Role of Mast Cells in Acupuncture Analgesia : A Pilot Study
Guanghong Ding,Di Zhang,Xueyong Shen,Wei Yao
2007-01-01
Abstract:Acupuncture has been practiced throughout Asia for more than 4000 years, however, acupuncture analgesia for surgical procedures was only developed and first used in 1958. The basic mechanism reason for better analgesia effects by stimulation of acupoints than of non-acupoints still remains inconclusive. In this work, the role of mast cells in acupuncture analgesia was investigated in Sprague Dawley (SD) rats. Acupuncture delivered to Zusanli (ST36) significantly increased mast cell degranulation in the acupoint and increased pain threshold (as indicated by increased latency of tail flick response), while injection of disodium chromoglycate (DSCG) to Zusanli (ST36) significantly inhibit mast cell degranulation and attenuated the acupuncture effect. We suggest that mast cell degranulation plays a role in acupuncture-induced analgesia. INTRODUCTION Acupuncture is a traditional Chinese therapeutic technique and used widely for pain management However, the mechanisms underlying the acupuncture-induced analgesia are not well understood. One of the major problems remains unsolved is what the physical basis of meridian is if they exist. More recent researches have focused on the correlation between acupuncture points, meridians and connective tissues. Durimng acupuncture, needles pull and distort the surrounding tissue and thus deliver mechanical signals to the cellular level, leading to "downstream effects" that could activate certain cellular pathways and facilitate healing. Based on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), anatomical and X-ray Computed Tomography (XCT) of morphological location, all point to the probability that the physical basis of meridians and acupoints was in a complex system mainly of connective tissue. Mast cells, as a resident of connective tissue, have aroused scientist’s attention since early 80’s. It was observed that acupoints have a higher concentration of mast cells than that of non-point location in control areas . The same was true for acupoints along the low impedance meridian lines . Mechanically, by causing local microtrauma, acupuncture stimulated the mast cells in-situ to degranulate and release their mediators. These active mediators, including histamines, caused many local changes such as phagocytosis. The released mediators also cause vasodilation, increased capillary permeability, and triggered a cascade reaction. In the present work, we asked whether mast cell degranulation plays a role in acupuncture-induced analgesia. This work focused on Zusanli (ST36) because Zusanli (ST36) has a high concentration of mast cells and stimulation of this acupoint could induce significsnt analgesia . Tail flick latency was used as the measurement of pain threshold , and the change rate of it reflected the effects of acupuncture analgesia of rats. Besides, numbers and degranulation rate of mast cells in specimens (skin and tissue) from ST36 were statistically calculated within initialized group of rats. (put in the methods). MATERIALS AND METHODS Animals and Groups. A total of forty male and female laboratory-born Sprague-Dawley rats bought from Shanghai Experimental Animal Centre of Chinese Academy of Science were used in this experiment, each with normal tail flick latency and weighed 200±20g. Animals were housed in cages at controlled temperature (20 ± 2°C) with a 14/10 hour light/dark cycle. Food and water were made available optionally. All animals were handled with care to prevent infection and minimize stress. Rats were randomly divided into the following groups: six of normal pain threshold served as the control (A); others were divided into Acupuncture ST36(B1) and sham point Nearby-ST36(B2), Injection of DSCG(C1) and NaCl(C2), Acupuncture after injection of DSCG(D1) and NaCl(D2), and Acupuncture opposite side of injection of DSCG(D3). Nociceptive Testing Model. Flick latencies to a radiant heat stimulus 23 were assessed for each rat using a Model 33T Tail Stimulator Analgesia Meter (IITC Life Sciences, Woodland Hills, CA). The room temperature was kept at 22°C±1 °C.A light beam (40% intensity) was focused on a 2×2 mm region of skin. Flick latencies were obtained by shining the heat light source on the tip of the tail until it flicked. Temperature Change in the tip of the tail was recorded as the flick latency. A 20-s cut-off maximum was programmed into the timer to prevent tissue damage. Rats were habituated to the testing apparatus for 10 min prior to testing on each test day. After the habituation period, the average of 3 times of basic flick latencies was measured for each animal. Then, the changed latencies tested every 5min divided by basic ones are taken as the changed ratio. Acupuncture Stimulation. Manual acupuncture stimulation was performed for 30 minutes with twirling and lift-thrust manipulation every 5min. Sterilized stainless steel acupuncture needles of 0.3 mm diameter were inserted into the loci