Abstract:Evaluation of solvation (binding) free energies with implicit solvent models in different dielectric environments for biological simulations as well as high throughput ligand screening remain challenging endeavors. In order to address how well implicit solvent models approximate explicit ones we examined four generalized Born models (GB(Still), GB(HCT), GB(OBC)I, and GB(OBC)II) for determining the dimerization free energy (ΔG(0)) of β-cyclodextrin monomers in 17 implicit solvents with dielectric constants (D) ranging from 5 to 80 and compared the results to previous free energy calculations with explicit solvents ( Zhang et al. J. Phys. Chem. B 2012 , 116 , 12684 - 12693 ). The comparison indicates that neglecting the environmental dependence of Born radii appears acceptable for such calculations involving cyclodextrin and that the GB(Still) and GB(OBC)I models yield a reasonable estimation of ΔG(0), although the details of binding are quite different from explicit solvents. Large discrepancies between implicit and explicit solvent models occur in high-dielectric media with strong hydrogen bond (HB) interruption properties. ΔG(0) with the GB models is shown to correlate strongly to 2(D-1)/(2D+1) (R(2) ∼ 0.90) in line with the Onsager reaction field ( Onsager J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1936 , 58 , 1486 - 1493 ) but to be very sensitive to D (D < 10) as well. Both high-dielectric environments where hydrogen bonds are of interest and low-dielectric media such as protein binding pockets and membrane interiors therefore need to be considered with caution in GB-based calculations. Finally, a literature analysis of Gibbs energy of solvation of small molecules in organic liquids shows that the Onsager relation does not hold for real molecules since the correlation between ΔG(0) and 2(D-1)/(2D+1) is low for most solutes. Interestingly, explicit solvent calculations of the solvation free energy ( Zhang et al. J. Chem. Inf. Model . 2015 , 55 , 1192 - 1201 ) reproduce the weak experimental correlations with 2(D-1)/(2D+1) very well.

Can The Anomalous Aqueous Solubility Of Beta-Cyclodextrin Be Explained By Its Hydration Free Energy Alone?

Theoretical studies on the binding affinities of β -cyclodextrin to small molecules and monosaccharides

Theoretical Studies On The Binding Affinities Of Beta-Cyclodextrin To Small Molecules And Monosaccharides

Steered molecular dynamics simulations of liquid-state hydration processes of α-, β-and γ-cyclodextrins at constant temperature

Molecular Recognition in Different Environments: Β-Cyclodextrin Dimer Formation in Organic Solvents

Molecular Dynamics Study of Conformations of Beta-Cyclodextrin and its Eight Derivatives in Four Different Solvents

Deciphering the mechanism of γ-cyclodextrin's hydrophobic cavity hydration: an integrated experimental and theoretical study

Insight into the Structural Deformations of Beta-Cyclodextrin Caused by Alcohol Cosolvents and Guest Molecules.

Counteracting Influence of 2-hydroxypropyl Substitution and the Presence of Guest on the Shape and Size of β-Cyclodextrin Cavity

Dehydration, Dissolution and Melting of Cyclodextrin Crystals

Β-Cyclodextrin Effect on Micellization of Cetyltrimethyl Ammonium Bromide in Aqueous Solution. Probed by Dual Fluorescence of Sodium P-Dimethylaminobenzoate

Generalized Born and Explicit Solvent Models for Free Energy Calculations in Organic Solvents: Cyclodextrin Dimerization

A microcalorimetric study of ?-cyclodextrin with 3-alkoxyl-2-hydroxypropyl trimethyl ammonium bromides in aqueous solutions

Host–Guest Complexation of β -, γ -Cyclodextrin with Alkyl Trimethyl Ammonium Bromides in Aqueous Solution

Molecular Recognition Studies on Supramolecular Systems (xxiv) - Conformations and Complexation Abilities of Chemically Modified Cyclodextrins in Aqueous Solution

Thermodynamic Insights into the Dynamic Switching of a Cyclodextrin in a Bistable Molecular Shuttle

A study of α-cyclodextrin with a group of cationic gemini surfactants utilizing isothermal titration calorimetry and NMR

Cavity and Hydrogen Bonding Effects of β-Cyclodextrin on the Structures and Photophysics of Amino Acid Derivatives

A Study on Interactions Between Α-Cyclodextrin and a Series of New Kind of Surfactants in Aqueous Solutions by Microcalorimetry

Effect of Β-Cyclodextrin on the Micellization of Cetyltrimethylammonium in Aqueous Solution at High Temperature

Study of host-guest complexation between β-cyclodextrin and 3-alkoxyl-2-hydroxypropyl trimethyl ammonium bromides in aqueous solutions with microcalorimetry