Abstract:Abstract. Plant activity in semi-arid ecosystems is largely controlled by pulses of precipitation, making them particularly vulnerable to increased aridity that is expected with climate change. Simple bucket-model hydrology schemes in land surface models (LSMs) have had limited ability in accurately capturing semi-arid water stores and fluxes. Recent, more complex, LSM hydrology models have not been widely evaluated against semi-arid ecosystem in situ data. We hypothesize that the failure of older LSM versions to represent evapotranspiration, ET, in arid lands is because simple bucket models do not capture realistic fluctuations in upper-layer soil moisture. We therefore predict that including a discretized soil hydrology scheme based on a mechanistic description of moisture diffusion will result in an improvement in model ET when compared to data because the temporal variability of upper-layer soil moisture content better corresponds to that of precipitation inputs. To test this prediction, we compared ORCHIDEE LSM simulations from (1) a simple conceptual 2-layer bucket scheme with fixed hydraulic parameters and (2) an 11-layer discretized mechanistic scheme of moisture diffusion in unsaturated soil based on Richards equations, against daily and monthly soil moisture and ET observations, together with data-derived estimates of transpiration / evapotranspiration, T∕ET, ratios, from six semi-arid grass, shrub, and forest sites in the south-western USA. The 11-layer scheme also has modified calculations of surface runoff, water limitation, and resistance to bare soil evaporation, E, to be compatible with the more complex hydrology configuration. To diagnose remaining discrepancies in the 11-layer model, we tested two further configurations: (i) the addition of a term that captures bare soil evaporation resistance to dry soil; and (ii) reduced bare soil fractional vegetation cover. We found that the more mechanistic 11-layer model results in a better representation of the daily and monthly ET observations. We show that, as predicted, this is because of improved simulation of soil moisture in the upper layers of soil (top ∼ 10 cm). Some discrepancies between observed and modelled soil moisture and ET may allow us to prioritize future model development and the collection of additional data. Biases in winter and spring soil moisture at the forest sites could be explained by inaccurate soil moisture data during periods of soil freezing and/or underestimated snow forcing data. Although ET is generally well captured by the 11-layer model, modelled T∕ET ratios were generally lower than estimated values across all sites, particularly during the monsoon season. Adding a soil resistance term generally decreased simulated bare soil evaporation, E, and increased soil moisture content, thus increasing transpiration, T, and reducing the negative bias between modelled and estimated monsoon T∕ET ratios. This negative bias could also be accounted for at the low-elevation sites by decreasing the model bare soil fraction, thus increasing the amount of transpiring leaf area. However, adding the bare soil resistance term and decreasing the bare soil fraction both degraded the model fit to ET observations. Furthermore, remaining discrepancies in the timing of the transition from minimum T∕ET ratios during the hot, dry May–June period to high values at the start of the monsoon in July–August may also point towards incorrect modelling of leaf phenology and vegetation growth in response to monsoon rains. We conclude that a discretized soil hydrology scheme and associated developments improve estimates of ET by allowing the modelled upper-layer soil moisture to more closely match the pulse precipitation dynamics of these semi-arid ecosystems; however, the partitioning of T from E is not solved by this modification alone.

Climate, canopy conductance and leaf area development controls on evapotranspiration in a boreal coniferous forest over a 10-year period: A united model assessment

Seasonality of Leaf Area Index and Photosynthetic Capacity for Better Estimation of Carbon and Water Fluxes in Evergreen Conifer Forests

Improvement of transpiration estimation based on a two-leaf conductance-photosynthesis model with seasonal parameters for temperate deciduous forests

Improved Modeling of Canopy Transpiration for Temperate Forests by Incorporating a LAI-based Dynamic Parametrization Scheme of Stomatal Slope

Separating meteorological condition and soil moisture controls on the variation in stand evapotranspiration of a larch plantation during three hydrological years

Rainfall Manipulation Experiments As Simulated by Terrestrial Biosphere Models: Where Do We Stand?

A General Predictive Model for Estimating Monthly Ecosystem Evapotranspiration

A Steady-State Approximation Approach to Simulate Seasonal Leaf Dynamics of Deciduous Broadleaf Forests Via Climate Variables

Developing a parsimonious canopy model (PCM v1.0) to predict forest gross primary productivity and leaf area index of deciduous broad-leaved forest

Long‐term trend and interannual variation in evapotranspiration of a young temperate Douglas‐fir stand over 2002–2022 reveals the impacts of climate change

The Dynamics of Transpiration to Evapotranspiration Ratio under Wet and Dry Canopy Conditions in a Humid Boreal Forest

[Erotic delusions of reference toward the family physician].

Measurement and modelling of bryophyte evaporation in a boreal forest chronosequence

The estimation and partitioning of evapotranspiration in a coniferous plantation in subtropical China

Drought Influences the Accuracy of Simulated Ecosystem Fluxes: A Model-Data Meta-Analysis for Mediterranean Oak Woodlands

Simulation and scaling of temporal variation in gross primary production for coniferous and deciduous temperate forests

Improved Regional Scale Dynamic Evapotranspiration Estimation Under Changing Vegetation and Climate

A Model for Estimating Transpiration from Remotely Sensed Solar-Induced Chlorophyll Fluorescence

A spatially explicit hydro-ecological modeling framework (BEPS-TerrainLab V2.0): Model description and test in a boreal ecosystem in Eastern North America

Testing water fluxes and storage from two hydrology configurations within the ORCHIDEE land surface model across US semi-arid sites

A canopy conductance model with temporal physiological and environmental factors