Abstract:Many scholars attach importance to the dissension of dual real estate transaction in different countries. The solution to this problem involves some different fields in civil law. Owing to the not-quite-the-same basic principles adopted by the different countries in civil law, some inevasible diversity exists between the law theory structures that are taken in dissension solution. However, this diversity is just because different countries want to maintain the coherence in its own law theory system. Instead of hypostatic difference, there exists certain commonness between different countries when they take the essential value judgment in settling the dissension. Altogether, the core value judgment in this problem is that law should be expected in what area to respect and to protect the free competition right of the second buyer.According to the German law, the French law and the Japanese law, and the experience of comparative law, generally the efficacy of the Second Contract which is a breach of morality can’t be protected by the law. And to judge whether the behavior of the second buyer is a breach of morality becomes the key to the settlement of the dissension. The judgment of breach of morality is not only affected by the registration system, but also closely related to the actual possession of estate. Notwithstanding, the provisional registration system for the transfer of real property established in the Property Law of the People’s Republic of China has some precautionary effect, but it can’t prevent the dual real estate transaction completely. Therefore, in judicial practice, we should set up a balancing of interest system which is based on the provisional registration for the transfer of real property to settle the dissension.Superficially, this paper is just talking about the value judgment in dual real estate transaction dissension. In fact, however, the core judgment of this problem is closely connected with the meaning of estate public announcement system. Consequently, the value judgment system discussed in the paper can also be used in other types of dissension in the transfer of title.After the adoption of the Property Law of China, some correlative theory structure has been established. The next research emphases should be to explain and apply the articles of the Property Law correctly. And the establishment of balancing of interest system is more important to the application of the Law.

Boundary Line of Interests Balancing

Logic in Weighing System Interests

On the Judgement of Public Interests of Administrative Requisition

Towards a simple mathematical model for the legal concept of balancing of interests

Balance and Imbalance in Human Rights Law

On the Legal Interests

On the Legal Concept of Public Interests

Balance of Interests in Reconciliation System of Antitrust Law Enforcement

The Relative Independence of Social and Public Interests

Study on Interests Balancing Mechanism of Stakeholder

Balancing Personal Data Protection with Other Human Rights and Public Interest: Between Theory and Practice

Harmony of Interests on Condition of Interest Differentiation--A Perspective on "Represent the Basic Interests of the Overwhelming Majority of the People"

Interest Weighing for the Reform of Collective Construction Land Circulation: An Analytical Framework

General Balance Functions in the Theory of Interest

Examining “interests” in the Context of the Rule by Law and Construction of Harmonious Society

Studys on Interest Compensation Mechanisms for the Coordination of the Water Resource Utilization

Weighing and balancing of principles in cases with rule paradoxes

Balance of Interests in the Mechanism of Protection of Industrial Property Rights

The Equity of the Conflict of Interest in Dual Real Estate Transaction

Limits of Justice: Between Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint

The Logic of the Limitation of Public Interest on Basic Rights