of Zusanli (ST36) on left feet, located 24 at 5 mm lateral and distal to the anterior tubercle of the tibia. Sham point Nearby-ST36 , which is 0.3mm away from ST36 (in direction to the fibula), was adopted as control point. To quantify the manual acupuncture stimulation, a self-made acupuncture needle real-time forced monitored was used to detect the wave shape of needle manipulation at ST36 on rats. During the acupuncture stimulation, animals were kept in plastic holders with their tails and hind legs protruding out. Animals in the control and injection groups were similarly kept in holders without acupuncture stimulation in order to rule out variations due to stress caused by the restraint. Inhibition of Mast Cells. An inhibitor of degranulation function has been applied to mast cells in Zusanli (ST36), in order to determine the role of mast cells in acupuncture analgesia. Twenty μl of 5% DSCG was injected into ST36 by microliter syringe. The amount and concentration were decided referring to the method of conversion between experiment animals and human. The same amount of 9% NaCl was used as control solution. Specimen Preparations and Microscopic Examination. Specimens at Zusanli (ST36) with a volume of 0.33 cubic millimeters were collected after decapitation under narcotism of the experimental and control animals. Continuous paraffin slices of 4μm in thickness were made from corresponding groups. Some specimens with the same volume were collected from the non-acupoints, which was 0.3mm away from ST36. The slides were then stained with two methods : Toluidine Blue and Neutral Red. Photomicrographs of the slides were taken at 400 with a 40 objective and investigated using light microscopy. The population of mast cells per microscopic view (×200) were taken count of. Only cells with visible nuclei were counted. And the ratios of degranulation and normal mast cells were calculated. To observe the degranulation inside mast cell more clearly, transmission electron microscope (TEM) slice was made for acupuncture and control group. The collection of specimen was the same as paraffin slice. Photomicrographs of the TEM slides were taken. Statistical Analysis. Statistical analyses were performed to compare the tail flick latencies of experimental and control animals. Influence of disodium chromoglycate on the role of mast cells in acupuncture analgesia was estimated as changes in pain threshold 0 pt P P R Δ = ,Where P0 represented the average baseline flick latencies average of 3 times and △P represented the increase or decrease of tail flick latencies. The quantities and degranulation ratios of mast cells per unit area in specimens from all groups were calculated. Differences between groups were considered significant if p < 0.05. All data are represented as mean ± SD. Tests performed to assess significance of differences in the estimates were two-tailed with no adjustments for multiple comparisons. The test statistic used to determine statistical significance of differences between two percents was b 2 a b a S S X X Z + + = , where Xa and Xb are the two percents being compared, and Sa and Sb are the standard errors of those percents. The critical value used for two-sided tests at 0.05 level of significance was 1.96. RESULTS The Criterion of De-qi Sensation. (Fig. 1, Fig.2). Based on previous studies , a self-made acupuncture needle real-time forced monitor was used to detect the wave shape of needle manipulation at ST36 on rats. The mean force of 240-280mN in lifting and thrusting and moment of 10-15mN·mm in twirling may be regarded as a regular range and parameter of De-qi. According to this method, each manual needle insertion in the following experiment could be basically identified to achieve de-qi sensation. The Effect of Acupoint Specificity (Fig.3). During 30min acupuncture at acupoint ST36, pain threshold increased significantly during the first 20min of acupuncture. In contrast, acupuncture in the groups of sham point Nearby-ST36 and blank control did not induce analgesia (How about Nearby-ST36? See Fig 3 Legend). Influence of DSGG injection on the pain thresholds (Fig.4). Same dose of DSCG (20%) and NaCl (0.9%) were merely injected to ST36 acupoint as well as the blank control point. After injection, there was a slight increase in pain thresholds at first. Twenty minutes later, there were no significant differences between the injections with two kinds of solutions. Influence of DSCG on the role of mast cells in acupuncture analgesia. (Fig.5, Table.1) Since the injection temperately increased pain thresholds (Fig. 4), acupuncture was made 20min after the injection. Figure 5 summarized the results of acupuncture effect on various groups. When DSCG was injected to Zusanli (ST36) to inhibit the mast cells, acupuncture analgesia was attenuated. However, injection of NaCl solution at the opposite side did not significantly affect the acupuncture effect ( Table 1). Light photomicrographs of stained mast cells in specimens at Zusanli (ST36) and non-acupoint under different statuse