Abstract:Sorption is a key process to understand the environmental fate of pollutants on soils, conduct preliminary risk assessments and fill information gaps. Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationships (QSAR) and Pedotransfer Functions (PTF) are the most common approaches used in the literature to predict sorption. Both models use different outcomes and follow different simplification strategies to represent data. However, the impact of those differences on the interpretation of sorption trends and application of models for regulatory purposes is not well understood. We conducted a systematic review to contextualize the requirements for developing, interpreting, and applying predictive models in different scenarios of environmental concern by using pesticides as a globally relevant organic pollutant model. We found disagreements between predictive model assumptions and empirical information from the literature that affect their reliability and suitability. Additionally, we found that both model procedures are complementary and can improve each other by combining the data treatment and statistical validation applied in PTF and QSAR models, respectively. Our results expose how relevant the methodological and environmental conditions and the sources of variability studied experimentally are to connect the representational value of data with the applicability domain of predictive models for scientific and regulatory decisions. We propose a set of empirical correlations to unify the sorption mechanisms within the dataset with the selection of a proper kind of model, solving apparent incompatibilities between both models, and between model assumptions and empirical knowledge. The application of our proposal should improve the representativity and quality of predictive models by adding explicit conditions and requirements for data treatment, selection of outcomes and predictor variables (molecular descriptors versus soil properties, or both), and an expanded applicability domain for pollutant-soil interactions in specific environmental conditions, helping the decision-making process in regard to both scientific and regulatory concerns (in the following, the scientific and regulatory dimensions).

QSAR Analysis of Soil Sorption Coefficients for Polar Organic Chemicals: Substituted Anilines and Phenols

Soil Sorption Coefficient Prediction of Substituted Phenylureas by Artificial Neural Networks

Estimation Of Soil Sorption Coefficients Of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons By Quantum Chemical Descriptors

Prediction of n-octanol/water partition coefficients and soil sorption coefficients for polychlorinated organic compounds (PCOCs) using quantum chemical parameters

In Silico Model for Predicting Soil Organic Carbon Normalized Sorption Coefficient (K(OC)) of Organic Chemicals.

QSPR Study of N‐octanol/water Partition Coefficient of Some Aromatic Compounds Using Support Vector Regression

QSPR Studies on the Octanol/water Partition Coefficient (IgK(Ow)) of Substituted Anilines with 2D and 3D Methods

Qspr/Qsar Study On Solubility And Acute Toxicity To Photobacterium Phosphoreum Of Substituted Anilines

QSPR Studies on the Octanol/water Partition Coefficient (lgk Ow ) of Substituted Anilines with 2D and 3D Methods

Sorption behaviors of aromatic anions on loess soil modified with cationic surfactant.

QSPR modeling of adsorption coefficient Koc of alkyl(1-phenylsulfonyl) cycloalkane-carboxylates on soil and sediments using MLSER model and ab initio

Estimation of soil organic carbon normalized sorption coefficient (Koc) using least squares-support vector machine

Using ami hamiltonian in prediction of benzaldehydes sorption on soil

Linear and non-linear relationships between soil sorption and hydrophobicity: model, validation and influencing factors.

High-accuracy QSAR models of narcosis toxicities of phenols based on various data partition, descriptor selection and modelling methods

Analysis method of information flow through the artificial neural network of chlorophenol QSAR model

[Research on QSPR for N-Octanol-water Partition Coefficients of Organic Compounds Based on Genetic Algorithms-Support Vector Machine and Genetic Algorithms-Radial Basis Function Neural Networks].

An application of artificial neural networks and molecular topological index for the QSBR of phenolic organics

Sorption of Polar and Nonpolar Aromatic Compounds to Four Surface Soils of Eastern China.

Understanding requirements, limitations and applicability of QSAR and PTF models for predicting sorption of pollutants on soils: a systematic review

Mechanistic studies of congener-specific adsorption and bioaccumulation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and phthalates in soil by novel QSARs.