Study of Environmental Performance Index for Eco-industrial Park Development in China
TIAN Jin-ping,LIU Wei,LI Xing,LAI Bin-jie,CHEN Lu-jun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5846/stxb201302270311
2014-01-01
Acta Ecologica Sinica
Abstract:This study establishes the Environmental Performance Index( EPI) for eco-industrial park development in China by applying multi-criteria ranking method. First,an indicator system is established by referring to the Standard for Sectorintegrate Eco-industrial Park. The indicator system includes eight indicators,which are classified into three categories,the indicators of economic development,resource and energy consumption,and pollution discharge. Second, a two-step normalization method is used to transform the original values of different indicators. Third,an equal weight method is applied for aggregation. The EPIs of the 24 national demonstration eco-industrial parks are analyzed and ranked with 2010 as the reference year. We suppose a standard eco-industrial park by referring to the Standard for Sector-integrate Eco-industrial Park. The key factors crucial to EPI are investigated,which include industrial structure,development stage of the ecoindustrial park,and the type of the eco-industrial parks. The industrial structure of the eco-industrial park,moreover,the pillar industries of the park usually play a significant role on the EPI. The development stage of the eco-industrial park is the second key factor for the EPI. The accredited national demonstration eco-industrial parks generally have better EPIs than the eco-industrial parks on trial. The third important factor crucial to the EPI is the type of the industrial park. Overall,the EPI of the eco-industrial parks retrofitted from high-tech industrial development zone is better than those retrofitted from economic and technological development zone. At last,the policy implication based on ranking the EPI of the 24 ecoindustrial parks is discussed. The standard eco-industrial park supposed above,which is designated an EPI of 60,is rankedalong with the 24 eco-industrial parks by comparing the EPI respectively. We find that 23 of the 24 eco-industrial parks have better EPI than that of the standard eco-industrial park. The Standard for Sector-integrate Eco-industrial Park is still at a low level compared with most national high-tech industrial development zones and national economic and technological development zones that have accredited as the national demonstration eco-industrial parks. In addition,some industrial parks that have homed to the industries having intensive energy and water consumption,such as steel,chemical industry,and textile dyeing and finishing,do not achieve the same good EPI as the high-tech industrial development zones or economic and technological development zones. However,they have greatly improved technologies of cleaner production and are devoted to pollution control,and thus should also be encouraged and honored for eco-industrial park development. The management of the eco-industrial parks should be classified carefully according to the categories and stage of development thereof. The indicator system underling the EPI of eco-industrial park in this study is open,and new indicators could be added with the continuously development of eco-industrial park,by the two-step normalization method proposed. The EPI method can be used to quantitatively evaluate the performance of industrial parks and promote the eco-industrial park development in China.