Abstract:Conventional time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) is based on a closed-shell Kohn-Sham (KS) singlet ground state with the adiabatic approximation, using either linear response (KS-LR) or the Tamm-Dancoff approximation (KS-TDA); these methods can only directly predict singly excited states. This deficiency can be overcome by using a triplet state as the reference in the KS-TDA approximation and "exciting" the singlet by a spin flip (SF) from the triplet; this is the method suggested by Krylov and co-workers, and we abbreviate this procedure as SF-KS-TDA. SF-KS-TDA can be applied either with the original collinear kernel of Krylov and co-workers or with a noncollinear kernel, as suggested by Wang and Ziegler. The SF-KS-TDA method does bring some new practical difficulties into play, but it can at least formally model doubly excited states and states with double-excitation character, so it might be more useful than conventional TDDFT (both KS-LR and KS-TDA) for photochemistry if these additional difficulties can be surmounted and if it is accurate with existing approximate exchange-correlation functionals. In the present work, we carried out calculations specifically designed to understand better the accuracy and limitations of the conventional TDDFT and SF-KS-TDA methods; we did this by studying closed-shell atoms and closed-shell monatomic cations because they provide a simple but challenging testing ground for what we might expect in studying the photochemistry of molecules with closed-shell ground states. To test their accuracy, we applied conventional KS-LR and KS-TDA and 18 versions of SF-KS-TDA (nine collinear and nine noncollinear) to the same set of vertical excitation energies (including both Rydberg and valence excitations) of Be, B(+), Ne, Na(+), Mg, and Al(+). We did this for 10 exchange-correlation functionals of various types, both local and nonlocal. We found that the GVWN5 and M06 functionals with nonlocal kernels in spin-flip calculations can both have accuracy competitive to CASPT2 calculations. When the results were averaged over all 36 test energy differences, seven (GVWN5, M06, B3PW91, LRC-ωPBE, LRC-ωPBEh, PBE, and M06-2X) of the 10 studied density functionals had smaller mean unsigned errors for noncollinear calculations than the mean unsigned error of the best functional (M06-2X) for either conventional KS-TDA or KS-LR.

Can Range-Separated and Hybrid Dft Functionals Predict Low-Lying Excitations? A Tookad Case Study

Predictive power of long-range corrected functionals on the spectroscopic properties of tetrapyrrole derivatives for photodynamic therapy

Comparative DFT Studies of Optoelectronic Properties of MTPA Derivatives

Exploring an Adequate DFT Functional to Accurately Describe the Singlet Excited State Properties in HLCT Materials: A Benchmark Study

Theoretical Predication for Transition Energies of Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Molecules

Toward an Accurate Description of Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence: Equal Importance of Electronic and Geometric Factors

Assessing the accuracy of TD-DFT excited-state geometries through optimal tuning with GW energy levels

Quasiparticle spectra from a non-empirical optimally-tuned range-separated hybrid density functional

Why Does the Optimal Tuning Method of the Range Separation Parameter of a Long-Range Corrected Density Functional Fail in Intramolecular Charge Transfer Excitation Calculations?

Benchmarking the performance of DFT functionals for absorption and fluorescence spectra of EGFR inhibitor AG-1478 using TD-DFT

Organic Emitters Showing Excited-States Energy Inversion: An Assessment of MC-PDFT and Correlation Energy Functionals Beyond TD-DFT

Optimal-tuning of range-separated density functionals to describe the optical and photophysical properties of rhodamine B dimers

The eXact integral simplified time-dependent density functional theory (XsTD-DFT)

Beyond Explored Functionals: A Computational Journey of Two-Photon Absorption

Theoretical investigation on functional group modulation of UV-Vis absorption profiles of triphenylamine derivatives

$Δ$ADAPT-VQE: Toward Accurate Calculation of Excitation Energies on Quantum Computers for BODIPY Molecules With Application in Photodynamic Therapy

Assessing and applying DFT approaches for geometries and UV–Vis absorption spectra of tetragonal iron(II) complexes

Photophysical properties of Pt(II) and Pd(II) complexes for two-photon photodynamic therapy: A computational investigation

Broadband X-Ray Absorption Spectra from Time-Dependent Kohn-Sham Calculations

Exploring non-covalent interactions in excited states: beyond aromatic excimer models

Testing Noncollinear Spin-Flip, Collinear Spin-Flip, and Conventional Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory for Predicting Electronic Excitation Energies of Closed-Shell Atoms