The Influence of Different Types of Performance Appraisal on Employee Appraisal Reaction:A Study Based on Appraisal Purposes

Wen Peng,Liao Jianqiao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2010.02.016
2010-01-01
Abstract:Previous research related to Performance Appraisal(PA) paid more attention to measurement tool than ratee reaction.However,PA always occurs in social environment which determines the important role of social reaction in PA process.At present,we still know less about the influence of PA on employee social reaction.Thus,this study aims to examine the influence of different types of PA on employee appraisal reaction.As PA has two main purposes----developmental and evaluative----and they always co-exist in organizational management practice,according to high and low matching method of the two purposes,PA was separated into four types including transaction,commitment,cooperation and laissez-faire in our study.After analyzing the meanings of the four types of PA,empirical dada was collected to examine their impact on employee PA reaction,which includes direct reaction such as PA satisfaction and perceived justice of PA and indirect reaction such as knowledge sharing behavior,turnover intention,and task performance.The survey from 308 employees in the city of Wuhan indicates that the four types of PA significantly influence employee reaction.Taken as a whole,employee perceived justice of performance appraisal and task performance were highest when cooperation appraisal was adopted and PA satisfaction lowest under laissezfaire appraisal.The next ANCOVA MANCOVA also testifies the above results.Additionally,our study results also suggestes the most employees(37.7%) in the present study sample reported that cooperative PA was adopted in their organizations,followed by laissez-faire,commitment,and transaction PA.Employees in foreign capital enterprises reported less laissez-faire PA than employees in state-owned enterprises and private enterprises did.In contrast,employees in foreign capital enterprises reported more commitment PA than employees of the other enterprises did.These results indicate that foreign enterprises focus more on implementing PA and establishing long-term social exchange relationship with their employees.Finally,discussion of the present study results are given.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?