Multimessenger Search for Sources of Gravitational Waves and High-Energy Neutrinos: Results for Initial LIGO-Virgo and IceCube
The IceCube Collaboration,The LIGO Scientific Collaboration,The Virgo Collaboration,M. G. Aartsen,M. Ackermann,J. Adams,J. A. Aguilar,M. Ahlers,M. Ahrens,D. Altmann,T. Anderson,C. Arguelles,T. C. Arlen,J. Auffenberg,X. Bai,S. W. Barwick,V. Baum,J. J. Beatty,J. Becker Tjus,K. -H. Becker,S. BenZvi,P. Berghaus,D. Berley,E. Bernardini,A. Bernhard,D. Z. Besson,G. Binder,D. Bindig,M. Bissok,E. Blaufuss,J. Blumenthal,D. J. Boersma,C. Bohm,F. Bos,D. Bose,S. Böser,O. Botner,L. Brayeur,H. -P. Bretz,A. M. Brown,J. Casey,M. Casier,D. Chirkin,A. Christov,B. Christy,K. Clark,L. Classen,F. Clevermann,S. Coenders,D. F. Cowen,A. H. Cruz Silva,M. Danninger,J. Daughhetee,J. C. Davis,M. Day,J. P. A. M. de André,C. De Clercq,S. De Ridder,P. Desiati,K. D. de Vries,M. de With,T. DeYoung,J. C. Díaz-Vélez,M. Dunkman,R. Eagan,B. Eberhardt,B. Eichmann,J. Eisch,S. Euler,P. A. Evenson,O. Fadiran,A. R. Fazely,A. Fedynitch,J. Feintzeig,J. Felde,T. Feusels,K. Filimonov,C. Finley,T. Fischer-Wasels,S. Flis,A. Franckowiak,K. Frantzen,T. Fuchs,T. K. Gaisser,J. Gallagher,L. Gerhardt,D. Gier,L. Gladstone,T. Glüsenkamp,A. Goldschmidt,G. Golup,J. G. Gonzalez,J. A. Goodman,D. Góra,D. T. Grandmont,D. Grant,P. Gretskov,J. C. Groh,A. Groß,C. Ha,C. Haack,A. Haj Ismail,P. Hallen,A. Hallgren,F. Halzen,K. Hanson,D. Hebecker,D. Heereman,D. Heinen,K. Helbing,R. Hellauer,D. Hellwig,S. Hickford,G. C. Hill,K. D. Hoffman,R. Hoffmann,A. Homeier,K. Hoshina,F. Huang,W. Huelsnitz,P. O. Hulth,K. Hultqvist,S. Hussain,A. Ishihara,E. Jacobi,J. Jacobsen,K. Jagielski,G. S. Japaridze,K. Jero,O. Jlelati,M. Jurkovic,B. Kaminsky,A. Kappes,T. Karg,A. Karle,M. Kauer,J. L. Kelley,A. Kheirandish,J. Kiryluk,J. Kläs,S. R. Klein,J. -H. Köhne,G. Kohnen,H. Kolanoski,A. Koob,L. Köpke,C. Kopper,S. Kopper,D. J. Koskinen,M. Kowalski,A. Kriesten,K. Krings,G. Kroll,M. Kroll,J. Kunnen,N. Kurahashi,T. Kuwabara,M. Labare,D. T. Larsen,M. J. Larson,M. Lesiak-Bzdak,M. Leuermann,J. Leute,J. Lünemann,O. Macías,J. Madsen,G. Maggi,R. Maruyama,K. Mase,H. S. Matis,F. McNally,K. Meagher,M. Medici,A. Meli,T. Meures,S. Miarecki,E. Middell,E. Middlemas,N. Milke,J. Miller,L. Mohrmann,T. Montaruli,R. Morse,R. Nahnhauer,U. Naumann,H. Niederhausen,S. C. Nowicki,D. R. Nygren,A. Obertacke,S. Odrowski,A. Olivas,A. Omairat,A. O'Murchadha,T. Palczewski,L. Paul,Ö. Penek,J. A. Pepper,C. Pérez de los