Book Review: Barbara Dancygier,The Language of Stories: A Cognitive Approach
Shang Biwu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0963947013498011
2013-01-01
Language and Literature
Abstract:Recent years have seen an explosion of interest in the cognitive approach to literature, the results of which are a number of scholarly works contributing to this rapidly developing field. Among these are Stockwell’s Cognitive Poetics: An Introduction, Gavins and Steen’s Cognitive Poetics in Practice, Herman’s Narrative Theory and Cognitive Sciences, Hogan’s The Mind and its Stories: Narrative Universals and Human Emotion, Palmer’s Fictional Minds, Lisa Zunshine’s Why We Read Fiction: Theory of Mind and the Novel, Brône & Vandaele’s Cognitive Poetics: Goals, Gains and Gaps, Boyd’s On the Origin of Stories: Evolution, Cognition, and Fiction, Aldama’s Toward a Cognitive Theory of Narrative Acts, and many more. The most recent addition to this list of works is Barbara Dancygier’s monograph The Language of Stories: A Cognitive Approach. Largely drawing on blending theory and construction grammar, this book attempts to address such questions as: How do we read stories? How do they engage our minds and create meanings? Are they a mental construct, a linguistic one, or a cultural one? And what is the difference between real stories and fictional ones? Meaning construction is Dancygier’s central concern. She postulates that ‘if a text means something to someone, there have to be linguistic phenomena that make that possible.’ (p. 1) From her point of view, meaning construction refers to ‘the processes which yield meanings of language expressions based on the frames evoked, constructional meaning patterns, and, among others, blending. Meaning construction in this sense relies on the specific word and grammar choices’ (p. 5). To pursue this line of thought, the book is dedicated to unpacking the complicated correlations between language choices and the meanings prompted thereby. The book begins by contextualizing the discussion of relations between language, cognition and meaning making. In doing so, the first chapter is engaged in such issues as literary analysis and linguistic analysis, literature, language and human nature, literary texts and communication, and narrative and grounding. Of particular interest is its argument that understanding narratives relies on a three-step process: ‘emergence, construction, and negotiation of meaning through specific language choices’ (p. 5). Chapter 2 examines the relations between blending, narrative spaces, and the emergent story. Apart from differentiating mental space from narrative space and the concept of the textual world, the book relies heavily on the theory of conceptual integration to 498011 LAL22410.1177/0963947013498011Language and LiteratureBook Reviews 2013