Comparative Study on the Operation Efficency in Enterprise Bond Markets and Stock Markets in China——Based on the Analysis of Sharp Ratio and the BDSS Model

YE Zhi-qiang,ZHANG Shun-ming,LIU Shi-bao

IF: 2.034

2010-01-01

Systems Engineering

Abstract:This paper uses the Sharp ratio to estimate both the risk and the profit of the enterprise bond market and the Stock market in China,and the results suggest that: during the stock market rising period,the relationship between the enterprise bond market's Sharp ratio and Stock market's Sharp ratio is indefinite;during the stock market falling period,the enterprise bond market's Sharp ratio is higher than Stock market's Sharp ratio;in a long time,the bond market's Sharp ratio is higher than the Stock market's Sharp ratio.Furthermore,according to the BDSS model,this paper considers the fluid risk of the enterprise bond market and the Stock market,and obtains the results that under any kind of market condition,the enterprise bond market's fluid risk must be smaller than Stock market's fluid risk.Finally this article analyses the sensitivity of the Scaling Factor and gets the robust conclusions.The results of the two models indicate that the enterprise bond market is better than the stock market in China in three aspects of security,profit and fluidity,which can challenges the tranditional views that the enterprise bond market operating is low efficiency.