Accuracy and repeatability analysis of Quantitative Cervical Vertebral Maturation (QCVM) for adolescents with normal occlusion

Luyue LI,Jiuxiang LIN,Lili CHEN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13591/j.cnki.kqyx.2013.04.024

2013-01-01

Abstract:Objective To investigate the accuracy and repeatability of Quantitative Cervical Vertebral Maturation(QCVM) for adolescents with normal occlusion.Methods According to the Fishman Skeletal Maturity Indicators(SMI),which was believed to be the golden standard for skeletal maturation evaluation,120 adolescents who visited Department of Orthodontics were selected and divided into four groups.Each group consisted of 30 people.The patients were grouped in double-blind trials and the maturation of cervical vertebrae was estimated by senior experts(SE) and postgraduate students(PS).The consistency of QCVM and SMI was analyzed and the repeatability and accuracy of QCVM were tested.Results As for the accuracy,skeletal maturation evaluation by QCVM by SE and PS was consistent with that by Fishman Skeletal Maturity Indicators(SMI).There was no statistical difference(P>0.05).As for the repeatability,there were no significant differences in both SE and PS group(P>0.05).SE was relatively better than PS,but the differences did not achieve statistical significance.Conclusions As for the application of QCVM,both SE and PS are good in accuracy and repeatability.QCVM is simple,convenient and quick,and can provide more objective and reliable basis for diagnosis and treatment in Orthodontics.Meanwhile it avoids extra radiation exposure for the patients.