T-plate Fixation and Open Reduction of Distal Radius Fractures:A Meta-analysis

ZHANG Chun,LIU Shi-qing,CHEN Zi-jian,LIAO Qi

2012-01-01

Abstract:Objective To compare the therapeutic effect of open reduction and T-plate fixation with simple manual reduction and plaster fixation for the treatment of distal radius fractures to provide references for the appropriate treatment selection.Methods Such datebases as PubMed,Cochrane Library,EMBASE,Medline,CNKI,CBM,VIP and Wanfang were searched from their establishment to January 31st 2012 for collecting the RCT about open reduction and T-plate fixation VS simple manual reduction and plaster fixation for the treatment of distal radius fractures,and the references of those RCTs were also searched from printed Chinese journals of orthopedic surgery by hand.After study selection,assessment and date extraction were conducted by two reviewers independently,meta-analyses were performed by RevMan 5.1 software.Results Three studies involving 171 patients were included.The results of meta-analyses showed that:open reduction and fixation of the T-plate was more effective than manual reduction and plaster external fixationin improvingthe radial axial length(the difference was statistically significant,MD=-1.98,95% CI-3.12-0.84,P<0.05),there was no significant differences of the recovery of palm dip(MD=1.69,95% CI-0.3-3.41,P=0.05),there was no significant differences of the recovery of ulnar deviation(MD=-1.50,95% CI-5.47-2.47,P>0.05).Conclusion Open reduction and T-plate fixation and simple manual reduction and plaster external fixation can both improve symptoms in patients of distal radius fractures with similar clinical efficacy.However,due to the lower quality of the original research affecting the authenticity of the conclusions,it is suggested that clinicians should be concerned about the patient′s requirements and expectations when referring to the conclusion.