Evaluation of the clinical effect of electro-acupuncture aversion therapy of alcohol-dependence
Jin Min,Li Jing,Yang Yan-chun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1673-8225.2006.47.014
2006-01-01
Abstract:AIM: To evaluate the effect of aversion therapy with electro-acupuncture of alcohol dependence. METHODS: Thirty-five male inpatients were randomly selected from the Center for Psychological Health, Huaxi Hospital of Sichuan University between April and July 2006. All enrolled subjects, who had no contraindications of aversion therapy with electro-acupuncture, met CCMD-3 diagnostic criteria for alcohol dependence and voluntarily participated in the experiment. The average age of patients was (41.4±8.2) years, and the average drinking time was (21.3±8.0) years. On an average, patients drank 350-1200 mL daily (50-60 mLL of alcohol). Patients were randomized into aversion therapy with electro-acupuncture group (aversion therapy group, n=20) and the control group (n=15), and there was no significant difference in age, sex, race and drinking between the two groups. Hamilton Anxiety Scale (HAMA) was adopted to evaluate the anxiety of patients (the score ranged from zero to 4 points with 5 grades. Zero as no syndrome, 1 point as slight, 2 points as moderate, 3 points as heavy and 4 points as severe). Patients' drinking conditions were evaluated by self-made alcohol-dependence scale (Including 4 items: thinking of drinking, sighting of alcohol, smelling of alcohol and other events. Each item was scaled as 0-7 points: Zero as none, 7 as experienced the highest dependence with a total score of 28 points.) Patients in both groups underwent physiological detoxification treatment in the first week of hospitalization, including benzodiazepines and supportive treatments. Patients were evaluated by self-made alcohol-dependence scale and HAMA and received psychological treatment in group from the second week. Patients in the aversion therapy group received one course of aversion treatment by electro-acupuncture at the same time: Han' s acupoint nerve stimulator was adopted. The electrode was placed on the forearm with the current gradually increased from weak to strong, a quarter of which was taken as the basic current while the patient could not bear, and it was regulated in the treatment according to the patients' reaction. Drinking only was considered as the target behavior. Patients were supplied with the alcohol they usually drank (the same alcohol of the same concentration with the same glass) at the beginning of the treatment, and they were required to image a drinking situation. Electron stimulation was given immediately at patients' alcohol-dependence came at the current intensity that patients felt unpleasant and accompanied with corresponding physiological response. The stimulation lasted for 10 minutes each time with a 5-minute rest, and then repeated once. Verbal suggestion was given in the treatment to increase the aversion. Electro-acupuncture treatment was given once a day and 10 times as one course. The alcohol-dependence and HAMA score were compared between the two groups after the treatment. RESULTS: A total of 35 patients were involved in the analysis of results. ① There were no significant differences in alcohol-dependence scale and HAMA at the second week of hospitalization between the two groups. ② The scores of alcohol-dependence scale and HAMA were decreased significantly in both groups after treatment than those before treatment, and the scores of alcohol-dependence scale and HAMA in aversion therapy group after the treatment was lower than those in the control group Score of alcohol-dependence before treatment: 19.75±1.86,20.27±2.46. Score of HAMA before treatment: 17.90±4.05,18.60±4.21. Score of alcohol-dependence after the treatment:1.45±1.28,4.27±3.03. Score of HAMA after the treatment: 2.45±2.46,6.33±4.37,P < 0.001,P < 0.005 . ③ In the follow-up of 2 months post-discharge, 4 patients in the aversion therapy group re-drank with the percent of 20.0%, while 5 patients in the control group re-drank with the percent of 33.3%, and there was no remarkable difference between the two group in the percent. CONCLUSION: Aversion therapy with electro-acupuncture can effectively resolve the drinking with a lower percent of re-drink. Ideal psychological therapy of alcohol-dependence is aversion therapy with electro-acupuncture based on other treatments.