Heros,C. Pfendner,D. Pieloth,E. Pinat,J. Posselt,P. B. Price,G. T. Przybylski,J. Pütz,M. Quinnan,L. Rädel,M. Rameez,K. Rawlins,P. Redl,I. Rees,R. Reimann,E. Resconi,W. Rhode,M. Richman,B. Riedel,S. Robertson,J. P. Rodrigues,M. Rongen,C. Rott,T. Ruhe,B. Ruzybayev,D. Ryckbosch,S. M. Saba,H. -G. Sander,J. Sandroos,M. Santander,S. Sarkar,K. Schatto,F. Scheriau,T. Schmidt,M. Schmitz,S. Schoenen,S. Schöneberg,A. Schönwald,A. Schukraft,L. Schulte,O. Schulz,D. Seckel,Y. Sestayo,S. Seunarine,R. Shanidze,C. Sheremata,M. W. E. Smith,D. Soldin,G. M. Spiczak,C. Spiering,M. Stamatikos,T. Stanev,N. A. Stanisha,A. Stasik,T. Stezelberger,R. G. Stokstad,A. Stößl,E. A. Strahler,R. Ström,N. L. Strotjohann,G. W. Sullivan,H. Taavola,I. Taboada,A. Tamburro,A. Tepe,S. Ter-Antonyan,A. Terliuk,G. Tešić,S. Tilav,P. A. Toale,M. N. Tobin,D. Tosi,M. Tselengidou,E. Unger,M. Usner,S. Vallecorsa,N. van Eijndhoven,J. Vandenbroucke,J. van Santen,M. Vehring,M. Voge,M. Vraeghe,C. Walck,M. Wallraff,Ch. Weaver,M. Wellons,C. Wendt,S. Westerhoff,B. J. Whelan,N. Whitehorn,C. Wichary,K. Wiebe,C. H. Wiebusch,D. R. Williams,H. Wissing,M. Wolf,T. R. Wood,K. Woschnagg,D. L. Xu,X. W. Xu,J. P. Yanez,G. Yodh,S. Yoshida,P. Zarzhitsky,J. Ziemann,S. Zierke,M. Zoll. The LIGO Scientific Collaboration,the Virgo Collaboration,:,J. Aasi,B. P. Abbott,R. Abbott,T. Abbott,M. R. Abernathy,F. Acernese,K. Ackley,C. Adams,T. Adams,P. Addesso,R. X. Adhikari,C. Affeldt,M. Agathos,N. Aggarwal,O. D. Aguiar,P. Ajith,A. Alemic,B. Allen,A. Allocca,D. Amariutei,M. Andersen,R. A. Anderson,S. B. Anderson,W. G. Anderson,K. Arai,M. C. Araya,C. Arceneaux,J. S. Areeda,S. Ast,S. M. Aston,P. Astone,P. Aufmuth,H. Augustus,C. Aulbert,B. E. Aylott,S. Babak,P. T. Baker,G. Ballardin,S. W. Ballmer,J. C. Barayoga,M. Barbet,B. C. Barish,D. Barker,F. Barone,B. Barr,L. Barsotti,M. Barsuglia,M. A. Barton,I. Bartos,R. Bassiri,A. Basti,J. C. Batch,J. Bauchrowitz,Th. S. Bauer,C. Baune,V. Bavigadda,B. Behnke,M. Bejger,M. G. Beker,C. Belczynski,A. S. Bell,C. Bell,G. Bergmann,D. Bersanetti,A. Bertolini,J. Betzwieser,I. A. Bilenko,G. Billingsley,J. Birch,S. Biscans,M. Bitossi,C. Biwer,M. A. Bizouard,E. Black,J. K. Blackburn,L. Blackburn,D. Blair,S. Bloemen,O. Bock,T. P. Bodiya,M. Boer,G. Bogaert,C. Bogan,P. Bojtos,C. Bond,F. Bondu,L. Bonelli,R. Bonnand,R. Bork,M. Born,V. Boschi,Sukanta Bose,L. Bosi,C. Bradaschia,P. R. Brady,V. B. Braginsky,M. Branchesi,J. E. Brau,T. Briant,D. O. Bridges,A. Brillet,M. Brinkmann,V. Brisson,A. F. Brooks,D. A. Brown,D. D. Brown,F. Brückner,S. Buchman,A. Buikema,T. Bulik,H. J. Bulten,A. Buonanno,R. Burman,D. Buskulic,C. Buy,L. Cadonati,G. Cagnoli,J. Calderón