Abstract:Long-term climate records of soil moisture are of increased importance to climate researchers. In this study, we aim to evaluate the quality of three different fusion approaches that combine soil moisture retrieval from multiple satellite sensors. The arrival of L-band missions has led to an increased focus on the integration of L-band-based soil moisture retrievals in climate records, emphasizing the need to improve our understanding based on its added value within a multi-sensor framework. The three evaluated approaches were developed on 10-year passive microwave data (2003–2013) from two different satellite sensors, i.e., SMOS (2010–2013) and AMSR-E (2003–2011), and are based on a neural network (NN), regressions (REG), and the Land Parameter Retrieval Model (LPRM). The ability of the different approaches to best match AMSR-E and SMOS in their overlapping period was tested using an inter-comparison exercise between the SMOS and AMSR-E datasets, while the skill of the individual soil moisture products, based on anomalies, was evaluated using two verification techniques; first, a data assimilation technique that links precipitation information to the quality of soil moisture (expressed as the Rvalue), and secondly the triple collocation analysis (TCA). ASCAT soil moisture was included in the skill evaluation, representing the active microwave-based counterpart of soil moisture retrievals. Besides a semi-global analysis, explicit focus was placed on two regions that have strong land–atmosphere coupling, the Sahel (SA) and the central Great Plains (CGP) of North America. The NN approach gives the highest correlation coefficient between SMOS and AMSR-E, closely followed by LPRM and REG, while the absolute error is approximately the same for all three approaches. The Rvalue and TCA show the strength of using different satellite sources and the impact of different merging approaches on the skill to correctly capture soil moisture anomalies. The highest performance is found for AMSR-E over sparse vegetation, for SMOS over moderate vegetation, and for ASCAT over dense vegetation cover. While the two SMOS datasets (L3 and LPRM) show a similar performance, the three AMSR-E datasets do not. The good performance for AMSR-E over spare vegetation is mainly perceived for AMSR-E LPRM, benefiting from the physically based model, while AMSR-E NN shows improved skill in densely vegetated areas, making optimal use of the SMOS L3 training dataset. AMSR-E REG has a reasonable performance over sparsely vegetated areas; however, it quickly loses skill with increasing vegetation density. The findings over the SA and CGP mainly reflect results that are found in earlier sections. This confirms that historical soil moisture datasets based on a combination of these sources are a valuable source of information for climate research.

Optimal Exploitation of AMSR-E Signals for Improving Soil Moisture Estimation Through Land Data Assimilation

Land Surface Model Calibration Through Microwave Data Assimilation for Improving Soil Moisture Simulations

Validation of a Dual-Pass Microwave Land Data Assimilation System for Estimating Surface Soil Moisture in Semiarid Regions

Auto-Calibration System Developed To Assimilate Amsr-E Data Into A Land Surface Model For Estimating Soil Moisture And The Surface Energy Budget

Retrieving accurate soil moisture over the Tibetan Plateau using multi-source remote sensing data assimilation with simultaneous state and parameter estimations

Improving Surface Soil Moisture Estimation Through Assimilating Satellite Land Surface Temperature with a Linear SM-LST Relationship

Improving Land Surface Soil Moisture and Energy Flux Simulations over the Tibetan Plateau by the Assimilation of the Microwave Remote Sensing Data and the GCM Output into a Land Surface Model

Auto-calibration System Developed to Assimilate AMSR-E Data into a Land Surface Model for Estimating Soil Moisture and the Surface Energy Budget( Coordinated Enhanced Observing Period(CEOP))

Soil Moisture Retrievals By Combining Passive Microwave And Optical Data

Development of a Satellite Land Data Assimilation System Coupled with a Mesoscale Model in the Tibetan Plateau.

A dual-pass variational data assimilation framework for estimating soil moisture profiles from AMSR-E microwave brightness temperature

Improving Soil Moisture Estimation Through a Dual-Cycle Assimilation Strategy

Soil Moisture Estimation over an Arid Environment in Mongolia from Passive Microwave Remote Sensing Based on A Simplified Parameterization Method

The Effect of Three Different Data Fusion Approaches on the Quality of Soil Moisture Retrievals from Multiple Passive Microwave Sensors

Estimation of regional soil moisture by assimilating multi-sensor passive microwave remote sensing observations based on ensemble kalman filter

Bias Correction of Satellite Soil Moisture Through Data Assimilation

An Improved Soil Moisture Retrieval Algorithm Based on the Land Parameter Retrieval Model for Water–Land Mixed Pixels Using AMSR-E Data

Quick Estimation of Parameters for the Land Surface Data Assimilation System and Its Influence Based on the Extended Kalman Filter and Automatic Differentiation

Constraining The Water Imbalance In A Land Data Assimilation System Through A Recursive Assimilation Scheme

Estimation of Surface Soil Moisture with Downscaled Land Surface Temperatures Using a Data Fusion Approach for Heterogeneous Agricultural Land

Simultaneous Estimation of Both Soil Moisture and Model Parameters Using Particle Filtering Method Through the Assimilation of Microwave Signal