Network Image Index of Scenic Spots:Based on a Content Analysis of 205 Travel Web Sites
SHEN Tiyan,HUANG Ning,PENG Changjiang,XU Haitao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-5006.2015.06.008
2015-01-01
Abstract:Tourism is a strategic industry in China's economy, and the vigorous development of that industry has led to competition among tourist destinations. Researchers have increasingly found that a destination's image is a key factor in attracting tourists. The rapid development of the Internet has meant that it has become an important tool for obtaining tourist information and making travel decisions. Scenic spots constitute one of the most important types of travel destination. Thus, a study of the network image of scenic spots offers a novel means of assessing research on scenic spots and destination image.Recently, destination image on the Internet has drawn academic attention. Previous studies have adopted three main research directions. First, some researchers have studied a destination's overall image and its outstanding feature. Second, researchers have compared several images of different destinations. Third, some studies have evaluated different methods of content analysis. Hitherto, most studies have been limited to qualitative descriptions. No systematic conceptual framework or quantifiable, operable index evaluation system has been formulated. Studies have always examined several destinations as the object of their research, and we have not found any single study that has investigated a large number of destinations in one country.We established the System of Scenic Spots Network Image Index that consists of four levels. The first level comprises the network image of scenic spots; the second level consists of cognitive and affective images; the third level is made up of tourism resources, infrastructure, services, and general management; and the fourth level consists of 13 indicators.We used 205 Web sites to examine the image of 153 national 5A scenic spots in China. These consisted of 35 official Web sites of tourism bureaus(including those of Hong Kong, Macau, and Taiwan), 156 official Web sites of scenic spots, and 14 travel channel Web sites. We collected the data from the Internet using Locoy Spider software. With Locoy Spider, we were able to set different rules according to the different structures of the Web sites. We used a My SQL relational database to store the data from the Internet. We undertook text analysis to establish index files and word segments using Solr. We employed Excel for a numerical analysis of the information. Finally, according to the System of Scenic Spots Network Image Index, we calculated the ranking of 153 national 5A scenic spots.Our results showed that the ranking of the network image of the scenic spots differed from the ranking using the number of tourist reception. The scenic spots that occupied the top 20 in terms of ranking by the number of tourist reception did not have a good network image. We also found four areas of differences among the 153 scenic spots:(1) different scores in terms of network image;(2) the locations of the scenic spots with good network image;(3) the cognitive and affective images of the scenic spots; and(4) the types of network image score structure of the 153 scenic spots.