Bustillo,E. Calloni,J. B. Camp,P. Campsie,K. C. Cannon,B. Canuel,J. Cao,C. D. Capano,F. Carbognani,L. Carbone,S. Caride,G. Castaldi,S. Caudill,M. Cavaglià,F. Cavalier,R. Cavalieri,C. Celerier,G. Cella,C. Cepeda,E. Cesarini,R. Chakraborty,T. Chalermsongsak,S. J. Chamberlin,S. Chao,P. Charlton,E. Chassande-Mottin,X. Chen,Y. Chen,A. Chincarini,A. Chiummo,H. S. Cho,M. Cho,J. H. Chow,N. Christensen,Q. Chu,S. S. Y. Chua,S. Chung,G. Ciani,F. Clara,D. E. Clark,J. A. Clark,J. H. Clayton,F. Cleva,E. Coccia,P. -F. Cohadon,A. Colla,C. Collette,M. Colombini,L. Cominsky,M. Constancio,A. Conte,D. Cook,T. R. Corbitt,N. Cornish,A. Corsi,C. A. Costa,M. W. Coughlin,J. -P. Coulon,S. Countryman,P. Couvares,D. M. Coward,M. J. Cowart,D. C. Coyne,R. Coyne,K. Craig,J. D. E. Creighton,R. P. Croce,S. G. Crowder,A. Cumming,L. Cunningham,E. Cuoco,C. Cutler,K. Dahl,T. Dal Canton,M. Damjanic,S. L. Danilishin,S. D'Antonio,K. Danzmann,V. Dattilo,H. Daveloza,M. Davier,G. S. Davies,E. J. Daw,R. Day,T. Dayanga,D. DeBra,G. Debreczeni,J. Degallaix,S. Deléglise,W. Del Pozzo,W. Del Pozzo,T. Denker,T. Dent,H. Dereli,V. Dergachev,R. De Rosa,R. T. DeRosa,R. DeSalvo,S. Dhurandhar,M. Díaz,J. Dickson,L. Di Fiore,A. Di Lieto,I. Di Palma,A. Di Virgilio,V. Dolique,E. Dominguez,F. Donovan,K. L. Dooley,S. Doravari,R. Douglas,T. P. Downes,M. Drago,R. W. P. Drever,J. C. Driggers,Z. Du,M. Ducrot,S. Dwyer,T. Eberle,T. Edo,M. Edwards,A. Effler,H. -B. Eggenstein,P. Ehrens,J. Eichholz,S. S. Eikenberry,G. Endrőczi,R. Essick,T. Etzel,M. Evans,T. Evans,M. Factourovich,V. Fafone,S. Fairhurst,X. Fan,Q. Fang,S. Farinon,B. Farr,W. M. Farr,M. Favata,D. Fazi,H. Fehrmann,M. M. Fejer,D. Feldbaum,F. Feroz,I. Ferrante,E. C. Ferreira,F. Ferrini,F. Fidecaro,L. S. Finn,I. Fiori,R. P. Fisher,R. Flaminio,J. -D. Fournier,S. Franco,S. Frasca,F. Frasconi,M. Frede,Z. Frei,A. Freise,R. Frey,T. T. Fricke,P. Fritschel,V. V. Frolov,P. Fulda,M. Fyffe,J. R. Gair,L. Gammaitoni,S. Gaonkar,F. Garufi,N. Gehrels,G. Gemme,B. Gendre,E. Genin,A. Gennai,S. Ghosh,J. A. Giaime,K. D. Giardina,A. Giazotto,J. Gleason,E. Goetz,R. Goetz,L. Gondan,G. González,N. Gordon,M. L. Gorodetsky,S. Gossan,S. Goßler,R. Gouaty,C. Gräf,P. B. Graff,M. Granata,A. Grant,S. Gras,C. Gray,R. J. S. Greenhalgh,A. M. Gretarsson,P. Groot,H. Grote,K. Grover,S. Grunewald,G. M. Guidi,C. J. Guido,K. Gushwa,E. K. Gustafson,R. Gustafson,J. Ha,E. D. Hall,W. Hamilton,D. Hammer,G. Hammond,M. Hanke,J. Hanks,C. Hanna,M. D. Hannam,J. Hanson,J. Harms,G. M. Harry,I. W. Harry,E. D. Harstad,M. Hart,M. T. Hartman,C. -J. Haster,K. Haughian,A. Heidmann,M. Heintze,H. Heitmann,P. Hello,G. Hemming,M. Hendry,I. S. Heng,A. W. Heptonstall,M. Heurs,M. Hewitson,S. Hild,D. Hoak,K. A. Hodge,D. Hofman,K. Holt,P. Hopkins,T. Horrom,D. Hoske,D. J. Hosken,J. Hough,E. J. Howell,Y. Hu,E. Huerta,B. Hughey,S. Husa,S. H. Huttner,M. Huynh,T. Huynh-Dinh,A. Idrisy,D. R. Ingram,R. Inta,G. Islas,T. Isogai,A. Ivanov,B. R. Iyer,K. Izumi,M. Jacobson,H. Jang,P. Jaranowski,Y. Ji,F. Jiménez-Forteza,W. W. Johnson,D. I. Jones,R. Jones,R. J. G. Jonker,L. Ju,Haris K,P. Kalmus,V. Kalogera,S. Kandhasamy,G. Kang,J. B. Kanner,J. Karlen,M. Kasprzack,E. Katsavounidis,W. Katzman,H. Kaufer,S. Kaufer,T. Kaur,K. Kawabe,F. Kawazoe,F. Kéfélian,G. M. Keiser,D. Keitel,D. B. Kelley,W. Kells,D. G. Keppel,A. Khalaidovski,F. Y. Khalili,E. A. Khazanov,C. Kim,K. Kim,N. G. Kim,N. Kim,S. Kim,Y. -M. Kim,E. J. King,P. J. King,D. L. Kinzel,J. S. Kissel,S. Klimenko,J. Kline,S. Koehlenbeck,K. Kokeyama,V. Kondrashov,S. Koranda,W. Z. Korth,I. Kowalska,D. B. Kozak,V. Kringel,A. Królak,G. Kuehn,A. Kumar,D. Nanda Kumar,P. Kumar,R. Kumar,L. Kuo,A. Kutynia,P. K. Lam,M. Landry,B. Lantz,S. Larson,P. D. Lasky,A. Lazzarini,C. Lazzaro,P. Leaci,S. Leavey,E. O. Lebigot,C. H. Lee,H. K. Lee,H. M. Lee,J. Lee,P. J. Lee,M. Leonardi,J. R. Leong,A. Le Roux,N. Leroy,N. Letendre,Y. Levin,B. Levine,J. Lewis,T. G. F. Li,K. Libbrecht,A. Libson,A. C. Lin,T. B. Littenberg,N. A. Lockerbie,V. Lockett,D. Lodhia,K. Loew,J. Logue,A. L. Lombardi,E. Lopez,M. Lorenzini,V. Loriette,M. Lormand,G. Losurdo,J. Lough,M. J. Lubinski,H. Lück,A. P. Lundgren,Y. Ma,E. P. Macdonald,T. MacDonald,B. Machenschalk,M. MacInnis,D. M. Macleod,F. Magaña-Sandoval,R. Magee,M. Mageswaran,C. Maglione,K. Mailand,E. Majorana,I. Maksimovic,V. Malvezzi,N. Man,G. M. Manca,I. Mandel,V. Mandic,V. Mangano,N. M. Mangini,G. Mansell,M. Mantovani,F. Marchesoni,F. Marion,S. Márka,Z. Márka,A. Markosyan,E. Maros,J. Marque,F. Martelli,I. W. Martin,R. M. Martin,L. Martinelli,D. Martynov,J. N. Marx,K. Mason,A. Masserot,T. J. Massinger,F. Matichard,L. Matone,N. Mavalvala,G. May,N. Mazumder,G. Mazzolo,R. McCarthy,D. E. McClelland,S. C. McGuire,G. McIntyre,J. McIver,K. McLin,D. Meacher,G. D. Meadors,M. Mehmet,J. Meidam,M. Meinders,A. Melatos,G. Mendell,R. A. Mercer,S. Meshkov,C. Messenger,M. S. Meyer,P. M. Meyers,F. Mezzani,H. Miao,C. Michel,E. E. Mikhailov,L. Milano,J. Miller,Y. Minenkov,C. M. F. Mingarelli,C. Mishra,S. Mitra,V. P. Mitrofanov,G. Mitselmakher,R. Mittleman,B. Moe,A. Moggi,M. Mohan,S. R. P. Mohapatra,D. Moraru,G. Moreno,N. Morgado,S. R. Morriss,K. Mossavi,B. Mours,C. M. Mow-Lowry,C. L. Mueller,G. Mueller,S. Mukherjee,A. Mullavey,J. Munch,D. Murphy,P. G. Murray,A. Mytidis,M. F. Nagy,I. Nardecchia,L. Naticchioni,R. K. Nayak,V. Necula,G. Nelemans,I. Neri,M. Neri,G. Newton,T. Nguyen,A. B. Nielsen,S. Nissanke,A. H. Nitz,F. Nocera,D. Nolting,M. E. N. Normandin,L. K. Nuttall,E. Ochsner,J. O'Dell,E. Oelker,J. J. Oh,S. H. Oh,F. Ohme,S. Omar,P. Oppermann,R. Oram,B. O'Reilly,W. Ortega,R. O'Shaughnessy,C. Osthelder,D. J. Ottaway,R. S. Ottens,H. Overmier,B. J. Owen,C. Padilla,A. Pai,O. Palashov,C. Palomba,H. Pan,Y. Pan,C. Pankow,F. Paoletti,M. A. Papa,H. Paris,A. Pasqualetti,R. Passaquieti,D. Passuello,M. Pedraza,A. Pele,S. Penn,A. Perreca,M. Phelps,M. Pichot,M. Pickenpack,F. Piergiovanni,V. Pierro,L. Pinard,I. M. Pinto,M. Pitkin,J. Poeld,R. Poggiani,A. Poteomkin,J. Powell,J. Prasad,V. Predoi,S. Premachandra,T. Prestegard,L. R. Price,M. Prijatelj,S. Privitera,G. A. Prodi,L. Prokhorov,O. Puncken,M. Punturo,P. Puppo,M. Pürrer,J. Qin,V. Quetschke,E. Quintero,R. Quitzow-James,F. J. Raab,D. S. Rabeling,I. Rácz,H. Radkins,P. Raffai,S. Raja,G. Rajalakshmi,M. Rakhmanov,C. Ramet,K. Ramirez,P. Rapagnani,V. Raymond,M. Razzano,V. Re,S. Recchia,C. M. Reed,T. Regimbau,S. Reid,D. H. Reitze,O. Reula,E. Rhoades,F. Ricci,R. Riesen,K. Riles,N. A. Robertson,F. Robinet,A. Rocchi,S. B. Roddy,L. Rolland,J. G. Rollins,R. Romano,G. Romanov,J. H. Romie,D. Rosińska,S. Rowan,A. Rüdiger,P. Ruggi,K. Ryan,F. Salemi,L. Sammut,V. Sandberg,J. R. Sanders,S. Sankar,V. Sannibale,I. Santiago-Prieto,E. Saracco,B. Sassolas,B. S. Sathyaprakash,P. R. Saulson,R. Savage,J. Scheuer,R. Schilling,M. Schilman,P. Schmidt,R. Schnabel,R. M. S. Schofield,E. Schreiber,D. Schuette,B. F. Schutz,J. Scott,S. M. Scott,D. Sellers,A. S. Sengupta,D. Sentenac,V. Sequino,A. Sergeev,D. A. Shaddock,S. Shah,M. S. Shahriar,M. Shaltev,Z. Shao,B. Shapiro,P. Shawhan,D. H. Shoemaker,T. L. Sidery,K. Siellez,X. Siemens,D. Sigg,D. Simakov,A. Singer,L. Singer,R. Singh,A. M. Sintes,B. J. J. Slagmolen,J. Slutsky,J. R. Smith,M. R. Smith,R. J. E. Smith,N. D. Smith-Lefebvre,E. J. Son,B. Sorazu,T. Souradeep,A. Staley,J. Stebbins,M. Steinke,J. Steinlechner,S. Steinlechner,B. C. Stephens,S. Steplewski,S. Stevenson,R. Stone,D. Stops,K. A. Strain,N. Straniero,S. Strigin,R. Sturani,A. L. Stuver,T. Z. Summerscales,S. Susmithan,P. J. Sutton,B. Swinkels,M. Tacca,D. Talukder,D. B. Tanner,J. Tao,S. P. Tarabrin,R. Taylor,G. Tellez,M. P. Thirugnanasambandam,M. Thomas,P. Thomas,K. A. Thorne,K. S. Thorne,E. Thrane,V. Tiwari,K. V. Tokmakov,C. Tomlinson,M. Tonelli,C. V. Torres,C. I. Torrie,F. Travasso,G. Traylor,M. Tse,D. Tshilumba,H. Tuennermann,D. Ugolini,C. S. Unnikrishnan,A. L. Urban,S. A. Usman,H. Vahlbruch,G. Vajente,G. Valdes,M. Vallisneri,M. van