Comparison of the influence of mechanical and laser methods for biopsy of blastomeres or polar bodies on the development of embryo and pregnancy in PGD cycles

Lian Ying,Liu Ping,Huang Jin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-7379.2007.10.014

2007-01-01

Abstract:Objective:To compare the results of the PGD by mechanical and laser methods in order to find an optimal and safe method for embryo or occyte biopsy.Methods:Twenty-one PGD-IVF cycles for 20 couples were included overall,during one and a half years period.The embryo biopsy was carried out by mechanical method or laser at 6~8-cell stage on day 3.One or two blastomeres were removed from each embryo.The nuclei of all blastomeres were analyzed by FISH procedure.Normal embryos were transferred on day 5 or day 6.Oocytes were biopsied and the first polar bodies were fixed within 6 hours after oocyte retrieval.After that,oocytes were inseminated by ICSI,while the polar bodies were analyzed by FISH.The normal embryos were transplanted 6 days after oocytes collection.Results:A total of 145 embryos underwent blastomere biopsy.There was no significant difference in clinic pregnancy rate(38.46% vs 16.67%),implantation rate(21.43% vs 8.33%) and blastocyst rate on D5/D6(33.94% vs 44.44%) between the two groups biopsied by mechanical method and laser.In total,27 oocytes were analysed.There was no significant difference in 2pn insemination rate(58.33% vs 46.66%),after growth rate(66.67% vs 60.00%) post biopsy,successful fixing rate(83.33% vs 28.75),whereas FISH signal positive rate(90.00% vs 28.75%) was significant different between the two groups.Conclusion:Both mechanical method and laser for zona drilling in cases of PGD can get similar clinical pregnancy rate and implantation rate.In spite of that,it is better in all parameters with mechanical biopsy.It is advantageous to use mechanical method for zona drilling.