Abstract:Objective. The Bayesian model plays an important role in diagnostic test evaluation in the absence of the gold standard, which used the external prior distribution of a parameter combined with sample data to yield the posterior distribution of the test characteristics. However, the correlation between diagnostic tests has always been a problem that cannot be ignored in the Bayesian model evaluation. This study will discuss how different Bayesian model, correlation scenarios, and prior distribution affect the outcome. Methods. The data analyzed in this study was gathered during studies of patients presenting to the Nanjing Chest Hospital with suspected tuberculosis. The diagnostic character of T-SPOT.Tb and KD38 tuberculosis antibody test were evaluated in different Bayesian model, and discharge diagnosis as a gold standard was used to verify the model results in the end. Result. The comparison of four models under the conditional independence situation found that Bayesian probabilistic constraint model was consistent with the Conditional Covariance Bayesian model. The results were mainly affected by prior information. The sensitivity and specificity of the two tests in Conditional Covariance Bayesian model in prior constraint situation were considerably higher than the Bayesian probabilistic constraint model in prior constraint situation. The results of the four models under the conditional dependence situation were similar to the conditional independence situation; pD was also negative with no prior constraint situation in both model Bayesian probabilistic constraint model and Conditional Covariance Bayesian model. The Deviance Information Criterion of Bayesian probabilistic constraint model was close to model Conditional Covariance Bayesian model, but pD of Conditional Covariance Bayesian model in Prior constraint situation (pD=2.40) was higher than the Bayesian probabilistic constraint model in Prior constraint situation (pD=1.66). Conclusion. The result of Conditional Covariance Bayesian model in prior constraint with conditional independence situation was closest to the result of gold standard evaluation in our data. Both of the two Bayesian methods are the feasible way for the evaluation of diagnostic test in the absence of the gold standard diagnostic. Prior source, priority number, and conditional dependencies should be considered in the method selection, the accuracy of posterior estimation mainly depending on the prior distribution.

Establishment and Application of Bayesian Conditional Dependence Model for Evaluation of Diagnostic Tests in the Absence of Gold Standard

Comparison of Two Bayesian Methods in Evaluation of the Absence of the Gold Standard Diagnostic Tests.

The Methods and SAS Program to Estimation of Bayesian Prior Parameters of Diagnostic Test in the Absence of the Gold Standard

Estimation of the Sensitivity and Specificity of Assays for Screening Antibodies to HIV: A Comparison Between the Frequentist and Bayesian Approaches

Bayesian Updating and Sequential Testing: Overcoming Inferential Limitations of Screening Tests

Three Diagnostic Tests Assessment in the Absence of Gold Standard

A1362 Bayesian Estimation on Diagnostic Performance of Dementia Screening Tests in the Absence of a Gold Standard

A Two-Stage Bayesian Method for Estimating Accuracy and Disease Prevalence for Two Dependent Dichotomous Screening Tests when the Status of Individuals Who Are Negative on Both Tests is Unverified

Bayesian Evaluation of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus Antibody Screening Strategy of Duplicate Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay in Xuzhou Blood Center, China

Accuracy Evaluation of Diagnostic Test Without Gold Standard Based on Latent Class Method

Evaluation of 30 Commercial Assays for the Detection of Antibodies to Hiv in China Using Classical and Bayesian Statistics

Application of Bayesian Bivariate Hierarchical Model in Meta Analysis of Diagnostic Test

0-1 Distributed Bayesian Test and Application in the Medical Examination

Joint meta-analysis of two diagnostic tests accounting for within and between studies dependence

Estimates of sensitivity and specificity of serological tests for SARS-CoV-2 specific antibodies using a Bayesian latent class model approach

Evaluation of Two Tests for Detecting Schistosoma Japonicum Infection Using a Bayesian Approach

The evaluation method for assessing a diagnostic test of HIV: some noteworthy issues.

Comparison the Correcting for Verification Bias in Studies of a Diagnostic Test

Bayesian Analysis of Complex Mutations in HBV, HCV, and HIV Studies

Bayesian Inference for Generalized Linear Mixed Models with Predictors Subject to Detection Limits: an Approach That Leverages Information from Auxiliary Variables.

A Bayesian method for synthesizing multiple diagnostic outcomes of COVID-19 tests