Beuzekom,J. F. J. van den Brand,C. Van Den Broeck,M. V. van der Sluys,J. van Heijningen,A. A. van Veggel,S. Vass,M. Vasúth,R. Vaulin,A. Vecchio,G. Vedovato,J. Veitch,P. J. Veitch,K. Venkateswara,D. Verkindt,F. Vetrano,A. Viceré,R. Vincent-Finley,J. -Y. Vinet,S. Vitale,T. Vo,H. Vocca,C. Vorvick,W. D. Vousden,S. P. Vyachanin,A. R. Wade,L. Wade,M. Wade,M. Walker,L. Wallace,S. Walsh,M. Wang,X. Wang,R. L. Ward,M. Was,B. Weaver,L. -W. Wei,M. Weinert,A. J. Weinstein,R. Weiss,T. Welborn,L. Wen,P. Wessels,M. West,T. Westphal,K. Wette,J. T. Whelan,D. J. White,B. F. Whiting,K. Wiesner,C. Wilkinson,K. Williams,L. Williams,R. Williams,T. D. Williams,A. R. Williamson,J. L. Willis,B. Willke,M. Wimmer,W. Winkler,C. C. Wipf,A. G. Wiseman,H. Wittel,G. Woan,N. Wolovick,J. Worden,Y. Wu,J. Yablon,I. Yakushin,W. Yam,H. Yamamoto,C. C. Yancey,H. Yang,S. Yoshida,M. Yvert,A. Zadrożny,M. Zanolin,J. -P. Zendri,Fan Zhang,L. Zhang,C. Zhao,H. Zhu,X. J. Zhu,M. E. Zucker,S. Zuraw,J. Zweizig,IceCube Collaboration,LIGO Scientific Collaboration,Virgo Collaboration. IceCube Collaboration,K.-H. Becker,H.-P. Bretz,et al. (1090 additional authors not shown)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1407.1042
2014-07-03
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
Abstract:We report the results of a multimessenger search for coincident signals from the LIGO and Virgo gravitational-wave observatories and the partially completed IceCube high-energy neutrino detector, including periods of joint operation between 2007-2010. These include parts of the 2005-2007 run and the 2009-2010 run for LIGO-Virgo, and IceCube's observation periods with 22, 59 and 79 strings. We find no significant coincident events, and use the search results to derive upper limits on the rate of joint sources for a range of source emission parameters. For the optimistic assumption of gravitational-wave emission energy of $10^{-2}$\,M$_\odot$c$^2$ at $\sim 150$\,Hz with $\sim 60$\,ms duration, and high-energy neutrino emission of $10^{51}$\,erg comparable to the isotropic gamma-ray energy of gamma-ray bursts, we limit the source rate below $1.6 \times 10^{-2}$\,Mpc$^{-3}$yr$^{-1}$. We also examine how combining information from gravitational waves and neutrinos will aid discovery in the advanced gravitational-wave detector era.