participation.The emergence of the dimension of employee competition and discipline management is the result of China's unique management context.It was demonstrated that China-based high-performance HRM system was strongly related to the measure of firm performance among a sample of 149 Chinese firms.Further analysis revealed that for Chinese firms,employee competition and discipline management,results-oriented performance appraisals,compensation,and strict employee selection have much more significant positive effects on firm performance compared with extensive training,information sharing,employee participation,and internal labor market.In sum,this study offers a number of contributions compared with some "replication and extension" studies.It highlights deep contextualization,linking high-performance HRM system to the Chinese management reality,and provides the evidence that the effectiveness of a HRM system needs to be understood in certain management context.The results of this study also show how a context-specific approach to the conceptualization and measurement of HR constructs can provide more insight into the HR-performance relationship.